When it comes to ultimate villains there is no comparison who the worst of the worst truly is. Lucifer has been blamed for all the bad things that have ever taken place in the world. Any evil act is done in his name and any disparaging thought is said to be him whispering in humanity's ear.
So when it comes to his portrayals on television, which version of him is the most sinister, the most diabolical the most inhumane? When it comes down to the Supernatural version of Lucifer and how Lucifer is portrayed in the show of his own name it is up for debate just truly who is the Lord of Darkness?
Lucifer: Which One Is Better With Children?
The Devil in Lucifer is repulsed by children. He can't even stand to have them touch his skin. When he does speak to Trixie his partner's daughter, he is constantly telling her to do bad things. Almost relishing in the fact she might go through with what he is telling her to. While Lucifer in Supernatural is less standoffish when it comes to children, especially his own. At first, Lucifer wants Jack to look up to him but then is willing to sacrifice him to regain his powers. So this category goes to Supernatural's Lucifer.
Supernatural: Which One Is Less Loyal?
Supernatural's Lucifer is only loyal to himself. He doesn't even try to appear loyal to any one person. When it comes to his relationship with his son Jack, Lucifer tries to win him over with a fatherly bonding experience but doesn't ever let him think that he wouldn't ditch him if it ever benefited his goals. However, the Devil in Lucifer is much more loyal to those he cares about. He might have selfish tendencies from time to time but would take a bullet for those he loves. Supernatural's Lucifer doesn't have a loyal bone in his body.
Lucifer: Which One Is More Conceited?
The Devil in Lucifer is blinded by his own self-image. He believes he is the greatest creation that God has ever made and for not acknowledging his perfection, he hates him for it. As far as his sexual prowess, Lucifer is confused when turned down, believing that no woman could resist his seductive charm.
The Lucifer in Supernatural is also stuck on himself but it isn't his conceited behavior that shows throughout the show but, instead, it is his hatred towards God and humanity that drives him. The Devil in Lucifer is more conceited.
Supernatural: Which One Would Kill Without A Second Thought?
The Lucifer in Lucifer isn't afraid to murder those he feels are guilty of the punishment. In fact, he revels in the idea of torturing them for all eternity. However, it isn't in his nature to murder those who he deems innocent and in some cases, he appears quite broken inside upon hearing of the victim of a murder. However, the Lucifer in Supernatural kills innocents left and right without even flinching. To him killing humans is the same as swatting flies, it is done without remorse. The Lucifer in Supernatural is more of a murderer.
Lucifer: Which One Is Open To Redemption?
The Lucifer in Supernatural seems to have come to terms with who he is and what he has done. He doesn't question his actions nor does he ask for forgiveness for them. He is a goal-oriented demon who treats the apocalypse like a business decision. However, he has been shown to be open to sitting down with God and hashing out their problems. The Lucifer in Lucifer never really grasps the concept that he has done anything wrong to deserve forgiveness or to seek forgiveness. So the Lucifer in Lucifer wins this round.
Supernatural: Which One Would Destroy Humanity?
Destroying God's creation is the Lucifer from Supernatural's sole purpose. He is angry about being cast aside by God, making him willing to snuff existence right out, even if it takes out him with it. While the Lucifer in Lucifer is so caught up in himself that he doesn't even take the time to ponder the destruction of humanity. In fact, he seems to enjoy the vices that go along with humans.
Without humans, life would be dull and Lucifer isn't one to be bored. So, The Lucifer from Supernatural is the more genocidal of the two.
Lucifer: Which One Takes Responsibility For His Own Actions?
The Lucifer in Supernatural will say its God's fault for caring about humanity more than he did about his angels that caused him to act out. However, his actions are on him and he isn't about to back down from owning up to them.
Sadly, the Lucifer in Lucifer never owns up to his crimes. In his eyes, his actions are completely justified because it is someone else who forced his hand. He might show remorse for what he has done but will never accept responsibility for it. Lucifer in Lucifer wins again.
Supernatural: Which One Is The Most Careless With Lives?
The Lucifer from Supernatural is closer to the Biblical Lucifer. He is willing to watch the world burn if it means he is allowed to rule. Humans are but cattle to him. Their lives are meaningless and the lives of most of the angels are meaningless. He would rule over the dead if it meant accomplishing his goals. As for the Lucifer in the TV show Lucifer, he doesn't seek to harm others, since all he wants is to be free from the shackles his father placed on him. The Supernatural Lucifer wins this round.
Lucifer: Which One Is Worse To His Servants In Hell?
To anyone who has ever watched Lucifer or Supernatural, this one would appear obvious. Lucifer in Supernatural is by far the most ruthless of the two. However, the Lucifer in Supernatural neither loves nor hates those in his domain, so he doesn't even concern himself with their existence at all. While the Devil in Lucifer seems to have a fetish for torture. He believes it is his job and responsibility to enact punishment on the damned and he keeps a tidy ship. So Lucifer in Lucifer wins this round too.
Both Supernatural and Lucifer: Which One Would Kill His Own Kind?
Lucifer in the TV series Lucifer loves his brother. While resentful, he doesn't wish harm upon his own kind. He only wishes they understood his side of the story. As far as the Lucifer from Supernatural, he has a complicated history when it comes to his own kind. He only considers a few of the angels to be his brothers, the ones he served by and was created with.
He mourns for their deaths but has been willing to do what is necessary to further his own goals. This category is a tie between the two.