Though there are other spin-off ideas for The Bachelor, nothing will ever match Bachelor In Paradise for the sheer amount of drama, backstabbing, and shocking rose ceremonies.
Though it’s been a while since the last season of the spin-off, another one is just around the corner, And with the huge personalities of the contestants from Peter’s season of The Bachelor, the producers are surely spoilt for choice on who to bring back, but there are a handful of contestants that must return.
Victoria F
There are a lot of reasons why Victoria F. Is the series’ most controversial contestant, and that’s exactly why she’d be perfect for Paradise. Between her dating history, the rumors that have done the rounds through Bachelor Nation, and her problematic personal life, she’d be the perfect villain of the season, and almost like the female version of Blake, who was the villain of last year’s season for similar reasons.
Hannah Ann
Being one of the contestants fans would also love to see come to Big Brother, it’d be great to see Hannah Ann on Paradise not only because it’d be fun to watch her go head to head against Victoria F again, but because she deserves another chance. She proved herself as a great contender in Pilot Pete’s season, and she held her own really well when it was revealed to her what really happened during the proposal.
Natasha P
The best thing about Natasha P is that she was one of the very few women in the running who was completely down to earth and called all the other girls out on their nonsense.
Though there clearly wasn’t a future between her and Peter, Natasha acted somewhat as a moral compass for the audience and she was clearly the most level headed of all the girls, and that’s why she’d be great for Paradise.
Jade M
One of the main reasons people tune in to any one of the many Bachelor shows is for the crazy drama. Well, with Jade M, the drama started before the show even began shooting, as she had only been divorced for 4 months and was being called out by her in-laws online. It had a big affect on her performance on the series too, as she couldn’t get past the first week, but she could fair better on Paradise.
Sydney H
Coming off the heels of one of the most shocking eliminations in the history of The Bachelor, it seemed as if Sydney had a great connection with the pilot and they were getting along swimmingly. However, as she was surrounded by drama, which is something that Pete was strict about staying away from since the very beginning, she was quickly palmed off by the bachelor. But she was interesting enough that Bachelor Nation want to see her in another format.
Madison P
There were a lot of conspiracy theories surrounding the finale of Peter’s season, and Madison was at the center of many of them. Madison had Pete wrapped around her little finger, as he was completely infatuated with her, but she didn’t quite feel the same way and she left before he had the chance to propose. With Madison P seeing a ton of attention after the season has ended, there’s no reason why she shouldn’t try her chances in Paradise.
Mykenna D
Being the subject of a ton of hilarious memes, Mykenna was one of the most entertaining contestants of the show in recent years, whether it was her facial expressions or her overly energetic behaviour.
Mykenna was a fan favorite who would totally shine in Paradise given the chance. Although its doubtful that she would ever return to the bachelor in any form, as she has been publicly very critical of the show since it aired.
Sarah C
Being a nurse and capturing the bachelor’s attention early on, Sarah C seemed like more of a sweetheart than any of the other contestants at first. But after locking horns with Alayah so many times and though she wasn’t necessarily lying, she was certainly hiding the truth. But Sarah honestly had a bad edit in the end, end she was definitely dealt a bad hand, and that’s why she deserves another chance.
Alayah B
The bachelor always needs a puppeteer in the group of contestants, or at least somebody who tries to control the rest of the group, and Alayah B was as manipulative as they come. Not only that, but she had some hilarious lies to boot. There’s no doubt about it that Alayah would stir up a fuss in Paradise, and she’d almost certainly be playing the guys against each other until it all blows up in her face.
Kelsey Weier
Kelsey got off to a rocky start on The Bachelor and it really didn’t seem like she’d last that long, as she was prone to a breakdowns and was at the centre of champagne-gate, one of the biggest controversies of the last season. However, after the first couple of weeks, Kelsey got her act together and it turned out that she was one of most mature and interesting contestants in the show, which is one of the reasons why she is also one of the best choices for the next Bachelorette.