Don't Compare Star Wars: The Force Awakens to the Original Trilogy

Star Wars: Episode 8 filming begins

Disney purchased Lucasfilm for the grand sum of $4 billion in October 2012, with the intention of making new Star Wars movies (both within the core saga and standalone adventures). The wait for the first of these projects, J.J. Abrams' Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens, ended up being a little more than three years, and now fans finally have the opportunity to go to their local theater and see the beloved space opera continue with a new generation of heroes and villains.

There were concerns that The Force Awakens would not be able to live up to the outrageous hype that it generated, but that tune changed once the reviews started rolling in (read ours). Many see it as a rousing return to form for the franchise, and Star Wars 7 has become the most acclaimed series installment since 1980's The Empire Strikes Back. Its Rotten Tomatoes score (as of this writing) is actually higher than A New Hope and Empire, and the American Film Institute recently named The Force Awakens one of the 10 best films of 2015.

If it's possible, these facts will only raise the expectations viewers have for the movie when they go to watch it. While most assumed it would improve upon the prequels, few could have predicted something that was this universally praised. Of course, this means that Force Awakens backlash is inevitable, as some who see it will call it "overrated" or "not as good" as the originals, particularly Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back. And the people who make that comparison are simply missing the point.

An Experience Like No Other

Star Wars trilogy theatical Blu-rays

Simply put, there really isn't anything that can compare to the first Star Wars films. Nobody is going to be able to replicate the cultural impact the original movie had in 1977, when the Hollywood blockbuster was a relatively novel thing and society was in a place where it desperately needed the escapism a space fantasy adventure provided. Nowadays, so-called "event" films open seemingly every other week, and the industry has a plethora of blockbuster franchises planned out for the next handful of years. While few (if any) modern movies could top the anticipation of The Force Awakens, it's one of many similar films that open over the course of the year.

The same can be said about The Empire Strikes Back, which is widely considered the greatest sequel ever made. For many fans, it's also the best in the series, seamlessly combining action spectacle with heartfelt character drama, developing all the principal players in ways that felt enthralling. Empire was a rare instance of catching lightning in a bottle twice, and illustrated what a great sequel could accomplish. The galaxy felt more expansive, characters were taken in exciting new directions, and there were plenty of surprises that added depth to the proceedings. At its core, Empire represents what many fans want a Star Wars film to be, since it does so many things perfectly.

So The Force Awakens had a pretty high bar to clear if it was even going to come close to the originals. The first two movies were unlike anything anyone had ever seen before, because there wasn't anything like them before. To his credit, Abrams seemed to understand this, and never set out to make something that would be "better" in terms of quality. He wanted to craft a heartfelt film that honored their tradition.

Appreciating the Present

Star Wars 7 Poster Banner

It's not an understatement to say that Abrams was under intense scrutiny and pressure to deliver on The Force Awakens' promise. Not only were the fans hungry for another good Star Wars movie, Disney also has substantial plans for the franchise's future moving forward. In order for the wave of forward momentum to keep going, Star Wars 7 actually had to earn a universal approval rating. If word-of-mouth was mixed (or worse, terrible), then the last three years would have been for naught and enthusiasm for the Star Wars brand would be greatly diminished.

For all intents and purposes, it's a minor movie miracle that Abrams was able to direct something that's so well-liked. These days, high-profile films such as this generate a flurry of opinions, and its uncommon for just about all of them to be positive. Even Abrams' own Star Trek Into Darkness (which is Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes) didn't sit well with all who saw it upon release, due to the derivative nature of the narrative and the mishandling of the Khan reveal. Out of Abrams' love and admiration for the original Star Wars trilogy, The Force Awakens could have easily fallen into the same trappings and divided the core fan base after everything played out. But the consensus across the board is that Star Wars is back in a big way.

That's the greatest triumph Abrams and Disney could have hoped for. While even the die-hard fans will admit there are a few flaws, the shortcomings are not prominent enough to derail the picture completely (after all, no film is perfect). It's a movie that has so many entertaining and heartfelt moments that it's nearly impossible not to like it. And for longtime followers of the galaxy far, far away, The Force Awakens is exactly what they've wanted since Return of the Jedi: an entertaining, exciting space opera populated by memorable characters with the essence of a classic Star Wars film. That's just as significant as what the first film meant in 1977.

Next: Something to look forward to...

1 2
Batwoman Rotten Tomatoes
Batwoman Has Been Review Bombed By Audiences - Here's Why

More in SR Originals