Suspiria Review: Luca Guadagnino's Horror Film is No Mere Remake

Suspiria is an alluring blend of sociopolitical allegory and visceral supernatural horror that yields imperfect, yet all the same fascinating results.

Having transported audiences to rural Italy circa 1983 in last year's Best Picture Oscar-nominated Call Me By Your Name, director Luca Guadagnino returns with Suspiria, a re-imagining of Dario Argento's cult horror film that takes viewers back in time to Germany, 1977 (the year Argento's movie was released). Guadagnino's remake, or "homage" as he calls it, has played at several major festivals over the past couple months and emerged with a reputation for being a genuinely polarizing filmgoing experience. Now that it's making its way into theaters, it's easy to grasp why the movie is so divisive. Suspiria is an alluring blend of sociopolitical allegory and visceral supernatural horror that yields imperfect, yet all the same fascinating results.

Suspiria picks up in the autumn of 1977, as American Susie Bannion (Dakota Johnson) makes her way to Berlin, in the hopes of landing a recently-vacated spot at the world-famous Markos Dance Academy. Despite having no formal training or professional recommendations, Susie manages to impress the company's director, Madame Blanc (Tilda Swinton), with her audition. Before she knows it, Susie is not only rehearsing with the other students, but even gets made the protagonist in the company's upcoming performance piece, Volk.

Dakota Johnson in Suspiria

Meanwhile, a local psychiatrist named Dr. Jozef Klemperer (Swinton as "Lutz Ebersdorf") begins to investigate the disappearance of his patient Patricia Hingle (Chloë Grace Moretz), a former student at Markos Dance Academy who claimed the school was run by witches. As Klemperer learns more and more about Markos, he begins to realize that there's definitely more to the academy than meets the eye. However, not even the highly-educated doctor has any idea of what Blanc and her matrons really are, nor what they are planning to do with Susie.

The 2018 version of Suspiria was written by The Terror season 1 showrunner David Kajganich and, in many ways, compliments his work on that AMC series. Both Guadagnino's film and The Terror weave supernatural horror concepts into a narrative involving real-life history (in Suspiria's case, the social instability that plagued Cold War-era Germany), in an effort to create a thematically richer story. Suspiria ultimately suffers from trying to do too much, even over the course of its pretty substantial runtime (which is divided into six acts and an epilogue). All the same, the film is quite effective in the way it juxtaposes the sinister, yet powerful and independent matriarchy that keeps the Markos Dance Academy running with the self-destructing patriarchal society residing just outside its walls. And like The Terror, Suspiria takes its time unraveling the dark mystery at the heart of its story, before providing a satisfyingly grisly and twisted payoff as its proceedings plunge into madness.

Tilda Swinton in Suspiria

Another thing that Suspiria and The Terror have in common is that they explore body horror, with the former offering a feminine perspective that compliments the latter's masculine approach. Admittedly, Suspiria sustains a foreboding sense of atmosphere for long stretches of its runtime, thanks in no small amount to the beautifully depressing color palette and grainy texture of Call Me By Your Name DP Sayombhu Mukdeeprom's cinematography. However, when the film does get intense, it serves up some of the more genuinely disturbing and sickening body horror imagery brought to the big screen in recent memory (especially during a particularly vicious sequence that's already infamous thanks to its screening at CinemaCon earlier this year). Guadagnino and his creative team further heighten the freakiness by employing stylish edits and splashes of vibrant color during the movie's most surreal moments, along with an unsettling mixture of painfully sharp sound effects, insidious silence, and Thom Yorke's beguiling soundtrack.

Johnson, for her part, once again demonstrates just how engaging she can be when she's not in a Fifty Shades movie, building on her recent turn in Bad Times at the El Royale. Suspiria marks a reunion for not only Swinton and Guadagnino (who have collaborated many times already), but also the pair and Johnson, following their efforts on the 2015 thriller A Bigger Splash (which Kajganich also wrote). The trio are clearly comfortable working together by now and the onscreen chemistry between Swinton's Madame Blanc and Johnson as Susie (who form a provocative yet tender relationship) is all the more palpable for it. Mia Goth does equally strong work in her supporting turn as Sara, a fellow Markos student who was friendly with Patricia, before she forms a pretty intimate bond with Susie. As for Swinton's much-discussed turn as "Lutz Ebersdorf" playing Dr. Klemperer: the character is all the more interesting, knowing that he's portrayed by a woman (to mention nothing of Swinton's, on the whole, quite impressive physical transformation).

"Lutz Ebersdorf" (Tilda Swinton) in Suspiria

A big part of why Suspiria's reception has been so polarizing thus far can be chalked up to Guadagnino's uncompromising vision. The film is overambitious in its thematic scope, resulting in a viewing experience that some will find sluggish and pretentious (and with valid reason), while others find it captivating and admirably dedicated to its slow-burn methods. If there's one thing that most everyone should be able to agree on, it's that Suspiria is a true re-imagining or "homage" and a far cry from Argento's movie (with its bold Technicolor visuals and highly-stylized gory violence). Guadagnino's "remake" comes closest to the Grand Guignol nature of its predecessor during its third act - but even then, it throws a curveball by sprinkling moments of compassion throughout its grandly bloody climax.

It may be too divisive to pick up much traction this awards season, but Suspiria is very much worth checking out if you're a fan of either Guadagnino's previous work and/or are curious to see a radically different take on the cult horror property, flaws and all. Suspiria is clearly a passion project for its director and, if nothing else, will leave filmgoers with plenty to talk about later, from its themes to its craftsmanship (especially, the visual and audial flourishes that Guadagnino brings to the table). The movie is quite content to dance to the peculiar beat of its own drum - whether viewers are onboard or not - so those who are willing are thusly advised to follow Susie's lead and give themselves to the dance.


Suspiria is now playing in select U.S. theaters nationwide. It is 152 minutes long and is rated R for disturbing content involving ritualistic violence, bloody images and graphic nudity, and for some language including sexual references.

Let us know what you thought of the film in the comments section!

Our Rating:

3.5 out of 5 (Very Good)
Key Release Dates
  • Suspiria (2018) release date: Nov 02, 2018
Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoeinx Joker
Joaquin Phoenix Evokes Heath Ledger In New Joker Footage

More in Movie Reviews