Was Queen Charlotte actually black? Bridgerton and Queen Charlotte may be works of fiction, but their portrayal of Queen Charlotte is surprisingly true to history - and she may well have been Black. Inspired by a series of novels by Julia Quinn, Bridgerton and Queen Charlotte tell the interweaving stories of Regency and Georgian era powerful families. Romances blossom, power plays sweep through social events, and everyone looks stunning. Intriguing, Bridgerton never explored the issue of Queen Charlotte's ethnicity, as it was merely part of an established alternate world of racial equality.
Unlike Bridgerton, Queen Charlotte directly addresses issues of race, no doubt drawing uneasy parallels between the real world story of Meghan Markle and Prince Harry for some viewers (particularly in terms of questions over skin tone). This is an important change, and one handled very smartly by drawing Charlotte's ethnicity into a wider story about power and society: particularly as it never arises as an issue even once between King George and Queen Charlotte themselves. But even with that blindspot, Charlotte is asked to realize her importance to racial equality - a question that sits as prominently in 2023 as it does in the 1780s in-universe.
Was The Real Queen Charlotte Black? Theory Explained
It's important to note that Shonda Rhimes has never claimed that Queen Charlotte is a true history - in fact, quite the opposite. But that hasn't stopped speculation, including questions of whether the real Queen Charlotte was black. Somewhat surprisingly, there is an enduring theory that King George III's wife may indeed have been dark-skinned.
Historians are actually divided about whether or not Queen Charlotte was Black. The theory was popularized by Mario De Valdes y Cocom, who believes Charlotte was descended from a Black branch of the Portuguese royal family: Alfonso III and his concubine, Ouruana. "Alfonso III of Portugal conquered a little town named Faro from the Moors," Valdes told The Washington Post. "He demanded [the governor’s] daughter as a paramour. He had three children with her." According to Valdes, one of these children married into Queen Charlotte's family. And he points to portraits suggesting Charlotte was indeed Black, although frequently he believes artists whitewashed her appearance, as Queen Charlotte itself depicts through Princess Augusta.
On the other side of the argument, modern historian Lisa Hilton told the Express that the theory is bunk: “There is not and has not been any evidence that Queen Charlotte was black. No, there was no black branch of the Portuguese Royal Family. Queen Charlotte was not black and I can keep repeating it.”
Evidence For The Theory That Queen Charlotte Was Really Black
Further supporting evidence that Queen Charlotte was black may come from the critical way in which she was treated. "She was famously ugly," Desmond Shawe-Taylor, surveyor of the Queen's pictures, told The Guardian. "One courtier once said of Charlotte late in life: 'Her Majesty's ugliness has quite faded.' There was quite a miaow factor at court." It's quite possible these criticisms actually reflected racist attitudes in British society, because certainly some of the insults sound like racial slurs. Sir Walter Scott described Queen Charlotte and her siblings as being "ill-colored, orang-outang looking figures, with black eyes and hook-noses."
Historians are divided about Valdes' theory, with many dismissing it outright. There's actually quite a generational distance between Queen Charlotte and her Black ancestor, so many argue she would not have inherited any so-called "African characteristics." More to the point, the British Museum holds a number of popular caricatures of Queen Charlotte, and none of these portray her as Black. Still, in spite of the criticisms, the theory can't really be disproven and the question remains unsettled.
Bridgerton and Queen Charlotte are, therefore, fascinating windows into a what-if world; what if Queen Charlotte really was Black? How would Regency England have reacted to that, and would Charlotte have taken advantage of the opportunity to elevate others who were Black as well - notably Simon, Duke of Hastings? "Putting that person at the top of the triangle, as a person of color, allows you to expand the boundaries," Rosheuvel explained in an interview with Insider. "The possibility for Black characters to love, to be passionate, to be seen in high status. You allow all that space to happen if you have somebody, who was ruling the country as a person of color."
Whatever the truth may be in this matter, Queen Charlotte isn't potentially even the first mixed-race Queen in British history. Another theory suggests Philippa of Hainault (1314-69), consort of Edward III, had African ancestry as well. Bridgerton certainly suggests British history books have been whitewashed a whole lot more than people may think.
What Is The Great Experiment - Did It Really Exist?
Queen Charlotte introduces the idea of a Great Experiment as a politically motivated move to unite all races of people in the ton, in the name of strengthening the country. Along with Charlotte's betrothal to George - which is not based on her skin color but the value of alliance with her country - Princess Augusta orchestrates peerages for each of the powerful black and other minority race families in the ton (including Simon Bassett's parents and the Smythe-Smiths). This is essentially the first steps to ending racism and racial inequality in Bridgerton's universe - something the original show established as fact without explaining.
There is no evidence to suggest that there was a Great Experiment in the United Kingdom's Regency Era in the same way Queen Charlotte depicts. While slavery may have been abolished in the UK in 1807 (within the Bridgerton timeline), racial equality was a distant hope. It is important, however, to acknowledge London's black community, which - according to author Vanessa Riley's research - amounted to at least 20,000 people in the era. The idea of peerages given out by the Crown to solidify relationships and remove divide may have been the right answer to speed up real world progression, but it is the stuff of fiction, written for Bridgerton and Queen Charlotte.