Venom's Bad Reviews Completely Misunderstood Venom

Tom Hardy as Venom with Catwoman and Fantastic Four

Venom's reviews completely misunderstood Venom. The prospect of a movie starring the alien symbiote made famous for attaching itself to Spider-Man has been there since the late 1990s when Sony acquired the Spider-Man movie rights, and after many false starts - including a spinoff of The Amazing Spider-Man - it's finally here. Tom Hardy is Eddie Brock in Reuben Fleischer's Venom movie, which tells a new, Spider-Man-less origin and looks to set up a whole new shared universe of Spidey villains (and possibly link to the MCU).

If you were to go entirely by the reviews, you'd be forgiven for thinking that Venom was not worth all that waiting on behalf fans and the efforts of those involved. The early reactions compared it to early-2000s efforts like Catwoman and Daredevil along with more-recent all-out failures Green Lantern and Fantastic Four, and the full reviews weren't much kinder. The film has a stinging 30% on Rotten Tomatoes (21% amongst Top Critics) and 35 on Metacritic. While both metrics have their issues, those numbers unavoidably show that the approval for Venom amongst critics was not good.

Related: The Most Brutal Reviews Of Venom

However, digging deeper, that appears to be only one side of the story. As we'll see later, general audiences have responded much more positively, and there appears to be a general misunderstanding in those reviews of what Venom is trying to be and how it wants to be viewed. Here's what was missed.

Venom Is Not The Character Most People Think

A lot of opinions regarding Venom center on the bigger picture aspects from its development, mainly the absence of Spider-Man and conversely its attempts to kickstart a new universe apart from the MCU. And while those are definitely topics of discussion, neither is a primary concern in Venom the movie - nor should they be.

Venom is, of course, a Spider-Man villain. Not just that, he's the Spider-Man villain with an origin most linked to Spidey: the symbiote came to Earth as Spider-Man's Secret Wars suit, later trying to corrupt Peter Parker, and became the Venom everybody purports to know when it attached to Peter's professional rival, Eddie Brock. This is the Venom villain story that's been retold across media, from the 1990s cartoon to Spider-Man 3. The problem here is that it all happened in the 1980s; there are three decades worth of Venom stories since that run in The Amazing Spider-Man, and a lot has changed.

That original rivalry ended when Spider-Man saved Anne Weying, forming a deal with Brock and the symbiote: Venom wouldn't kill Spidey as long as Spidey didn't chase him. Venom's solo comic (the Lethal Protector arc on which the movie is loosely based) picked up with Eddie Brock in San Francisco where he was trying to work with Venom to protect innocents, eventually seeing him form a shaky bond with Spider-Man and almost give his life to save an underground city of homeless people. From that point, Venom was firmly in anti-hero territory, fighting with his own morals. His popularity in the 1990s saw him come up against other symbiotes and generally become a major Marvel player in his own right - independent of Spider-Man. Recently, his mythology was vastly deepened by becoming part of the Guardians of the Galaxy.

Read More: Venom Erases Spider-Man To Avoid Marvel Mistakes

Plainly, Venom without Spider-Man or Venom as a line-toeing anti-hero doesn't betray what's in the comics; rather they honor pretty much everything after the overdone story everybody knows. This semi-assumed familiarity with only the very early days leads to a skewed view of the character and subsequent assessment of what he is: that would be like saying Iron Man isn't faithful because it has no Cold War paranoia.

Venom's Reviews Think They're Laughing At Venom (Not With It)

Even if there was a unified view of Venom, that likely wouldn't have done much to get around the fact that many were expecting the movie to fail: from spending most of pre-production as a "they're actually making this?" prospect to weak trailers, Sony never gave cause for much faith. That is, of course, not the reviews - it's the lead-in - but expectations for what Venom was trying to be are incredibly important in the assessment of what is, ultimately, a very weird film.

Tom Hardy goes for broke in Venom, eating cold chicken out of a bin, cooling off in a lobster tank and making out with the symbiote. He's an actor known for his bold acting choices, and Venom has all the makings of a greatest hits. This, along with some other jump-out comedic moments has elicited screens full of laughter. The issue here is that in many of these cases, it feels like it's been taken as laughing at Venom, not with it. All of this (or at least, most of it) is intentionally off-the-wall and humorous. Let's not forget the director is Ruben Fleisher, whose directorial debut's best moment was the sudden death of Bill Murray. It's meant to be crazy and weird. If it brings out a laugh, then it's winning.

Related: Venom Does One Comic Thing So Much Better Than The MCU

This reading of the film seems to correlate almost directly with enjoyment, and the reviews suggest the converse is true. That isn't to say that Venom being knowingly weird makes it a great film. There are still tonal issues within the comedy and its pacing throughout every scene is frantic, and those aspects deservedly invite the comparisons to early 2000s movies. However, the implication that the lobster scene is unintentionally on the same level as Halle Berry pretending to be a cat is a step too far.

Between the premise and the approach, it feels like much of the Venom backlash comes from treating the movie as something it fundamentally isn't. It's a bad serious film in the same way it's a bad cosmic adventure: it isn't trying to be one.

Page 2 of 2: Venom's Reviews Are Part Of A Bigger Problem

1 2
Key Release Dates
  • Venom (2018) release date: Oct 05, 2018
Dragon Ball Super Future Trunks
Dragon Ball Super Shows That The Buu Saga Could Have Been Avoided

More in SR Originals