Dragon Ball Super introduced a whole line of divinity to the Dragon Ball canon and the multitude of gods are attended to by a multitude of angels, like Whis. The effeminate, neck-haloed Whis is bound to the God of Destruction Beerus and doesn’t seem bothered by his lord’s constant temper tantrums that often end with Beerus wiping out whole civilizations. Whis doesn’t even try to prevent the mass genocides, so is he really an actual angel or more of the fallen angel variety? 

Whis, and the purple cat god Beerus, were introduced in the manga early on and stopped by Earth after Beerus became interested in the legend of a Super Saiyan God. Goku stumbles his way through offending the God of Destruction and picks a fight with Beerus only to have the threat of annihilation hanging over the Earth. Whis does nothing to get in the way of this and sits down to enjoy some Earth cuisine. He’s at best benevolent, but Whis seems to have no problem with all life being wiped out of existence by Beerus. 

Related: Does Goku's Ultra Instinct Form Make Him Unkillable?

Beerus has a malevolent streak and wantonly blows up planets if the mood strikes him, as it often does, but both he and Whis are easily swayed by culinary delicacies, as they are both avowed foodies. Whis doesn’t often offer critiques of Beerus’ behavior, but early in the manga, Beerus blows up half a planet when the food he is served is too greasy. Beerus earlier remarked on the tastiness of the dishes but decided to halve the planet anyway. Whis showed concern, but it wasn’t as much for the immense loss of life, as much as it was over the perceived unfairness of the deal. 

Whis seems to have some understanding of right and wrong, but doesn’t insert himself—or Beerus—into the frequent potentially-world-ending fights Goku finds himself in. But this rule of non-involvement turns out to be very bendable. Goku’s old nemesis Frieza returns to Earth in a brand new form as Golden Frieza (copying Goku’s Super Saiyan form) and blows up the planet. However, Whis ended up reversing time, allowing Vegeta to kill Frieza. So is Whis a demon? Or are his morals pliable? His excuse for reversing time was to save the delicious food on Earth, but does he have a soft spot for more than just succulent food stuffs?

Whis is clearly privileged with special knowledge as Beerus often defers to his attendant’s expertise. And Whis is an experienced martial artist, training Beerus, Goku and Vegeta. His divine powers are not in question. But his aloof personality and similarly withdrawn attitude toward mass homicide don’t make him a very noble character. And when the (real?) god over all the other gods, Zenos, decides to wipe out all life except the multiverse’s angels, Whis is just as pleased as ever, even rubbing it in Beerus’ face, betraying the millennia he has spent with Beerus.

Angels in Dragon Ball Super are held to a code of conduct that requires them to be indifferent to ordinary lives. So it makes sense why Whis is so aloof. But he often breaks with that tradition by training Goku and Vegeta as well as saving Earth, rooting for the Earthlings and showing concern for the universe if Earth is threatened. He may not be a “good” angel but he’s certainly not a demon. He may feign detachment, but it’s not just Earth’s cuisine that Whis is protecting. 

Next: Dragon Ball Super Reveals A Forgotten Fighter With The Power Of A God