It's Casa Amor time on Love Island USA, and while Isaiah Campbell has six new beautiful women to choose from, he may find himself back in Sydney Paight's arms when it's time to reunite. Along with the Timmy Pandolfi and Zeta Morrison drama, Isaiah and Sydney have been the talk of the season. They've had so many ups and downs on the island that they're starting to make fans at home queasy. Sydney stepped forward for the tattooed 21-year-old during episode 1, and it seems to have been love at first sight.
The Love Island USA couple split up for a short period of time when Sydney shocked contestants by coupling up with Andy Voyen for reasons no one has quite figured out. The islander seems to have thought the two had a connection after they kissed behind Isaiah and Andy's partner, Mady McLanahan's, back. However, soon after, Sydney was back to Isaiah, and despite some temptations, the two have not coupled up with anyone else. Recently, the contestants split up, with the female islanders staying at the villa and the men sneaking off to Casa Amor. Each island home comes with six new bombshells for contestants to connect with.
While many of the new women seem interested in Isaiah, they may be out of luck as the islander has been bonded to Sydney since day one and could very likely go back to her. While many fans have found the Love Island USA couple to be quite toxic, the two have made it through the rough seas of their relationship and seem to truly care for one another. After Sydney left Isaiah for Andy, she apologized and let her former partner know that she still had feelings for him and planned to choose him the next time there was a recoupling. Isaiah has probably done the most apologizing out of everyone on the show. He's made Sydney cry multiple times after getting to know other girls on Love Island USA, but no matter what, it doesn't seem like anyone fulfills him as Sydney does. When Kat Rose and Nadjha Day arrived as new bombshells on Love Island, USA, they both chose to go on a date with Isaiah. Unfortunately, there was no connection between the islander and Kat, but when he sat down to talk with Nadjha, there was an immediate spark.
Sydney did not like the idea of her partner getting to know someone else on the island and gave him an ultimatum: he stays with her, or she'd move on to someone new. While it seemed he was leaning towards recoupling with Nadjha, he realized the new bombshell was not worth losing his connection with Sydney and stayed with her instead. Fellow contestants like Timmy, and some of the new bombshells who have been following the relationship from home before entering the villa, seem to think Isaiah is staying with Sydney because she's the safe choice and is afraid of losing her. He's caught the eye of new bombshells Phoebe Siegel and Chanse Corbi, and while he'll likely get to know the girls better, he doesn't seem to be as interested in them as they are in him. In fact, his conversation with Chanse seemed a little awkward and lacked chemistry. Nothing seems to compare to what he has with Sydney.
Most Love Island USA fans seem to believe Isaiah will have a hard time staying faithful to Sydney while in Casa Amor. According to a few sneak peeks, he'll likely be kissing a lot of women. However, that doesn't mean he wants to take any of those islanders to the finale with him. Despite what he and Sydney have gone through, the two are inseparable. After all, there's a reason their fellow contestants voted them as the first couple to spend the night at the villa's hideaway. No matter how determined the Casa Amor girls are to turn Isaiah's head, they might find themselves in the same position as Nadjha, coming second to Sydney.
Love Island USA airs Tuesday through Sunday at 9 p.m. EST on Peacock.