What If Disney-Marvel Buys Superman?

Disney has purchased Marvel Comics and we're all still trying wrap our heads around what it will mean for the future of some of our favorite comic book heroes. Well, I was in the shower last night washing my hair (TMI?) and somewhere in that shampoo veil a question occurred to me: Will Disney-Marvel try to sign Superman in 2013?

If that question has you scratching your head, allow me to catch you up on some of the Screen Rant articles you should've been reading(!) and break down for you why this Disney/Marvel grab for Superman is not nearly as implausible as it might seem.


OK, so DC Comics and Warner Bros. have been in a decade-long legal dispute with the heirs of Superman creators Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. Recently WB lost the rights to use Superman's origin story in any films or shows, and a judge has already ruled that in 2013, the rights to the character revert entirely back to the estates of Siegel and Shuster.

This will essentially make Superman a "free agent," not tied to any comic book company or comic book universe.  Of course, anybody with a toddler's business sense would naturally assume that DC/WB is working out a deal to retain Superman - after all he is their flagship character and still the most beloved superhero in the world (yes, Batman fans, our dark icon still has not surpassed Big Blue).

I'll tell you up front: I don't know anybody involved with this lawsuit, personally or professionally; I haven't gone over all the legal fine print with a microscope; and really, I am nothing in this situation other than an outsider (WAY outsider) looking in. But I can say this: Maybe DC/WB is working out a deal to retain Superman, and maybe they aren't. After all, there is PLENTY of reason for the Siegel/Shuster heirs to want to part ways with Warner Bros. and never look back.  Personally, I've already been wondering just how attractive of an option Marvel would be (I even asked Stan Lee about it!) - but now, with Marvel backed by the fat purse of Disney, I don't even have to wonder: I have only to listen to the one thought in the Siegel/Shuster heirs' minds: Cha-Ching!



Our own Paul Young spelled it out for you in his Disney/Marvel's future article: Disney is a pro at making smart buys and developing them into massive success stories (ABC's Lost and Pixar, for example) - Do you really think the House of the Mouse hasn't already had Marvel under a microscope, watching what's worked, what's been wasted, and what would best maximize their profitability? Do you really think a man as wily as Disney C.E.O. Roger Iger wouldn't be looking at all the ways (read: angles) that could catapult Marvel into a higher stratosphere of success than it has ever reached?

Let's just assume that Disney has been doing just that for a moment. What better coup d’état could there be than snagging Superman at what could, conceivably, be the one time in our lifetimes when Big Blue is free to play for another team? And if Disney/Marvel could pull off the deal, how could any other superhero venture even HOPE to rival them?

Remember that the Disney suits aren't fanboys (most of them at least) and don't have the same kind of reverence for continuity and comic book mythology and all that great stuff. They don't care that Superman and Batman are pals; they don't care if we ever find out what was up with Lois Lane's son in Superman Returns; and they don't care if Lex Luthor is going to ever return on Smallville. These guys see opportunity for growth and profit and staying ahead of the competition. They also know (if they're smart) that they just got a whole bunch of creative comic book guys on payroll who have either worked with Superman before, or have been itching to try him out and (gasp!) maybe even make the character relevant again for the masses.

And would Superman getting a fresh start in a new camp really be such a tragedy? Sure, like any custody battle the transitional period would be a little strange, a little awkward (how DO you write Superman out of the DC Universe and into the Marvel one?) but once the dust has settled just imagine some of the pros:

Continue reading 'What if Disney-Marvel Buys Superman?'

1 2
Justice League: Zack Snyder Supports HIS Batman With New Image

More in Movie News