Since the advent of home video game consoles, the choice of a player's preferred controller has remained an ever-present debate within the Fighting Game Community. People with more experience playing games in arcades have popularized Arcade Sticks among even the youngest fans. As a result, many newcomers in the FGC are confused as to whether they should invest in an arcade stick or continue using their default controller pad. Typically, this decision is merely a matter of preference and has no tangible effect on a player's skill or success.

In the early days of fighting games, the combination of a single, eight-way joystick with large, snappy arcade-style buttons had proven itself an effective control method for all kinds of fighters. When western arcades began to dwindle due to the popularity and convenience of home consoles, fans of fighting games developed a new controller to suit them. The arcade stick was invented as a way for people who loved playing fighting games like Street Fighter 2, King of Fighters, and Tekken on arcade cabinets to enjoy fighting games in the comfort of their own homes. For a long while, arcade sticks were especially rare and expensive, but they have become exceedingly more accessible in recent years. Still, purchasing even the most affordable sticks is a bit of an investment, so one should think carefully before they decide if it's worth it.

Related: How Two Special Moves Changed Fighting Games Forever

The first thing a potential stick-buyer should understand is that by no means will an arcade stick make them better. Arcade sticks are not an inherently superior control method compared to a regular pad, though they do have different advantages and disadvantages. What owning an arcade stick does affect is one's comfort level and lifestyle. An arcade stick's buttons are larger and spaced in such a way as to line up comfortably with most people's fingers. They also make a satisfying snap sound when pressed. Some people find that these two factors help them make inputs more precisely. Likewise, the wide-range of the joystick may seem more comfortable to some than the clustered buttons on a controller's d-pad.

Which Controller Is Better For Fighting Games?

Street Fighter V Capcom Tease

Unfortunately arcade sticks are not perfect, and there are some ways in which regular controllers are superior. Portability is the most obvious of examples, as the average arcade stick is around the same size as a home console. Likewise, as comfortable as the eight-way joystick may seem to some, it is typically a much slower input method as players' wrists must cover a wider distance to move around than someone's thumb would on a d-pad. In some circumstances, the sound of an arcade stick's snappy buttons may be a double-edged sword. It is not an unpopular tactic to listen for the sound of an opponent's buttons during in-person matches in order to react to their actions, and while button silencers are available for stick users, regular controller buttons are always silent.

The final argument against arcade sticks is also the likeliest to deter buyers. In general, arcade sticks are a more expensive option than simply using a regular controller. A smaller arcade stick made with low quality parts can still cost upwards of $40. Meanwhile, a standard-sized arcade stick built with the same parts used by many fighting game pros will cost at least $100-150. That's a lot to dish out for a new controller that someone may not even want once they try it.

In general, the best advice for someone curious about Arcade Sticks is to use what they're comfortable with. If they seem committed to the game, and feel like a standard controller isn't working for them, then an arcade stick may be the right choice. Hopefully they can borrow one from a friend or visit an arcade first, however, so they can test out the idea before they spend $40-100 on what may be a novelty.

Next: Best Fighting Games For Casual & Beginner Players In 2020