Disney Infinity was the Toys-to-life crossover game that brought the worlds of Disney animation, Pirates Of The Caribbean, Marvel, Star Wars, and more together. With all these classic and modern characters brought together in a vinyl toy aesthetic, it showed so much ambition while appealing to kids and adults alike.
When Disney Infinity was sadly discontinued, people coveted the figures of the characters to either collect as decorative ornaments or play as in the still functioning game. Those who seek to finish their collection or simply want to get into gathering the Infinity figures might run into a snag as some of these figures are very rare to find and rather expensive to purchase.
Jack Skellington (Disney Infinity 1.0)
Ranging from about $10 to $25 dollars, the Pumpkin King is rarely ever spotted online. This is mostly due to the love for the character of Jack Skellington and how well the skeletal character was translated into Disney Infinity's unique art style while keeping Tim Burton's signature gothic aesthetic.
Fans of The Nightmare Before Christmas and/or gamers looking for a bit of Halloween fun can enjoy displaying Jack on a shelf or playing as him in The Nightmare Before Christmas playset which can be found online as well. As a playable character, Jack is useful as a stealthy character who can employ his long legs to run great distances.
Phineas (Disney Infinity 1.0)
It shows the popular impact Phineas & Ferb has had when it has crossed over with multiple Disney properties on their show and characters such as Phineas and Agent P made it into Disney Infinity. Of all the characters to get the Disney Infinity treatment, Phineas stands out the most as feeling out of place due to the drastically different art styles between the show and the game.
The flat triangular design of Phineas in the show looks a bit awkward in the 3D art style, making Phineas look too conical. That said, fans of the show still bought up the figure, and currently, Phineas is usually priced from $10 to $30 on sites such as eBay.
Sam Flynn (Disney Infinity 3.0)
Many characters from Disney Infinity 3.0 are rare since it was the phase that lasted the least amount of time due to the game's abrupt discontinuation. Tron Legacy's Sam Flynn was one such character. His Identity Disc-inspired base was brought to life in the Disney Infinity art style beautifully while still keeping the visual appeal of the cult classic, which was one of Disney's infamous flops that deserved more attention from fans. Online, Flynn can be found for prices from $15 to $50 and is worth the elevated price due to his unique power set and striking futuristic aesthetic.
Alice (Disney Infinity 3.0)
In an interesting choice, instead of trying to perfectly replicate how Alice looked in the classic 1951 Disney animated film, she was given a modernized design with fingerless gloves, curly hair, and a more elegant yet streamlined dress akin to the Tim Burton version seen in the 2010 live-action version of Alice In Wonderland.
This was likely a sign that other Disney princesses would have received similar modern redesigns if Disney Infinity had not been discontinued. Those that still want Alice can find the figure on eBay with prices ranging from $15 to $50.
Ant-Man (Disney Infinity 3.0)
Since Ant-Man had a supporting role in 2015's Captain America: Civil War, the character's sleeker design was based on the way he looked in the movie to capitalize on that film's commercial success. The character's bulky helmet and exaggerated proportions translated well to the Infinity art style and his gameplay incorporated his shrinking powers in an entertaining way.
Not only is Ant-Man hard to find but he's also a bit pricey, ranging from $15 to $50 online. A sobering fact is that had Disney Infinity continued, Ant-Man could have been transformed into anyone of his alternate comic book personas such as Yellowjacket, Wasp, and even Hank Pym AKA the original Ant-Man.
Captain America: The First Avenger (Disney Infinity 3.0)
The base Captain America from Disney Infinity 2.0 was definitely a good attempt at creating the hero in the game's slightly cartoonish style. However, the second Captain America figure released in Infinity 3.0 was more inspired by the later designs of Chris Evans' patriotic Avenger from Avengers: Age Of Ultron to make it unique and relevant to the then-current sequel.
The figure itself definitely appealed to fans with the Chris Evans-esque design with a dynamic pose, holding Captain America's iconic vibranium disc shield in a fashion identical to one of the posters for The First Avenger. This more epic version of the Star-Spangled hero is typically spotted online for an average of $20 to $50.
Hulkbuster (Disney Infinity 3.0)
Ranging from $20 to $90, the Hulkbuster was released for Disney Infinity's Marvel Battlegrounds expansion. Fans of the game always gravitated towards bigger figures in the three phases such as the symbiotic anti-hero Venom, the Disney animated hero Wreck-It-Ralph, and yes, Hulkbuster.
Hulkbuster is an iconic suit from the comics and the movies, so it is definitely a challenge to find him online due to its popularity with fans. However, if he is found, he makes for some of the more beautiful figures to have on display, thanks to the number of details put into the large figure's design such as the signature dome head and oversized chestplate.
Black Suit Spider-Man (Disney Infinity 3.0)
Even though the comics feature many other black suits for Spider-Man, everyone gravitates towards the symbiote suit as it's one of the most iconic outfits in the Marvel hero's wardrobe. The costume proved to be so popular that Disney Infinity released two versions of it with the second release for Disney Infinity 3.0 after being exclusive to the PS Vita starter pack.
When the Black Suit Spider-Man was re-released separately, fans flocked right to it. Since the black suit is so beloved, very few want to be rid of it. As a result, the prices range from $50 to $120. It is a beautiful translation of the ebony costume with a jet shade of black that faithfully replicates the version commonly drawn in the comics.
Light FX Kylo Ren (Disney Infinity 3.0)
Despite the love for characters such as the always iconic Obi-Wan Kenobi and Luke Skywalker, Sith characters such Darth Vader and Darth Maul were some of the most anticipated figures. The rare Light FX figures had lightsabers actually lit up when placed on the portal were sought after by both Disney and Star Wars fans.
With Kylo Ren sporting the unique Star Wars crossguard lightsaber, many sought and kept the figure to themselves. It's not impossible to find the Light FX version online but with prices ranging from $50 to $120, the game piece is one of the more expensive Infinity figures.
Sorcerer Mickey Mouse (Disney Infinity 1.0)
From the beginning, The Sorcerer's Apprentice variant of Mickey Mouse was already a challenge to get. This character was exclusively sold at Disney's D23 Expo in 2013, which meant that the supply was limited to that convention's lucky attendees. If it was found for sale outside of D23, it was likely someone was going to charge a lot for it due to the limited availability of the figure.
The game piece itself is a nice replication of the famous segment from Fantasia, which translates into the Disney Infinity art style well. This rare figure has been spotted on sites such as eBay ranging from $50 to over $200 as fans are eager to own and play as one of Mickey's most famous characters.
Peter Pan (Unreleased)
Peter Pan figures were made and scheduled to be released but when Disney Infinity was discontinued, he never made it to stores. However, some figures for him were found and made their way online. While technically an unofficial release, the figure is the rarest Infinity figure of them all due to the very nature of its canceled product release.
Prices for the Peter Pan figure on eBay range from $200 to well over $1000. This pricing is a tad ridiculous seeing how Peter cannot function when placed on the portal without a PC mod. That said, the game piece itself is a nice representation of the design from the original 1953 animated film and is a worthy addition to an Infinity fan's collection.