Should there be another Big Brother: All-Stars season, fans already know which past players they would want to compete. So far, there have been two All-Star seasons in the history of the show. The first was Big Brother season 7 in 2006. Then, during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the production brought back another cast of former players for the show's second All-Star season.
The most recent All-Star season consisted of some fan-favorite past players as well as some houseguests that fans did not like at all. Big Brother season 16 runner-up Cody Calafiore ultimately took home the then half-a-million-dollar grand prize, becoming the second All-Star season winner. Although the season aired two years ago, Big Brother fans in the Reddit thread started by u/Justin32526jshx are already discussing which players they would like to see make a return to the house for a third All-Star season, some of which already won the game before.
Fans Want To See Big Brother Legends Return
The list of houseguests ranges from older seasons to the most recent season this past summer. The potential houseguests that have been out of the game the longest include Big Brother season 3 winner Lisa Donahue, James Rhine of Big Brother 6, and Big Brother legend Danielle Reyes. Danielle competed alongside Lisa in season 3 before returning for the first all-star season. Lisa was rumored to return for Big Brother season 22, while James declined the offer due to the pandemic.
Another player that has not been in the Big Brother house for quite some time that fans would like to see return is Hayden Moss, who won Big Brother season 12. Fans would also like to see other houseguests return who weren't fan favorites during their original season, such as Paul Abrahamian, Big Brother season 19 winner Josh Martinez and Big Brother season 20 winner Kaycee Clark. Other past winners that could return include Rachel Reilly as well as the most recent Big Brother winner Taylor Hale.
The remaining players on fans' dream All-Star cast list also include Brett Robbinson, Kyland Young, Derek Xiao, Michael Bruner, Vanessa Rousso, Jessica Nickson, and Tiffany Mitchell. While it would be awesome to see a group of familiar faces return to the Big Brother house again, there has been no talk of a third all-star season from CBS. Despite this, there is still a possibility it could happen in the future. As longtime host, Julie Chen Moonves always says, "Expect the unexpected" inside the Big Brother house.
Source: u/Justin32526jshx/Reddit