Black Panther fans have been demanding Marvel Studios to recast T'Challa in the MCU for the upcoming Black Panther: Wakanda Forever following the tragic death of actor Chadwick Boseman. Black Panther made his MCU debut in 2016's Captain America: Civil War, and was immediately a fan-favorite. However, since Boseman's passing, there has been uncertainty around the future of the character, with many fans now calling for a replacement.

2018's solo Black Panther film became a cultural sensation and went on to become one of the most successful MCU films with a worldwide box office gross of 1.35 billion US dollars. Black Panther's role in the MCU only became more pivotal after he played a major part in Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame. Unfortunately, the world received the sad news of Chadwick Boseman's passing in August of 2020 after privately battling cancer for years. Four months later, during Disney's Investor Day presentation, Kevin Feige confirmed that T'Challa won't be recast for Black Panther 2 and that director Ryan Coogler was working on a film that will honor Boseman's legacy and focus more on the rest of Wakanda. Any statement made on such a sensitive topic would have been controversial, but after the decision to not recast was given time to marinate, it seems that fans disagree with Marvel Studios.

Related: Denzel Washington's Perfect Final Movie Would Be A Black Panther Sequel

Over the past year, a petition demanding recasting T'Challa picked up over Fifty Thousand signatures, and the hashtag #RecastTchalla was trending on social media for some time. The conversation around recasting T'Challa is an important one, and it seems that the consensus is in favor of the recast. Many believe that recasting the character is the correct way to honor Boseman's legacy, rather than letting the character of T'Challa fade away. Additionally, fans of the character understand his importance to the MCU and to people around the world as well, and would like to see him continue his contribution to the MCU.

T'challa looking up against a night sky in Black Panther

Marvel Studios probably elected not to recast T'Challa to avoid any comparisons between Boseman and whoever plays Black Panther next, to honor Boseman's memory. However, some claim that allowing the character to fade into nothingness would be a disservice to the work that Boseman put into perfecting the role. By contrast, advocates suggest, continuing the character's arc with a new face is the best way to appreciate what Boseman brought to the role and ensure that his legacy lives on through the character of Black Panther.

Another argument used by those in favor of the recast is the importance of Black Panther in the MCU. T'Challa was poised to be one of the leaders of the New Avengers, and the new face of the MCU alongside Tom Holland's Spider-Man and Benedict Cumberbatch's Doctor Strange. Moreover, there are plenty of Black Panther stories that are yet to be told in live-action, not the least of which is the war between Wakanda and Atlantis. Black Panther was also important outside of the fictional shared universe. The impact of the first Boseman-led film proved the importance of diversity in the MCU, and how significant of a change Black Panther's inclusion made on people around the world.

Ultimately, good reasoning can be found on both sides of the debate. As Wakanda Forever inches closer, this discussion is bound to gain more traction, perhaps enough traction to warrant another comment from Marvel Studios explaining their position. Fans of the character and the MCU have made it clear that they are in favor of recasting thee T'Challa, which would have a lot of benefits and would in no way tarnish Chadwick Boseman's legacy. Details around Black Panther: Wakanda Forever remain scarce, but with less than 10 months until release, information is bound to start trickling out, finally clearing up how the creative team behind the film is attempting to continue the Black Panther franchise without their Black Panther.

More: Marvel's Next 6 Movies Are All MCU Sequels: Why That's A Problem

Key Release Dates