Dancing With The Stars season 31 contestants Gabby Windey and Vinny Guadagnino seemed to exchange flirtatious Instagram comments following Gabby’s recent split with fiancé Erich Schwer, and fans are noticing. Vinny was partnered with Koko Iwasaki until his elimination during “90’s Night,” while Gabby is still in the running for the Mirrorball Trophy with her partner, Val Chmerkovskiy. Gabby and Erich ended their engagement in early November, and she confirmed their split during post-show interviews following the November 14 episode of DWTS, where she cited differences in their goals and places in their lives.

Page Six reported that when Gabby posted a celebratory video about making it into the finale of DWTS, Vinny left a comment that surprised and excited many fans. Vinny wrote, “Good job Baby Mamma” to which Gabby replied, “My main man.” Fans immediately noticed the exchange and commented “Okay wait a second...I’m entirely here for this,” while another wrote, “I’m so on board with team VinnyGabby.” The flirty exchange did not end there as Gabby and Vinny swapped comments on his Instagram page.

Related: Why Gabby Windey Could Win Dancing With The Stars Season 31

DWTS Fans Rooting For Vinny & Gabby After Flirty Comments

Vinny Guadagnino and Koko Iwasaki's DWTS Halloween Night performance

DWTS contestant Vinny posted an image of him lounging on a couch looking outside a floor-to-ceiling window and gazing at the New York City skyline. The caption read, “Stop looking for the one...be the one, and let them all come to you.” Gabby left a short but direct comment, which simply stated “Omw,” meaning on my way. Vinny did not let the flirty comment go unnoticed; he wrote back, “Patiently waiting while you kill the finale.” Once again, fans erupted with adulation in the comments, writing, “Pleaseee make it happen!!!!” Another Instagram user pleaded, “I hope this [is] a real thing and if she wins the finale I hope you announce it then a girl can only hope.

Vinny and Gabby are both known to have a good sense of humor, so this may just be a running joke between the pair. However, if the flirty banter is a hint at something more serious happening between the duo, the public has spoken and expressed their approval. While initial reactions are mostly positive, there will surely be critics who disapprove of how quickly this connection seems to be forming after Gabby’s breakup. Some may even believe the comments are inappropriate, even if it is simply a joke.

Fans will surely be glued to Vinny and Gabby’s Instagram profiles for more social media exchanges and any possible reaction from Erich. Vinny may also be in attendance at the DWTS season 31 finale, where fans may get a hint as to whether their flirtation translates in person as well. Perhaps Gabby and Vinny’s chemistry while competing on DWTS together was a factor in her breakup with Erich all along that is just now coming to light.

Dancing With The Stars streams Mondays at 8 p.m. EST on Disney+.

More: All Dancing With The Stars Week 9 Semi-Finals Leaderboard Rankings

Sources: Gabby Windey/Instagram, Vinny Guadagnino/Instagram, Page Six