Star Wars: Battlefront Review: Style Over Substance

Star Wars: Battlefront is finally here, a full month ahead of the headline-dominating, record-breaking, money machine that will be Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens. The game might be the best way for Star Wars fans to whet their appetites for the return of the film saga that began in 1977, kicking off the beloved original trilogy of space operas. And you just know that Battlefront will do its best to tie-in with the film (see: Battle of Jakku DLC).

And it needs to because Star Wars: Battlefront doesn't quite live up to its name, and it's unlikely players will be playing it for too long without new content. DICE's first Star Wars game, and the first release under the 10-year exclusive deal publisher Electronic Arts signed with Disney-Lucasfilm, is not a bad game. It's just not a complete one.

Battlefront released this week but subscribers to the Xbox One exclusive EA Access program were able to play several days early up to a maximum of 10 hours. For a lot of players, those 10 hours will be enough. Star Wars: Battlefront is the perfect rental game experience. But as a full retail game, it's a bit of a ripoff that crosses a line in begging players at every step to invest even more money - nearly the full price of the game again - to purchase the season pass and pre-order upcoming DLC. In fact, "Season Pass" is built into the main menu of the game on the front page in two different places.

Star Wars Battlefront Menu Season Pass DLC
Can you spot the words "Season Pass"?

Similar to last year's Titanfall, another EA game from developers with a strong shooter pedigree, Star Wars: Battlefront suffers from its lack of a story campaign. It's almost a crime given that the last three Battlefield games all featured story-driven missions. If any of these games deserve to put players into epic and varied narrative-driven experiences, whether that be reliving sequences from the films or telling new stories, it's the Star Wars one out of them all.

Instead, Star Wars: Battlefront is multiplayer focused with a little extra for training purposes. The two single-player modes the game does ship with can be played with a friend, solo, and offline. There's Survival, a wave-based mode and Battle which pits the player and some optional AI allies vs. enemy AI and potentially an opposing player in a simple MOBA-inspired session where enemies spawn in until 100 points are earned. The latter requires a lot of running around aimlessly searching for enemies and the former is neat to test yourself once or twice. There's little in these offerings to grab players. They're basic and can be considered the tutorial. Again, the focus is on multiplayer.

There are nine multiplayer modes in Star Wars: Battlefront but there's only one that stands out a great. The game doesn't support the 64-player counts of its modern military predecessors but it does feature two 40-player modes in Supremacy and Walker Assault which are the flagship experiences the game offers and the main reason Star Wars: Battlefront is worth playing. The first few matches on each of the game's four planets in these modes are simply awe-inspiring. Seeing massive AT-AT walkers trudge through a (predefined on-rails) path with player-controlled aircraft whizzing above and smaller player-controlled AT-ST walkers supporting troop movements is a sight to behold, especially since the game looks gorgeous.

Star Wars: Battlefront Walker Assault Screenshot
Walker Assault mode is the highlight of Star Wars: Battlefront

DICE has always been an industry leading developer in sound design and graphical fidelity, and their Frostbite 3 engine shines through in Star Wars: Battlefront. It's easy to see the work that went into getting the details right on vehicles, characters, and weapon designs. The evidence is right there that the team scanned in real-life props, costumes, and set pieces for a sense of authenticity.

That authenticity unfortunately doesn't carry too much weight in general gameplay if you're looking for a hardcore shooter experience with depth since Star Wars: Battlefront embraces an arcade game approach, simplifying every aspect of progression, combat, and vehicular gameplay in favor of appealing to the widest possible demographics. Players can play in first or third-person but cannot go prone, nor can they enter a vehicle on the map, and there are no sniper classes. Instead, in each mode there are glowing, hovering icons that represent usable power-ups (proximity mines, rocket launches, air strikes, etc.) or vehicles (walkers, TIEs, X-Wings, etc.), the latter of which spawn the player in the air in said vehicle when activated.

This system allows for any player, regardless of skill, to have a chance at grabbing a vehicle or playing as one of the game's six hero or villain characters, but it also can make it difficult to do what you want to do. In 20 hours of play, I've never been able to fly the Millennium Falcon or control the weapons of an AT-AT walker for instance. It speaks to the greater problem of there really being little support for teamwork. The game doesn't have squad and commander features, or the ability to give orders like in the Battlefield games so everyone is generally just playing for themselves, racing teammates for the nearest icon and spamming infinite recharging grenades. There is a partner system which lets players spawn or use the loadout of another randomly selected player but too frequently this doesn't work because a partner wasn't assigned or dropped out.

Page 2 of 2: Fighter Squadron, Hero Hunt, and Disappointment

Our Rating:

3 out of 5 (Good)
1 2
Star Wars 9 Resistance Fleet
Star Wars 9 Trailer Teaser Reveals A LOT Of Ships (Including The Ghost?)

More in Game Reviews