The first photo of Brandon Routh in the Superman costume has popped up online thanks to USA Today. What you may not have seen is one of a number of new images of Christian Bale from Batman Begins. Now I'm sorry, but when I compare the images I've seen of Batman and this one of Superman... Routh just looks kind of... dorky.
I mean compare these two images. Look at how Bale beefed up for the role (those arms are monstrous!). When I picture Superman, I picture a monstrously buff dude, not the picure I see here. (Click on the image for a larger version):
I mean sure, Routh makes a great Clark Kent, but as Superman I just don't think he's big enough or tall enough. With the boots his legs just look kind of stubby.