Netflix's new trilogy of horror concludes with Fear Street Part 3: 1666 and here's a guide to the cast of new and returning characters. Directed and co-written by Leigh Janiak, the installments bring R.L. Stine's popular Fear Street novels to the screen. Released weekly, the Netflix saga tells a single cross-generational story across three chapters that comprise a different genre of horror. As a result, not only does it blur the lines between movie and television but the Fear Street trilogy starts a new trend of young adult horror adaptations.
Released on July 2, 2021, the brutal action kicks off with Fear Street Part 1: 1994. Homaging a range of classic 90s teen slasher movies, the movie follows a group of teens as they incur the wrath of an ancient evil. Having maintained a curse on Shadyside, Ohio for over 300 years, that evil dispatches a variety of killers from the town's dark history. Those include the newly-undead form of the Skull Mask Killer and the ax-wielding Nightwing Killer. Though several lose their lives in increasingly brutal ways, a trio survives the harrowing night and makes it to the shocking ending of Fear Street Part 1: 1994 — only for the curse to take a new form.
Picking up where things left off, Fear Street Part 2: 1978 dropped on July 9, 2021. As Deena and Josh seek to restore Sam, they meet with the reclusive C. Berman. They learn from her the details of what happened at Camp Nightwing in 1978. Equally depicted in an extended flashback, teens are similarly hunted by newly-relentless killers. In the process, the tale reveals a way to potentially end the curse once and for all. As per the nursery rhyme, Deena reunites the bones of Sarah Fier with her long-lost hand. Rather than put demons to rest, however, the ending of Fear Street Part 2: 1978 sees Deena cast (á la Quantum Leap) back to 1666 and dropped into Sarah Fier's body. With the time period further peppered with familiar Fear Street faces, the origins of the Shadyside Curse are set to be revealed. Here's a breakdown of Fear Street Part 3: 1666's cast and the (in some cases dual) roles that they play.
Fear Street 1666's New Characters
- Kiana Madeira as Sarah Fier - The resident veterinary midwife of Union (Shadyside's original name) destined to be infamously executed for witchcraft. Madeira is also known for playing Moe Truax in Trinkets and Spencer Young on The Flash.
- Benjamin Flores Jr. as Henry - Sarah's brother and fellow farmhand. Flores Jr. also plays Eugene in Bryan Cranston's Showtime series: Your Honor.
- Olivia Scott Welch as Hannah Miller - The Pastor's daughter and Sarah's love. Welch is best known for playing Heather Nill on Amazon Prime's Panic.
- Julia Rehwald as Lizzie - A fellow Union resident and sardonic friend of Sarah's. Rehwald is best known for also playing the ill-fated Kate in Fear Street Part 1: 1994.
- Fred Hechinger as Isaac - Sarah's more hedonistic friend. Hechinger also plays Simon in Fear Street Part 1: 1994 and Ethan Russell in The Woman in the Window
- Emily Rudd as Abigail Berman - Sarah's reportedly promiscuous friend. Rudd also plays Cindy in Fear Street Part 2: 1978 and Heidi on The CWs Dynasty remake.
- Sadie Sink as Constance Berman - Abigail's cheerful younger sister. Sink also plays the younger Ziggy in Fear Street Part 2: 1978 and Max Mayfield on Stranger Things.
- Ashley Zukerman as Solomon Goode - Nick Goode's luckless and grief-stricken ancestor. The actor is best known for playing Nate Sofrelli on HBO's Succession and assuming the Robert Langdon role from Tom Hanks in The Lost Symbol adaptation.
- McCabe Slye as Mad Thomas - Union's resident superstitious and preachy alcoholic. Slye also played the tragic Tommy (a.k.a. The Nightwing Killer) in Fear Street Part 2: 1978 and Ryan in 2018's Nicole Kidman-starring crime drama movie: Destroyer.
- Jordana Spiro as The Widow - A reclusive healer and another suspected witch. Spiro also plays Sarah Weller on Blindspot and Rachel on Ozark.
- Matthew Zuk as Elijah Goode - Solomon's brother and town alderman. Zuk's credits include Negative Man on Doom Patrol.
- Michael Chandler as Cyrus Miller - Union's Pastor, driven mad by the curse. Chandler's previous credits include superhero drama The Gifted and The Conners sitcom.
- Charlene Amoia as Beth Kimball - Another Union resident. Amoia appears with Maya Hawke in Fear Street Part 1: 1994's opening and plays Judy Glatzel in the appropriately titled 2021 horror sequel The Conjuring 3: The Devil Made Me Do It.
- Lacy Camp as Grace Miller - Hannah's disapproving mother. Camp also plays Sam's similar mother in Fear Street Part 1: 1994 and Mrs. Vickers on Vice Principals.
- Jeremy Ford as Caleb - Union's vengeful, wannabe witch-hunter. Ford also plays Peter in Fear Street Part 1: 1994, and Logan on The Mosquito Coast.
- Randy Havens as George Fier - Sarah and Henry's father. Havens is best known for playing helpful science teacher Mr. Clarke on Stranger Things.
- Todd Allen Durkin as The Watchman - As per his title, Union's guard. Durkin is known for playing Martin on The Resident and dual appearances in Doom Patrol.
Fear Street 1666's Returning Characters
- Gillian Jacobs as C. Berman (a.k.a Ziggy) - The Camp Nightwing survivor returns, fully helping Deena and Josh to try and end the curse. The actress is best known for playing Britta Perry on all six seasons (but not yet a movie) of Community. Regardless, Jacobs has had notable roles since Community ended, on screens big and small.
- Kiana Madeira also returns as Deena - Deena is a survivor of Fear Street Part 1: 1994, still trying to cure Sam and end the curse.
- Benjamin Flores Jr. also returns as Josh - Deena's brother and fellow survivor.
- Olivia Scott Welch also returns as Sam - Deena's girlfriend also returns, still under the thrall of Shadyside's witch.
- Ashley Zukerman also plays Sheriff Nick Goode - The adult version of Nick, now the town Sheriff reappears after being called by Ziggy.
- Darrell Britt-Gibson as Martin P. Franklin - The man Josh previously helped returns the favor by battling the new killers. Gibson plays Jermaine on HBO's Barry.
- Jordyn DiNatale as Ruby Lane - The undead Fear Street killer, Ruby Lane, returns with her song to help terrorize the residents of Shadyside one more time in Fear Street Part 3: 1666. DiNatale also plays Rory on The Birch.
- Kevin Waterman as Henry "The Milkman" Rooker - Another terrifying figure from Shadyside's past. Waterman plays the infamous Florida Man in Atlanta and performed stunts on a whole range of movies, including Black Widow.
- Emily Brobst as Billy Barker - A third previously-possessed Shadyside killer that returns for a final turn at-bat. The stunt performer and actress is credited in everything from TV shows like Big Little Lies to cinematic blockbusters like X-Men: Dark Phoenix.
- Jordana Spiro also features as Nurse Mary Lane - Camp Nightwing's former nurse and Ruby Lane's mother returns following the easter egg-laden Fear Street Part 2: 1978.
- Matthew Zuk also appears as Adult Will Goode - The adult version of Will, now the Sunnyvale Mayor.
- Todd Allen Durkin also stars as Officer Kapinski - An incompetent officer that works with Sheriff Goode.
- Lloyd Pitts as The Nightwing Killer - The infamous killer from the Camp Nightwing Massacre. Pitts takes back over embodying the role from Slye for the Fear Street conclusion. Pitts is known for his work as an actor and stunt person on MCU offerings such as WandaVision and Spider-Man: No Way Home.
- Keil Oakley Zepernick as Isaac "Shame Killer" Milton - Yet another figure from Shadyside's cursed past makes his first direct appearance. Zepernick's credits include Thunder Force and The Falcon and the Winter Soldier.
- Noah Garrett as Skull Mask Killer - The original killer from Fear Street Part 1: 1994 returns. Newcomer Noah Garrett assumes the role, making his debut.
- Elizabeth Scopel as The Real Sarah Fier - The infamous witch loomed over the events Fear Street Part 1: 1994 and Fear Street Part 2: 1978. Following that, Sarah Fier makes even more of a direct appearance as both hers and Shadyside's story is further illuminated and brought full circle in Fear Street Part 3: 1666. Scopel's past credits also include Chicago Med, guest-starring as Britt Mills.
