Battle Droids were commonly used as foot soldiers of the Trade Federation and later the Separatists in the Star Wars prequels, though they became progressively dumber, serving as comic relief. Debuting in Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace, B1 Battle Droids were initially depicted as simple automatons that lacked sapience, but starting with Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith, they became noticeably chattier, talking back to superiors like General Grievous and displaying a greater ability to think and speak than the previous two prequel films suggested. 2008’s Star Wars: The Clone Wars significantly intensified the droids’ mouthiness, turning them into one of the show’s primary forms of comic relief and making them even less competent than they are in the films. Canon and Legends material offers different explanations for the Battle Droids’ gradual stupidity throughout the Star Wars prequel era.

The Trade Federation was one of many corrupt corporate entities in the Star Wars prequel era. By the events of The Phantom Menace, they’d become so large and influential that they had representation in the Republic Senate alongside the representatives of whole star systems. The Trade Federation also had a vast army that Captain Panaka of the Royal Naboo Security Forces considered “battle-hardened.” B1 Battle Droids were cheap, simple, and deployed in massive swarms against the enemies of the Trade Federation. Over a decade later, the Trade Federation lent their war machines, including B1 Battle Droids, to the Separatists.

Related: How Count Dooku Turned The Galaxy Against The Republic

By this point, however, the infamous incompetence of the venerable B1 Battle Droids had been proven time and again. During the Separatist Crisis, the fledgling secessionist movement introduced the B2 Super Battle Droid. Although Super Battle Droids were no match for Republic Clone Troopers and Jedi Knights, they were far more formidable than their predecessors. In the Legends continuity, the Confederacy of Independent Systems (CIS) treated Super Battle Droids as a standard front-line infantry unit, gradually replacing the older B1 models with the B2 droids. In canon, B2 Super Battle Droids were treated as an advanced military unit by the Separatist Alliance, who used them to back up their more common B1 predecessors in battle.

The Battle Droids' Increasing Stupidity In The Star Wars Films

Battle Droids in Star wars

In The Phantom Menace, B1 Battle Droids were mindless drones who spoke little outside of issuing and receiving orders. The Jedi, Naboo Security Forces, and Gungan warriors destroyed them with ease, but the droids were nevertheless shown to be deadly in large numbers. Star Wars: Episode II – Attack of the Clones continued this depiction, showing the droids killing Jedi and Clone Troopers on Geonosis, though the film highlighted the superiority of their successors in one particular moment. A Super Battle Droid bludgeons a malfunctioning B1 out of its way during the battle, showing that the Separatists’ new droid models have little regard for their predecessors. A deleted scene also shows that Clone Wars-era B1 droids are no longer reliant on a central computer’s signal to function, showing that the Trade Federation learned from their defeat on Naboo.

Revenge of the Sith creates something of a discrepancy with its depiction of B1 Battle Droids. The film’s act 1 battles aboard General Grievous’ flagship, the Invisible Hand, has B1 droids with much higher-pitched voices and dialogue that indicates a greater capacity for thought than the in the previous two films. Despite their banter with the Jedi and General Grievous, the B1 droids seem no more or less competent than in their previous appearances (that is to say, still incompetent). No explanation is given for the droids’ different behavior in the film, however, but canon and Legends non-movie material provides different reasons for this discrepancy.

Star Wars Legends' Explanation For Battle Droid Stupidity

Battle Droids in Revenge of the Sith

In the Legends continuity, B1 Battle Droids are depicted the same way throughout the Clone Wars as they were in The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones. After Revenge of the Sith, however, some Legends material would occasionally portray Battle Droids as mouthy and sarcastic. In an issue of Clone Wars Adventures, a B1 droid and Jedi Master Aayla Secura reluctantly work together on the Forest Moon of Endor, with the droid providing unusually snarky commentary on their situation throughout their adventure. In another issue of the comic series, a B1 sustains damage in a battle that frees it from CIS programming, rendering the droid fully sapient and intent on fleeing the Clone Wars for a safer existence as a farmhand.

Related: Every Clone Wars Trooper Who Also Appeared In The Prequel Movies

Instances of mouthy B1 Battle Droids were rare in Legends, but the continuity provides two different explanations for them. The first, as shown in the short story, Republic Commando: Odds, showed droid factories being sabotaged by Republic clones, like the Null-class ARC Trooper Prudii. The 2012 sourcebook, The Essential Guide to Warfare, goes into even more detail, explaining that the CIS upgrade to the B1 droids that rendered them independent from a central computer’s master signal, resulted in numerous droids having bugs and glitches that resulted in some droids having high-pitched voices and excessive commentary.

The Battle Droids As Comic Relief In Star Wars Canon

Split image of Kelleran Beq and Jar Jar Binks played by Ahmed Best in Star Wars

From its 2008 film debut, canon’s The Clone Wars depicted B1 Battle Droids as far less competent than their film counterparts and their antics were far more exaggerated than in Revenge of the Sith. B1 Battle Droids were uniformly sapient, with higher-pitched voices and personalities that ranged from comically defeatist to downright cowardly. Their foolish behavior resulted in them being even less threatening to Jedi and Clone Troopers, and a constant source of irritation to Separatist Alliance field commanders. Asajj Ventress and General Grievous are shown destroying droids out of frustration on multiple occasions.

Canon gives this apparent downgrade a similar explanation to the Legends version, thanks to an episode of The Clone Wars’ first season. In “Liberty on Ryloth,” a group of Battle Droids finds the destroyed remains of an older B1 model. The droids mock the older models, noting that they’re not programmed by a central computer and are thus “independent thinkers.” This indicates that the older and less chatty B1 models from The Phantom Menace were still used by the Separatist Alliance, but were being phased out, becoming a rarity by the start of the Clone Wars (and explaining their depiction in Attack of the Clones). The gradual stupidity of the B1 Battle Droids is a running gag in the Star Wars prequel era, and both continuities provide similar explanations for their Clone Wars-era comic relief.

Next: Star Wars: All 9 Factions In The Skywalker Saga Explained