X-Men: 20 Fan-Made Castings Better Than The Real Versions

It almost feels like the world has forgotten about the X-Men. After the poorly received X-Men: Apocalypse and a slew of production issues with the upcoming Dark Phoenix, Xavier's mutants are just not on people's radars like they used to be. Sure, there's a bit of news regarding the almost guaranteed Fox/Disney merger that will bring the X-Men into the MCU, but we still can't be certain of how relevant they will be alongside characters like Captain Marvel, Black Panther, Doctor Strange, and The Incredible Hulk. Still, there are many X-Men fans out there that are praying for the day when their favorite characters are back on the big-screen and stealing Groot and Rocket Racoon's thunder. One of the ways that the X-Men will return to their former glory is if they are re-cast with spectacular actors who can breathe life into them. In the past, many fantastic performers have portrayed the X-Men. But that doesn't mean they were always the best person for the job. At the very least, they were better options out there and still are today.

Fans all over the internet have provided images of some potential casting choices that could truly elevate the characters. This article will delve into some of the best examples that fans have come up with. Maybe the creative minds behind the future X-Men movies will take note of some of these phenomenal performers who could slip into the yellow spandex and save the world. Without further ado, here are 20 X-Men Fan Castings Better Than What We Got.

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

20 Naomie Harris As Storm

Naomie Harris would have been a wonderful choice for Storm. Halle Berry is one of the greatest actors of her generations but she wasn't really given a lot to do in her X-Men films. Additionally, there were some issues with her dialect throughout her films. Sometimes she sounded like she was from Africa and other times like she sounded like she was from the States. And then there's Alexandra Shipp who also hasn't been given all that much to do. But Naomie Harris is a scene-steeler. There's no way that she would let a moment get away from her.

This artist's rendering of Harris as Storm is also pretty incredible. Here she's portrayed as the full-on leader and action hero that she should be seen as.

19 Natalia Dyer As Kitty Pryde

Stranger Things' Natalia Dyer may actually be the ideal Kitty Pryde, aka Shadowcat. First of all, we can see that she would physically portray the role perfectly. She looks almost identical to the character from the comics. Dyer also shows a variety of different emotional angles on her famous Netflix show as well as in the array of independent films. This is important as Kitty Pryde is equal parts soft, kind, and innocent, as she is a ferocious, focused, and a leader.

Ellen Page did a good job as the character, but Dyer just seems like the more natural choice for the role. If they revamp the character, they may want to consider this wonderful young actor.

18 Jon Bernthal As Wolverine

Nobody is saying that anyone could have played Wolverine stronger than Hugh Jackman. But other actors could have played Wolverine better in certain X-Men movies such as X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: Apocalypse. Aside from that, the character is about to be recast making a conversation about his replacement all the more relevant. Besides, it's amazing to see how many great choices fans are coming up with.

Jon Bernthal would be a wonderful replacement for the character. He has shown just how formidable he can be with The Punisher. He almost always comes across as the loner in his movies. The type of guy who accomplishes more on his own but who can join up with others when need be. Therefore, he would be perfect for the role.

17 Alexandra Daddario As Rogue

Ever since she showed up on HBO's first season of True Detective, Alexandra Daddario has taken the world by storm. Fans want to see her in as many projects as possible. Of course, she is easy on the eyes, but she is also the type of actor who is capable of doing both comedy and drama within a single moment. She also has some of the most expressive eyes in Hollywood, which would give her an edge if she ever played Rogue.

Anna Paquin played a wonderful young version of the character. Someone who we could follow into the world of the X-Men. But Daddario matches the comic book version of the character. This is someone older and more experienced. A character who can both intrigue her enemies as well as intimidate them.

16 Kerry Washington As Storm

Storm has always been appealing as a character in part because of her leadership skills. A lot of this has to do with age and experience. Although X-Men: Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix's Alexandra Shipp is a capable performer, someone like Kerry Washington better matches the comic book version of the character. Even though this fan-created her in the image of Halle Berry, one could easily see her slipping into a more current take on the character.

Scandal's Washington constantly shows the balance between heart and ruthlessness that the character of Storm needs. She is not just one or the other. From what we've seen so far, Berry's Storm is mostly kindly and soft while Shipp's version is just an action hero. Washington would find an equilibrium.

15 Charlie Heaton As Quicksilver

Evan Peters stole the show in his action scene in X-Men: Days of Future Past. Even though fans were wary about his casting (as well as his look), they were pleasantly surprised. However, after that, things sort of fizzled out with him. Although his may have more to do with the role that was written for him versus his performances. But one can't help but think that Stranger Things' Charlie Heaton would help alleviate the character.

Heaton can easily play the arrogant bully that the role of Quicksilver needs. But he is also a master at playing the sensitive outsider. This is the type of performance we need to see a young man who is just needing his father's love. Besides, Heaton looks pretty cool as the character.

14 Daniel Craig As Magneto

Sir Ian McKellan was and still is the perfect Magento. There isn't anyone who could have done what he did with the character. It's just too bad that he wasn't given more to do while he was playing him. Michael Fassbender is also a pretty incredible Master of Magnetism. But this fan seems to think that Daniel Craig would have been even better for the job. At the very least, he would make an adequate replacement for when the character is inevitably recast.

Craig is definitely due for a villainous turn. He's already shown that he can play an adequate leader. But his stone-cold eyes are ideal for a ruthless and equally inspiring villain. Like McKellan and Fassbender, Craig can find the nuance and complexity to the highly sympathetic and multi-dimensional villain.

13 Lily Collins As Scarlet Witch

If the world of the X-Men and the world of the Marvel Cinematic Universe are going to remain separate, Lily Collins would be a stellar choice for Wanda Maximoff, aka Scarlett Witch. She is excellent at playing the removed, moody, and independent type. Although the MCU's Elizabeth Olsen can do these things as well, Collins somehow feels more comic-accurate.

This artists' take on the character feels more grounded in reality, which would have made more sense for James Mangold's Logan movie versus something like X-Men: Apocalypse or the MCU. Still, she could slip into any X-Men or Avengers universe if played correctly. The prolific Collins has shown that she can slip into practically any tone, whether it's gritty or not.

12 Hailee Steinfeld As Kitty Pryde

If X-Men filmmakers really wanted to capitalize off of the popularity of Kitty Pryde, they would cast someone who is equally as popular. Enter Oscar-nominated actor, singer, and mega-celebrity, Hailee Steinfeld. Of course, younger fans know her from her music and young adult movies, but the rest of us know her from films like True Grit where she easily went toe-to-toe with talents like Jeff Bridges, Josh Brolin, and Matt Damon. In short, Steinfeld has everything needed to make a character come to life. Match that with the popularity of the character herself and you have a winning combination. It's not that Oscar-nominee Ellen Page doesn't have the ability, but she doesn't quite match the character like Steinfeld would.

11 Keanu Reeves As Wolverine

When it comes to action hero, you don't get much bigger than The Matrix and John Wick star, Keanu Reeves. Wolverine is one of the most physical characters in the X-Men universe, so it makes sense that Reeves would be the one to play him. After all, Reeves loves doing his own stunts.

Nowadays, Reeves is almost as big of a star as he was when the first Matrix first came out. Chances are, he (as well as his original Matrix cast-mates, Carrie-Anne Moss and Laurence Fishburne) are headed for even bigger stardom in the years to come. This means that Reeves would be a smart choice for the MCU and further X-Men films. He may not have the dynamic that Hugh Jackman has, but nobody looks more perfect on a motorcycle than Reeves.

10 Dianna Agron As Polaris

Fans have wanted to see Polaris on the big screen for years. Unfortunately, the closest they got was Fox's Gifted. Although she is portrayed by a capable actor, there isn't really anything that makes the show stand out as it should. Polaris is the youngest daughter of Magento and possesses the same powers that he has. In fact, she becomes a force to be reckoned with. But, at times, she's also slightly naive. This is why Dianna Agron would be great for the role. Gifted's version of the character is just anxiety. It would have been better to go for something utterly different like a posh, ignorant young woman played by Agron. That or someone far more intimidating than what they have on Gifted. Besides, Agron looks pretty rad with green hair.

9 Halston Sage As Emma Frost

There have been tons of reports of Paper Towns and The Orville's Halston Sage being cast as Dazzler in various X-Men movies. At this time, we have no idea whether or not this is true. But what is accurate is that Sage would be stellar as Emma Frost, aka The White Queen. January Jones' version was pretty stiff and uninteresting. This is really too bad since the character in the animated series and the comics is far more important and engaging. But Sage would inject energy and appeal. Not only is Sage a capable actor but she's also inherently likable. This is a must for a character who often walks the line between good and bad. We need to be behind her all the way. Sage would make sure of this.

8 Amber Heard As Polaris

If one were to go with a more intimidating, alluring, and simultaneously perilous version of Polaris, Amber Heard may be the best choice. Although she would bring something very different to the role than someone like Dianna Agron, she would be an improvement upon the version of the character seen in Fox's The Gifted. As we just saw in Aquaman, Heard is supremely capable of pulling off action sequences as well as being an all-around immovable force. But we've also seen other sides of her in her various movies such as The Rum Diaries. She'd make a really good fractious and disaffected version of Polaris whether it was a version of her on T.V. or in the movies.

7 Dylan O'Brien As Ice-Man

Going with a younger, teen-idol for the character of Bobby Drake/Ice-Man would be a smart move going forward. Additionally, he would have been a better choice than Shawn Ashmore in the original X-Men films, even though he was far from bad. Teen Wolf's Dylan O'Brien is a heartthrob that would absolutely put young people in movie theater seats. More importantly, O'Brien is a capable actor who's totally charming. O'Brien's suitable for a big-budget superhero movie like X-Men and could breathe life into a character who is easily a fan favorite. He also looks like a natural as Ice-Man, but here's hoping that the artists come up with better rendering of the actor's face. Here his face looks like a mix between a White Walker and Lord Voldemort.

6 Joel Edgerton As Wolverine

In keeping with the tradition of Wolverine being played by an Australian actor, this fan has created Joel Edgerton as the character. He looks like a natural for the role. He is equal parts intimidating and likable. He's also a bit of a heartthrob. Most importantly, Edgerton is a fantastic actor who has appeared in films like The Great Gatsby, The Gift, Loving, and Midnight Special. Hugh Jackman is absolutely Wolverine in all most every sense, but Edgerton would be nearly as good. In fact, the filmmakers probably could have picked him and Wolverine would have become equally as popular on the big screen. Moving forward, he would make a superb replacement and would catapult this wonderful actor into the mainstream. He also has Wolverine's lifted eyebrow down perfectly.

5 John Boyega As Cyclops

There's nothing that would feel off by making Scott Summers, AKA Cyclops, change race. In fact, he's one of the characters that would have a fairly easy time moving away from his comic-book origins. In short, an update would feel appropriate. There are many capable actors who could play this role, but Star Wars: The Force Awakens' John Boyega would be a good choice. This is not just because he's likable and relatable, but because he can be a strong leader when needed.

In the comics, as well as in the animated shows, Cyclops is a lot more likable than his versions in the movies. James Marsden and Tye Sheridan are adequate, but Boyega would help create a more stand-out character that is fitting with the version in other mediums.

4 Benicio Del Toro As Beast

Kelsey Grammer mastered the intelligent side of Beast in X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men: Days of Future Past. But he didn't quite nail the more animalistic angle of the old-school X-Men character. Then there's Nicholas Hoult, who is totally likable but may have been completely miss-cast as the younger version. Benicio Del Toro would have been one of the most perfect choices for the role. He doesn't have a problem with bringing on the charm and the charisma. Sicario's Del Toro is also one of the more ferocious actors around. Fans would really want to see Beast let loose would be thrilled with this casting. Given how capable Del Toro is, he could also pull-off the brainy side of the character.

3 David Harbour As Sabretooth

David Harbour may have started with small roles on shows like The Newsroom, but after Stranger Things, he's become a mainstay. He's even playing Hellboy in the new movie. Therefore, we now know that he can be a really capable action star. This is something that's needed for the character of Sabretooth. But Sabretooth also has to be engaging and, if possible, likable. Liev Schrieber is one of the best actors out there but he was a letdown as the character. This mostly had to do with the material as well as the make-up. But still, he didn't bring his all. Prior to him, Tyler Mane portrayed the character as nothing but a dumb henchman. Harbour could have added heart and intelligence to a character that is so much more than a mindless baddie.

2 Anne Hathaway As Polaris

We've previously spoken about some of the qualities that Polaris needs that the actor on Fox's Gifted doesn't quite bring to the role. Of all the replacements for the character on this list, Anne Hathaway is the most experienced and arguably the most beloved. The Oscar-winning actor is more than capable of portraying Magneto's daughter as a fierce and engaging leader. In fact, she could easily go toe-to-toe with her father and battle him for the authoritative position. Just by casting her, the filmmakers would also be forcing the character into the spotlight more than ever before. A character like Polaris may need an A-list superstar like Hathaway since some may just see her as a copycat of Magneto.

1 1 Luke Evans As Beast

The Hobbit and The Alienist star Luke Evans would also make total sense in the role of Hank McCoy, AKA Beast. As we can see from this fan's rendering of the character, he could easily be the smart and sophisticated version of Beast. But he's also a proven action star. In short, he has both prominent traits that Kesley Grammer and Nicholas Holt really didn't have. It doesn't hurt that many find Evans to be a bit of a heartthrob. Casting a proven action star, a well-regarded thespian, and a hunk is always a winning combination for big box-office draw. Although, if they did make an X-Men movie with Evans, they might consider shaving off his mustache as it looks a little odd here.


What do you think is the best fan casting that we never got? Let us know in the comments below!

More in Lists