Jenny McCarthy is one of four judges on season 5 of The Masked Singer. The judges are more like professional guessers, as they all try to uncover who the singer is before their identities are revealed when they get unmasked. Robin Thicke, Nicole Scherzinger, Ken Jeong, and Jenny McCarthy have all had some questionable guesses, but many fans have been mocking some of Jenny's more notoriously poor guesses.

After five seasons of The Masked Singer, fans may have thought the judges would get better with their guessing. But they have had just as many outlandish guesses as to who is under the mask as past seasons. Jeong always makes completely absurd shots in the dark, usually for the comedic effect. Many fans feel like the show is overproducing the show recently, so Jenny actually looks smarter in her guessing. One Reddit user commented that it feels like producers want "Jenny to be the queen of guessing."

Related: The Masked Singer: Most Popular Unmasked Celebs Ranked By Instagram Followers

However, fans have been sounding off on some of her "lame guesses of her husband/some guy in the same boyband or Jamie Foxx [that] aren't cutting it either." They are referencing the times that Jenny has legitimately guessed her husband, Donnie Wahlberg, as the rabbit in the first season of The Masked Singer, as if she would not know that her own husband was on the show. Fans have also had a problem with how she "repeatedly guesses Jamie Foxx every time there's a black male singer." She and Nicole also guessed that Lady Gaga was the lion in season one, even though it was right in the middle of her iconic movie "A Star is Born" getting nominated for several Oscars.

jenny mccarthy the masked singer cropped 2

Many fans feel that the show is gaslighting them, saying "it's a bummer that Nicole and Robin are made to look like they're dumber than Jenny given that they're actual musicians and their industry knowledge should help them." Many fans believe she is being fed answers to build that narrative and that she would be more respected "if her guesses were more often wrong but well-reasoned." Jenny had even guessed the bee who was legendary Gladys Knight as none other than Beyonce because of her fanbase calling themselves "Beyhive."

Some fans have mocked Jenny's lack of credentials as a judge on The Masked Singer, saying "she yells and talks over people and doesn't seem to know music." Others argue that as the pop-culture guru, "Jenny knows the most about celebs by far out of all of them" and dubbing her a "bona fide celebrity knowledge rolodex." After Nick Cannon was temporarily replaced by Niecy Nash, fans have even been calling for her to join The Masked Singer as a judge and replace Jenny, since she brought a breath of fresh air to the show.

Next: Masked Singer Announces First Masky Awards During Sing-A-Long Episode

The Masked Singer airs Wednesdays at 8pm EST on Fox.

 Source: Reddit