Warning! Spoilers for Blue and Gold #2
The Justice League is too scared to address Batman’s “Robin problem.” The Dark Knight has had several sidekicks take on the Boy Wonder’s persona, and his super friends aren’t holding him accountable.
Beginning with Dick Grayson, and continuing with Jason Todd, Tim Drake, Carrie Kelly, and Damian Wayne, Robin has had a long legacy at Batman’s side. Although it might have been slightly weird when the Caped Crusader first announced his first juvenile crimefighting partner, it was especially concerning when the second Robin’s death didn’t bring the dynamic duo to a definitive end. For some fans, Bruce moved on too quickly for comfort from the tragic murder of Jason Todd to bestow Tim Drake with the costume. Alfred might be one of the few people in Bruce’s life who would be willing to mention the issue, but hasn’t made much of a difference regarding his superhero habits.
Despite Batman’s closeness with the Justice League as a founding member, his teammates shy away from acknowledging his Robin problem. When the topic is brought up by Blue Beetle in Blue and Gold #2, Booster Gold tells him, “we aren’t supposed to talk about that.” Written by Dan Jurgens with art by Ryan Sook, the issue is the first time that it’s been revealed the Justice League is too scared to hold Bruce responsible. With such a sensitive topic as adolescent crimefighting, the League’s reluctance to confront Batman is concerning. Booster Gold might be kidding around, but there seems to be some truth to his sentiment.
Although he’s considered “a realistic superhero,” Batman’s endless supply of child sidekicks who adopt the name “Robin” borders on the absurd. In the real world, Commissioner Gordon would likely feel compelled to point out something strange is going on. The fact that B-list Leaguers like Blue Beetle and Booster Gold don’t bother Bruce with it is one thing. However, it’s problematic that heroes like Superman and Wonder Woman want nothing to do with the conversation. If they won’t have a much-needed dialogue with the Dark Knight, it’s telling what else they might let their friend get away with.
Batman’s Robin problem has been bought up by the fans before, but it never seemed like a point that stories would incorporate. Recently in HBO Max’s Titans, Bruce’s lack of remorse and consistent search for a crimefighting partner to wear the tights has come up. While it might seem like a comedic beat, Batman’s cycle of Boy Wonders could easily reflect a serious psychological conflict. Similarly, it’s been pointed out by the fanbase that Batman has a problem targeting the poor and mentally ill. Recently, this critique of his crimefighting methods was also adapted into Batman: Reptilian as a relevant plot point. As DC Comics listens to readers, there might be hope for Batman to get past his Robin issue.