24Who Got Cremated?
In Season 9, Charlie was revealed to have been blown to smithereens by a train during his honeymoon with Rose. However, in Season 12, this was shown to be a lie and Charlie was actually alive. Charlie had a coffin in the Season 9 premiere, but Alan didn’t have it
opened because it was too awful to look at.
In the finale, Rose mentioned a goat had been cremated instead of Charlie, so the ashes Alan had were actually from the goat. But was this true or was it all made up?