Screen Rant

  • Every year, Brooklyn Nine-Nine has a Halloween Heist to determine the Ultimate Detective/Human/Genius. 1 / 7

  • Jake won the first heist, outsmarting Captain Holt. 2 / 7

    Brooklyn Nine Nine Halloween Heist Vertical 7

  • Holt came back strong in the second Halloween Heist, defeating Jake. 3 / 7

  • Annoyed at being left out of the game, Amy won the third Halloween Heist. 4 / 7

  • Gina fooled everyone by switching the plaques in "Halloween IV" 5 / 7

    Brooklyn Nine Nine Halloween Heist Vertical 8

  • Jake used the fifth Halloween Heist to set up his marriage proposal to Amy - though Holt technically won. 6 / 7

  • And finally, Terry won the first event set during Cinco de Mayo! 7 / 7