Jamie Lloyd Is Halloween's Most Underappreciated Character

Jamie Lloyd's three-film story arc in the Halloween franchise is underrated despite standout performances from horror fan favorite, Danielle Harris.

Jamie Lloyd and Michael Myers on the Halloween 5 Poster

The Halloween 4-6 trilogy starring Jamie Lloyd is an underrated movie run. Jamie's introduction in Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers expanded on the saga of Michael Myers and Laurie Strode by extending on their already tumultuous family tree. Her story, which saw Michael Myers target his young niece instead of his sister, brought a new level of brutality to the already arduous killer because, comparatively, many horror films set a precedent of shying away from the taboo of killing children onscreen. Jamie Lloyd’s story was wrapped up within the span of three movies, ending with Halloween 6: The Curse of Michael Myers.

Today, the Halloween franchise has become somewhat of a "choose your own adventure" series for horror fans, with multiple timelines telling very different stories, and Jamie Lloyd’s trilogy is very much part of that. In fact, some fans argue that pulling her out of Myers’ familial history in both Halloween H20 and Halloween 2018 was an over-sighted mistake. Danielle Harris, who originated the role of Lloyd when she was a child, even expressed her disappointment about the reboot in 2018 not including Jamie and the choice to give Laurie Strode a different daughter instead.

Related: Halloween Movies Ranked, Worst to Best

Similar to how Halloween III: Season of the Witch has made a turnaround in recent years with horror fans after being initially panned by critics and audiences, Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers has made a similar push toward acceptance, and part of that is because of Danielle Harris’ stunning performance as Jamie Lloyd. Originally, the producers wanted Jamie Lee Curtis to reprise her role as Laurie and return to the original storyline after it was abandoned in the previous installment. However, due to Curtis’ rising success in Hollywood, she declined their offer. Since the Strode/Myers dynamic was so popular with fans, the writers decided to pursue Jamie Lloyd’s story instead.

Halloween 4 Broke The Child Actor Curse With Jamie Lloyd

Child actors are risky, especially in horror because, as seen in films like The Shining, when they are the driving force behind a story, there’s a make or break potential that comes down to performance. Danielle Harris delivers in creating a sympathetic character who exerts just as much grit and bravery as other final girls in slasher movies despite still being a child. Jamie’s outsider status becomes apparent early on when she’s mocked relentlessly by her classmates for being the niece of “The Bogeyman” and having a dead mother. On top of that, increasingly terrifying nightmares of her uncle returning for her come to a head on Halloween eve.

What stands out most is Halloween 4's twist ending, where Jamie is revealed as a new killer. Though this fate is foreshadowed early by her selection of a clown costume (the same one Michael wore to kill as a child) to wear trick or treating with her foster sister, it’s a wild ride getting to an explosive final scene. Reprising his iconic role as Dr. Loomis, Donald Pleasence is caught once again in a position where he can only watch on with horror after he realizes that Jamie has decided to follow in Michael’s footsteps by brutally attacking her foster mother with a pair of scissors.

Halloween 5 Made Jamie Lloyd A Superior Final Girl

Danielle Harris as Jamie Lloyd in Halloween 5

When Jamie Lloyd’s story continues in Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers, she is being cared for a children’s psychiatric facility and has been decreed mute after being terrorized by Michael Myers a year prior. We learn that her foster mother survived her vicious attack, but Jamie’s mind has continued to fracture as she continually suffers not only the nightmares, but now experiences seizures and has developed some sort of psychic link to her uncle. Under the care of Dr. Loomis (Donald Pleasence), Jamie is used to convince detectives that Michael is still alive.

Related: Why Danielle Harris Returned For Rob Zombie's Halloween

For such a young performer, Harris shows a great deal of strength and confidence in the role the second time around despite being mute for much of the story, steeling herself for another showdown with her uncle. While the logic of a psychic bond forming between Michael and Jamie might be something of a stretch, especially since many fans of the franchise weren’t fond of the supernatural elements that surrounded the character of Myers, the intensity it created in this part was incredibly satisfying, particularly when it resulted in a remarkably tender finale between Jamie and Michael.

Before he makes an attempt to kill her, Michael responds to Jamie’s insistent plea that he remove his mask and obliges, even shedding a single tear, showing he has some shred of humanity. It’s short-lived, but showcases a distinct strength and bravery from Jamie, who even dares to touch Michael’s face just before he’s apprehended. This fearlessness and curiosity which could only be expressed by a child sets Jamie Lloyd apart from other and heroines who go toe-to-toe with monsters and live to tell the tale.

Jamie Lloyd Was Treated Poorly By Halloween 6

Jamie Lloyd in Halloween 6

The final leg of Jamie Lloyd’s story was cut surprisingly short in Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers. In this installment, instead of being a formidable adult heroine, Jamie (now played by J.C. Brandy) is a means to an end. The film catches up with her as a hostage of the Thorn cult after she was kidnapped by a mysterious Man in Black at the end of the fifth film. During a flashback, it's revealed that it was he who killed the police officers in charge of guarding Michael’s cell; he was allowed to escape, and Michael and Jamie were abducted by the cult.

In present time, Jamie gives birth to a baby boy on Halloween eve and escapes the cult, only to be found by her uncle at a bus stop. He unceremoniously murders her, Tommy Doyle (Paul Rudd) ends up finding her baby, and that’s the end of Jamie’s story. In the producer’s cut of Halloween 6, it is heavily implied that Michael is the father of Jamie’s baby, but this is never confirmed. Originally, writer Daniel Farrands intended for Jamie to survive the duration of the film and die a more heroic death at the end.

Related: Every Character Confirmed To Return In Halloween Kills (So Far)

Halloween Misused Jamie Lloyd

Jamie Lloyd in Halloween

Eventually, Jamie Lloyd met an even worse fate by being excluded and dropped from canon completely in Halloween H20: 20 Years Later; Jamie Lee Curtis’ return to her role of Laurie Strode required some hand waving over plot holes and created an entirely alternate Halloween timeline.

Not only are the movies that tell the tale of Jamie Lloyd incredibly underrated in general, her character has, in many ways, suffered the most of any character in the franchise. She embodied the tender innocence of Laurie Strode that fans fell in love with during the original film, but also brought an unwavering valor to the role of a traumatized child who dared fight Myers not once, but twice. Like it or not, Jamie’s inclusion in the franchise brought a tremendous amount of depth and characterization to staples like Dr. Loomis and Michael Myers, giving them a foil to build off of and play against. Many child actors are praised for their ability to carry a role in serious movies, yet it could be easily argued that Danielle Harris as Jamie Lloyd not only carried one Halloween film, but two.

More: Halloween: Resurrection Has the Series' Worst Michael Myers Retcon

IT - Pennywise in Sewer With Blue Eyes
IT: Why Pennywise Changes His Eye Color Before Killing Georgie