Logan director James Mangold is not exactly thrilled with post-credit scenes and he's not exactly shy about sharing his opinion about them, either. Historically, credits and/or post-credits scenes are nothing new; 1979's The Muppets Movie, 1980's Airplane!, and 1986's Ferris Bueller's Day Off all include some, as did 2016's Deadpool (riffing on Ferris Bueller's Day Off's famous credits stinger). Of course, they've really taken off in popularity over the past ten years thanks to the Marvel Cinematic Universe - starting with 2008's Iron Man, when Nick Fury showed up looking for Tony Stark, after the credits had finished rolling.
Since the first Iron Man was released, fans have become accustomed to waiting around for post-credits scenes, especially when they're seeing a superhero movie. And while the majority of people don't seem to think there's anything wrong with them, there are some who are definitely not happy about the post-credits scene's rise in popularity. Mangold is very much in the latter category, and he didn't mince his words when he was asked for his thoughts on the subject.
While attending Audi's 2018 Writers Guild Association Beyond Words Panel in Los Angeles (via Cinema Blend), Mangold shared his thoughts on post-credit tags in films and their current popularity. The filmmaker was pretty clear about not being particularly fond of attaching extra footage at the end of his movies (despite having done so with The Wolverine, via a post-credits scene that set up X-Men: Days of Future Past):
Technically, there is nothing wrong with using stingers. At this point, it's simply regarded as something already part of the film and not a bonus scene, especially with Marvel offerings. And to be fair, not all films that have tags at the end are deemed bad. For projects that are part of a franchise, it's a different way of reminding people that what they have just seen is part of a bigger narrative. Other times, it's just a fun bit attached at the end of a movie. Moreover, it's a great ploy to keep people in their seats for the film's credits and learn to better appreciate just how many people actually worked on the movie that they just finished watching.
Then again, Mangold does have a point about the idea of a couple short credits scenes being expected to salvage the full two-hour film that just came before it. It's like studios are asking people to pay to watch a subpar movie and sit through the whole thing, just to get a short bit at the end that may or may not have a direct relation to what they just watched . Stingers shouldn't feel like they're consolations for seeing a film; if anything, they should be added perks for those who stayed until the very end of the credits roll.
Source: Cinema Blend
- X-Men: Dark Phoenix (2019) release date: Jun 07, 2019
- Deadpool 2 (2018) release date: May 18, 2018
- New Mutants (2020) release date: Apr 03, 2020
- Gambit (2020) release date: Mar 13, 2020