Year after year, it is not unusual for fans to fall in love with the women featured on Love Island USA as they search for a partner and attempt to find love. From Elizabeth Weber and Alexandra Stewart on Love Island USA season 1 to Justine Ndiba and Cely Vazquez in season 2 to Cashay Proudfoot, Kyra Lizama, and Shannon St Clair in season 3, this show has featured an incredible and diverse array of female contestants.
More often than not, the girls on Love Island USA are very supportive toward each other as they attempt to navigate the challenges of dating a bunch of new guys in the villa. While many other dating competitions capitalize on showing women fighting amongst themselves, the US edition of Love Island has truly established a new blueprint for female contestants appearing on reality TV. As a result, many Love Island USA girls have become very popular on Instagram.
4. Cely Vazquez - 476,000 Followers
It is not surprising at all that Love Island USA season 2 star Cely Vazquez is one of the most-followed women from this series. With 476,000 Instagram followers as of this writing, Cely has slightly more followers than her BFF Justine Ndiba's 424,000 followers. With that said, Cely and Justine are still the best of friends and even co-host a podcast now. Both of them had pretty dramatic breakups with their respective Love Island partners, but they are in a much better place as a result.
3. Leslie Golden - 512,000 Followers
Fans were very confused by Leslie Golden's sudden off-camera elimination and later found out that she was kicked off the show for bringing a dab pen to Love Island USA. Leslie made waves in season 3 following her introduction at Casa Amor. As the twist came to an end, Korey Gandy chose to couple up with Leslie and guarantee her place in the main villa. However, Leslie was kicked off the show just a few days later. On Instagram, Leslie has 512,000 followers right now.
2. Caro Viehweg - 555,000 Followers
On Love Island USA season 1, Caro Viehweg was introduced as a 21-year-old girl from Los Angeles, California. She eventually coupled up with Ray Gantt and made it to the grand finale with him, placing third overall. According to different reports, this couple is no longer together outside the villa. Alas, CBS recently announced that Caro and Ray will be competing together on the upcoming The Amazing Race season 33, which is scheduled to air in 2022. Caro currently has 555,000 Instagram followers.
1. Kaitlynn Anderson - 1,000,000 Followers
Despite being introduced as one of the five OG women on Love Island USA season 2, Kaitlynn Anderson didn't last very long in the villa. She initially coupled up with Carrington Rodriguez upon first impressions, but there was clearly nothing romantic between them. After the first main re-coupling of the season, Kaitlynn became the first-eliminated islander from season 2. And yet, Kaitlynn is the most-followed contestant of Love Island USA with 1 million followers.