screenrant.com

Why Star Trek 4 Has Been Canceled

Paramount recently made the decision to indefinitely shelve Star Trek 4, but why did that happen? Ten years ago, the iconic sci-fi franchise was awarded a new lease on life thanks to J.J. Abrams' acclaimed reboot, which reinvigorated the property with an all-new younger cast. In addition to stellar reviews, the film also earned $257.7 million at the domestic box office and remains the highest-grossing Star Trek movie of all-time. The real trick of the reboot was that it introduced Trek to a new generation of fans, appealing to general moviegoers with big screen spectacle and high-quality entertainment. With the Star Wars prequels now past, Hollywood had a new space opera to love.

The success of 2009's Star Trek ensured sequels would be made, and the first of those arrived in the summer of 2013 with Star Trek Into Darkness. While that film proved to be much more divisive than its predecessor (largely because of Wrath of Khan parallels), it was still a commercial hit after bringing in $467.3 million at the worldwide box office. A third movie, Star Trek Beyond, premiered in 2016 to celebrate the franchise's 50th anniversary, and a period of uncertainty followed. Though there were plans in place for a fourth installment, no real progress was ever made and now the project is essentially dead. There are a few reasons why that is.

Related: CBS Wants Star Trek TV Shows Airing All Year Long

Star Trek Beyond Underperformed

Star Trek Beyond Empire covers and posters

Most importantly, the aforementioned Star Trek Beyond did poorly at the box office. The film earned just $343.4 million worldwide against an $185 million production budget, which wasn't enough to reach its break-even point (roughly estimated at $370 million). By most accounts, Paramount ended up losing money on their investment, which was a troubling development since Beyond received positive reviews from critics and fans. Some consider it to be the best entry of the rebooted series (officially dubbed the Kelvin Timeline), so it's a wonder word-of-mouth wasn't able to carry the picture to profitability. Co-writer and star Simon Pegg blamed a lackluster marketing campaign, which got off to a terrible start with the infamous "Sabotage" teaser trailer that made the film look like a generic action flick as opposed to Star Trek. Additionally, Into Darkness backlash didn't help matters and might have killed enthusiasm some had.

There's something else at play here. In December 2015, Disney released a little film called Star Wars: The Force Awakens, which shattered just about every box office record in the book, received critical praise, and revived one of pop culture's most legendary touchstones. Star Wars and Star Trek have been compared endlessly for decades, and it's apparent the return of the former all but ended the latter. Remember, Abrams' Trek movies were widely considered to be Star Trek in Star Wars clothing, relying more on the pacing and style of the Skywalker saga than traditional Star Trek. That angered some purists, but it certainly filled a void. However, when Star Wars started up again and got into the business of annual tentpoles, it was game over for Star Trek. There was no longer a widespread demand for a new Trek movie because everyone was excited for the next Star Wars film. Studies have shown that casual moviegoers pay to see only a handful of films in theaters, so with multiple Marvel installments, DC entries, and Star WarsTrek didn't have much of a place in the hierarchy anymore.

Star Trek 4's Director Moved On

Deep Roy and Simon Pegg in Star Trek Beyond (photo: Paramount Pictures)

After Abrams called the shots on the first two Kelvin Star Trek movies, Justin Lin was handed the keys for Beyond. Lin did an excellent job with the material, but he became a hot commodity afterwards. He toyed with directing Space Jam 2 and is now in place to helm the final two installments of the Fast and Furious franchise. So, Lin was never a realistic possibility for the Star Trek 4 job. Neither was Abrams, who despite having a deal with Paramount, opted to hop aboard the Millennium Falcon once more and direct Star Wars: Episode IX for Lucasfilm. After a search, the job eventually went to S.J. Clarkson, who was set to become the first female director of a Star Trek movie. Only problem is she didn't stick around for long.

Related: William Shatner Thinks Chris Pine Deserves More Money

Members of the Star Trek cast expressed excitement for Clarkson's involvement, but with the film dragging through development, she decided to look elsewhere for work. Clarkson was recently pegged to direct the pilot for HBO's upcoming Game of Thrones prequel series. That will obviously keep her occupied for quite some time, so Paramount was going to have to look elsewhere for a replacement. Obviously, they felt it wasn't worth the effort and chose to pull the plug on Star Trek 4 altogether. Perhaps if Clarkson stayed attached, the studio would have attempted to move forward, but there were other issues they were dealing with that plagued pre-production.

Page 2: Chris Pine's Contract Dispute

1 2
Why Doctor Strange Didn't Fight Thanos In Avengers: Endgame

More in SR Originals