30 Forgettable Sequels Only True Fans Remember

The movie industry has entered a stage where sequels and franchises are now part of the norm. It’s practically irresponsible if future movies and sequel packages aren’t something that are put into consideration when a new project is pitched to prospective studios.

Sequels are what succeed, longevity breeds more stories, and elaborate franchises are what the studios want.

With large development details becoming such a public process, it seems like fans are well-aware of the biggest sequels that move forward and those that don’t come to pass.

It was no surprise to moviegoers that James Cameron would be given the green-light to develop multiple sequels for Avatar after it's box office success. Or that the "Dark Universe" wouldn't be making it's way to the big screen anytime soon, after The Mummy's poor box office performance.

Fans are now more receptive to sequels than they’ve ever been in the past, but they’re also savvier and more intelligent when it comes to them.

Most of the time, the goal of a sequel is to continue a larger story and increase a property’s visibility. This means that sequels are obviously made with the intention of succeeding and prolonging a franchise, but this isn’t always the case.

Many of the biggest sequel failures are common knowledge in the industry. However, there is an array of sequels to big films that have surprisingly managed to stay out of the spotlight, which is a good thing for most of these movies.

Here are the 30 Forgettable Sequels That Only True Fans Remember.

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

30 The Next Karate Kid

The Karate Kid turned out to be an unexpected hit and even garnered Pat Morita an Oscar nomination for his work in the movie. The Karate Kid gave birth to two sequels that continued to push Ralph Macchio’s titular Karate Kid to new heights in the field of Martial Arts.1.

At a point, Macchio’s age started to show and the series was “rebooted,” so to speak, with Morita’s Mr. Miyagi training a new female karate protégé (played by Hilary Swank).

The Next Karate Kid couldn’t summon the same chemistry as its predecessor, unfortunately, but at least it didn’t hold back Swank from finding success.

29 Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights

The original Dirty Dancing is classic love story, but when people think of things that are missing from the beloved movie, is the Cuban Revolution really the first thing that comes to mind?

Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights tells the same story of forbidden love and rhythm that’s present in the first movie, but the oppressive foreign backdrop feels like a weird missing ingredient to bring into a sequel.

Havana Nights might be a much more obtuse version of the original movie, but one of the small highlights of the movie is Patrick Swayze’s limited appearance as a dance instructor. It’s a cute nod to what’s a much more confident, natural dance movie.

28 S. Darko

Richard Kelly’s Donnie Darko became a surprising cult smash that helped put a struggling Jake Gyllenhaal on the map for a lot of people.

The mysterious, indulgent sci-fi/horror hybrid didn’t exactly need a sequel, but it embraces its idea and decides to focus on Donnie’s sister, Samantha (Daveigh Chase reprises her role from the original film).

If Donnie Darko was subtle with its heavy message, S. Darko gets right in the audience’s face with its crazy time travel and trippy science fiction theories.

Without Kelly’s involvement or Gyllenhaal to anchor the picture, it’s just a overwrought mess-- but yes, there are more creepy bunny men.

27 Fight Club 2

Author Chuck Palahniuk is far from the sort of person who treats his work like untouchable gospel, as the writer has turned out some memorable classics that have seen second lives as movies.

While his novels have largely become hits or misses, Fight Club is undeniably one of the author’s better works as well as one of David Fincher’s strongest movies.

In the recent years where nostalgia is king, Palahniuk decided to release a ten-part sequel to his formative work in comic form.

Fight Club 2 contains the same nihilistic wit as the original, but it goes even deeper through the looking glass.

Palahniuk even writes himself into the story in a way that’s just as cringe-worthy as it is appropriate.

26 Son Of The Mask

Son of the Mask, much like Ace Ventura Jr.: Pet Detective, is a soulless sequel that came out far too late for anyone to take it seriously or care.

The original Jim Carrey movie from the ‘90s contains some of the best work from Carrey’s career, but this sequel misses the point entirely.

Jamie Kennedy is a poor substitute for Jim Carrey, but it’s the baby of Kennedy’s character that’s the real focus of the mask’s desires.

Though many consider the original a fan-favorite, Son of the Mask is one of those rare sequels that actually takes away from the original film.

25 The Rage: Carrie 2

The Rage: Carrie 2 is pretty much as shameful as secrets come.

As most of the characters from the original story, including the infamous Carrie White, don’t exactly make it out okay, Carrie 2 is largely a reboot that looks at an entirely new cast of characters that merely deal with a similar problem as the one in the original movie. Why even call it Carrie?

While Carrie 2 doesn’t have a character named "Carrie" in it, it tried to profit off its predecessor which didn’t work out in their favor.

The Rage is an angst-ridden sequel that fails to capture the same energy as the Stephen King classic. It feels like a cash grab that shamelessly cribs the Carrie name to make this story of telekinesis feel more exciting than it actually is.

24 Look What’s Happened To Rosemary’s Baby

Look What's Happened to Rosemary's Baby (1976)

Some of the greatest horror movies of all time are so powerful because they intentionally go out on chilling, ambiguous notes.

Even though it might be tempting to revisit some characters, sequels absolute destroy that ambiguity and take away a lot of the magic that made the original special in the first place.

Look What’s Happened To Rosemary’s Baby is a TV movie that does exactly that, as it takes the Omen route and watches Adrian’s mother attempt to raise a young version of the Antichrist.

Additionally, Mia Farrow doesn’t return, which should be the first sign that something’s wrong here.

23 Grease 2

Michelle Pfeiffer in Grease 2

Sometimes sequels to musicals can be huge successes. For instance, a massive sequel to Mamma Mia! is set to see release later this year. That being said, some musicals are colossal failures and the less said about them, the better.

Grease 2 wasn't just a disappointing sequel, it was also a disappointment in song and dance department.

Grease 2 naturally features different characters and stars than the original. While it has a lot of heart, the songs are clunky, forgettable messes for the most part.

It’s easier to pretend that this sequel doesn’t exist, but it’s some fun, campy trash for when the mood is right.

22 Honey, We Shrunk Ourselves

Honey, We Shrunk the Kids is a modest, fun science fiction movie that looks pretty incredible for the time. Due to the movie's success and the vast scientific abilities of the family within the film, the prospect of a sequel made a lot of sense.

Honey, I Blew Up the Kid goes in the opposite direction and sees the family’s toddler grow gigantic in size as opposed to shrinking him down.

However, even further down the road, a lesser known sequel was put together where Rick Moranis’ plucky scientist ends up shrinking himself along with the rest of the parents and it’s up to the children to save the day.

21 Home Alone 4: Taking Back The House

Home Alone 4 (2002)

Home Alone and its sequel, Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, are beloved movies that helped put Macaulay Culkin on the map.

The original team involved decided that the series had run its course, but that didn’t stop other people from telling more slapstick home invasion stories.

Home Alone 3 steps away from Kevin McCalister, but the fourth movie in the series, Home Alone: Taking Back the House, re-introduces not only Kevin, but also Marv the Wet Bandit who now has a villainous wife by his side.

Home Alone: Taking Back the House is a disappointing return of Kevin and company and it’s even more uninspired than the third movie in the series.

20 Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps

Society has certainly entered a chapter where it’s become quite fashionable and profitable to return to titles and properties from many years in the past.

Suddenly, old cult hits are seeing new life decades later and it’s leading to very mixed reactions.

Wall Street is a cult classic from 1987 that starred Michael Douglas, Charlie Sheen, and Martin Sheen. Sadly, it's sequel wasn't as well received.

Oliver Stone decided to make a sequel to his popular movie, Wall Street, more than twenty years after the original came out.

Admittedly, the themes of greed and corruption from Wall Street are even more relevant now, so a sequel does make sense. Unfortunately, it had to throw in Shia LaBeouf as the unnecessary voice of the next generation.

19 2010: The Year We Make Contact

2010 The Year We Make Contact Probe

The movie 2010  is a modest effort that isn’t necessarily bad-- it just follows the impossible task of attempting to follow-up Kubrick’s monumental sci-fi classic, 2001: A Space Odyssey.

The flick is actually closer to Arthur C. Clarke’s original source material, but it’s just a terrifically more normal picture.

Furthermore, many people would appreciate not having the mystique of 2001 be ruined for them and that’s kind of the goal of 2010, by and large.

The movie still amounts to an interesting sci-fi film that offers up some fascinating ideas about the future, but it probably would have been better if they had changed the name entirely and pushed the material even further.

18 *18. Butch And Sundance: The Early Days

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid’s freeze frame ending is such a memorable conclusion to a movie that it’s clear that any sort of future work in the universe would have to be a story that looked at the duo’s formative years.

Butch and Sundance: The Early Days does exactly that and looks at how the rascals got together and some of their earliest exploits.

The movie came out ten years after the original, but it feels much more like an idea that lines up with the current cinema landscape. Forced prequel stories that nobody asked for is commonplace now and these guys were well ahead of the curve.

17 Staying Alive

Staying Alive

Staying Alive is as big and bad as sequel spectacles get. The movie is a flashy, unsubtle '80s sequel to the classic Travolta dance film, Saturday Night Fever, and what's even worse is that it's devoid of the passion that makes the original movie such an enjoyable experience.

Staying Alive was released in 1983 and has a 0% score on Rotten Tomatoes, but it was a success at the box office.

What's confusing about this sequel is that it's written and directed by Sylvester Stallone/

It takes Travolta's Tony Manero out of disco dancing and into the world of musical theater. It's a bewildering experience, but the musical “Satan's Alley” must be seen to be believed.

16 The Last Days Of Patton

It's always a risky gamble when actors choose to reprise famous roles that won them critical acclaim, or in the case of George C. Scott, an Academy Award for Best Actor.

Scott gave an unforgettable performance in Patton, but it's quite unusual to see him return to the role 16 years later for a TV movie.

Not only that, but the movie removes Patton from the battlefield and instead depicts his final days, many of which have him detained to a hospital bed in paralysis.

It's a bizarre role in a bizarre biopic, but perhaps Scott was just eager to close the door on this important role from his life.

15 Lawrence After Arabia

Even the title of the TV movie sequel to Lawrence of Arabia sounds like sketch from a comedy series. Lawrence After Arabia screams "silly sequel" while it is far from that. Instead, the title sets a bad first impression.

To the movie's credit, Ralph Fiennes is the one that plays Lawrence and he does a mighty good job. He is arguably more passionate than the original performance.

The movie isn't all bad and Fiennes’ take brings a lot to the table, but the whole thing just seems unnecessary and seems as if it is created from deleted scenes from the original movie.

Its lengthy release from the classic movie's debut also doesn't help the movie.

14 The Lives Of Harry Lime

One of Orson Welles’ most iconic roles is Harry Lime in The Third Man. It’s an enigmatic role that naturally had moviegoers demanding for more.

That wish was granted when a prequel TV series to The Third Man titled The Lives of Harry Lime went into production.

The series chronicled Lime’s many exploits before his untimely end in Vienna.

It was an engaging series that captured much of the original movie's atmosphere and, for what it’s worth, the prequel series also existed as a radio series, where Welles did, in fact, reprise his role of Harry Lime.

13 Psycho IV: The Beginning

Psycho IV The Beginning Norman Bates

Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho is an absolute classic piece of cinema. While many people are harsh on its sequels, Psycho II and Psycho III still manage to progress Norman's story in a challenging, exciting way that makes for a worthwhile addition to Hitchcock's story.

That being said, Psycho IV is a strange misfire that still features Anthony Perkins in his famous role and even sees him in the director's chair.

The movie adopts a weird structure, where Norman calls into a radio station and gets into his "origin story." It provides a lot of answers that nobody was looking for.

At least Bates Motel was a satisfying success.

12 Shock Treatment

Shock Treatment

The Rocky Horror Picture Show still holds such a special, cherished place within its audience's hearts to this day.

The movie woke people up in a big way, so it makes plenty of sense that a sequel would come to pass. What’s so surprising here is that Shock Treatment, the controversial sequel to Rocky Horror, decides to put entertainment culture, specifically game shows, on its radar.

Shock Treatment is a loud, vibrant sequel that doesn’t contain music that is nearly as memorable as its predecessor, but it still makes for a bewildering spectacle.

There’s such a satirical tone present that it’s hard to take Shock Treatment seriously.

11 The Two Jakes

Jack Nicholson in The Two Jakes

Roman Polanski's Chinatown is one of the most impressive noir movies in all of cinema. It's a staple of the genre and that's why the idea of a sequel is so surprising, especially one that comes along fifteen years later.

The Two Jakes has a lot going for it, like a script from Chinatown's screenwriter, Robert Towne, Jack Nicholson as director, and a cast that also featured the likes of Harvey Keitel and Meg Tilly.

In spite of this, a convoluted plot held down the movie and the plans to fill out the Jake Gittes trilogy were put to rest.

10 Caddyshack II

Sure, if something like The Hangover could get a trilogy then why not make a sequel to Caddyshack?

Well it’s not exactly a terrible idea, but with practically none of the original talent or crew involved, why bother rocking the boat?

Caddyshack isn’t exactly Ghostbusters and it didn’t leave a lot of hanging threads open, so perhaps the sequel should have just focused on being an original golf comedy.

Caddyshack II is an awkward, stilted effort at comedy that makes for healthy cringe fuel nearly ten years after the original.

However, at least it leads to more work for gopher puppets. Caddyshack II is a testament to how not everything is a franchise.

9 The French Connection II

French Connection II

Just like there's a lot of controversy that surrounds attempts to make sequels to classic movies decades later, there's also quite a stigma against making sequels to movies that have won major Academy Awards, especially Best Picture.

This was the case with the impressive police drama, The French Connection, which decided to put out a sequel a mere four years after the original's release.

The French Connection II followed Popeye Doyle as he continues his search for Alain Charnier, a few years after the events of the first movie.

What's problematic about a sequel to The French Connection is that the original movie is based on a real crime.

The movie also completely destroys Gene Hackman's Popeye Doyle and turns him into a disgrace of a character.

8 Wizard Of Oz: Journey Back To Oz

The creepy Return to Oz might still be too obscure for some people, but Journey Back to Oz is an even more puzzling relic from the Oz universe.

Furthermore, the 1974 animated feature is technically the only officially sanctioned sequel to the original MGM classic.

Journey Back to Oz, as peculiar as it is, features a pretty stacked voice cast that includes the likes of Liza Minnelli, Mickey Rooney, and Milton Berle.

While the movie was a box office disaster, it saw a second life on television and now features live-action sequences with Bill Cosby as the Wizard.

7 The Sting II

Jackie Gleeson in The Sting II

The Sting II is such a puzzling venture that it almost seems like it’s supposed to be a grift on the audience. The movie is ostensibly a remake of the Best Picture-winning movie, but it performs a minor name change on the central characters and recasts the roles.

It’s a baffling experiment that misses the magic of the original movie and is a much more hollow outing.

Everything about The Sting II feels like a downgraded, lazier version of what the original does. Even though Jackie Gleason and Mac Davis give commendable performances, they’re no Paul Newman and Robert Redford.

6 Scarlett

Gone With the Wind is one of those classic movies where even the very idea of proposing a continuation of the story almost seems insulting. People that try to make a Citizen Kane 2 are going to face quite the uphill battle.

In spite of the objection of purists, nearly 55 years after Gone With the Wind's release came the TV miniseries, Scarlett.

Scarlett continues the story of Scarlett O'Hara and Rhett Butler, but it treats the titular character so terribly that you wonder why this exists in the first place.

Scarlett totally destroys the goodwill that the original movie earned and many people won't see a purpose for the cruel treatment of the character.

5 The Black Bird

The Black Bird is one of the stranger sequels to come around because as much as it is a direct sequel to the Humphrey Bogart noir classic, it’s also a comedy and parody of the original movie.

George Segal stars as Sam Spade Jr. and he’s more or less staffed with the same mystery that his father was almost 35 years ago.

The Black Bird manages to provide a fresh take on the source material, but it also explores an entirely new genre that throws extremist dwarves and evil surfers into the mix.

4 They Call Me Mister Tibbs! And The Organization

It's admirable when a hit movie that garners critical acclaim and prestigious awards decides to turn itself into a franchise of pulpy crime thrillers.

To their credit, while In the Heat of the Night is a great movie that impressively handles race relations and romance, it doesn't seem like they were aware of the hit that they had.

In the Heat of the Night spawned two sequels that up the stakes for Detective Tibbs as he deals with corrupt criminals and an intimidating gang rings.

The sequels may carry on Tibbs' legacy, but the fact that the name of the first sequel is Tibbs' famous catchphrase from the original movie does not bode well.

3 The Birds II: Land’s End

Header The Birds II Lands End Attack

The idea of making a sequel to one of Alfred Hitchcock’s classics should always be put under severe consideration, which is why it’s so disappointing that The Birds II is such a random, low-quality endeavor.

Made in the ‘90s as a Showtime TV movie, The Birds II basically goes through the plot of the first movie again, except in a different location with a new family.

The film’s director, Rick Rosenthal, was so ashamed with the movie that he opted to credit himself as Alan Smithee.

2 It Runs In The Family

It Runs in the Family is one of those sequels we're surprised nobody tried to stop from being made. The movie is a sequel to A Christmas Story and continues the story of Ralphie Parker (now played by Kieran Culkin), and his family.

It Runs in the Family removes Christmas from the equation and attempts to just show this quirky family during a "normal" time in their lives.

In spite of strong work from Charles Grodin and Mary Steenburgen, the movie just feels pointless in the end. There's also a more traditional sequel, A Christmas Story 2, but it's even worse.

1 The Fall Of A Nation

The Fall of a Nation isn’t a particularly considerate or graceful movie, but it earns a strange place in history since it’s technically the first sequel of all time.

The Birth of a Nation is a highly controversial propagandistic movie, but it was also one of the most popular films of all time upon release.

The sequel was rushed into production in order to capitalize on that success and came out within a year of the original. However, all copies of The Fall of a Nation have been lost, so this sequel remains an old artifact of time.


Can you think of any other sequels that most fans forgot about? Sound off in the comments!

More in Lists