Despite its popularity with fans and critics alike, Batman: The Animated Series was canceled in the midst of its run. Even if a show ends up being a success with audiences or critics, it can still come to an end for any number of reasons. That was the case with Batman: The Animated Series, but the reasons for its ending aren’t completely without logic.

Premiering in 1992, Batman: The Animated Series quickly won the hearts of fans and critics alike as an adaptation of the Batman mythos with writing that pushed the boundaries of what was expected of a children’s cartoon at the time. The show was nominated for, and won, multiple awards during its run, including winning four Emmy Awards, and its popularity even led to major changes in the comics such as changing Batman villain Mr. Freeze from a generic thug into a textbook tragic villain and the canonization of Harley Quinn. With its mature and serious depiction of the Batman mythos that also maintained a lot of charm and heart, the show has managed to remain in high regard with fans and critics alike nearly thirty years after it originally premiered.

Related: Mark Hamill's Favorite Batman: TAS Episodes Explained

In spite of that, Batman: The Animated Series was still ultimately canceled in 1999 for a couple of reasons. First and foremost, the show had a major problem with garnering ratings. In December 1992, three months after its debut, Fox started airing new episodes on prime-time Sunday evenings, but they fell short of expectations due to the show having to compete with 60 Minutes airing at the same time, and it went back to airing solely on weekday afternoons in March 1993. A year later in 1994, Batman: The Animated Series was retooled as The Adventures of Batman & Robin and featured Robin, one of the more popular characters, more prominently, but ratings still fell short, especially with it now only airing on Saturday mornings. The show ended in 1995, but was revived in 1997 as The New Batman Adventures and aired in an hour-long block with Superman: The Animated Series, but the show still wasn’t getting great ratings, and when it was canceled again in 1999, it stayed canceled.

Batman Animated Series Book Art

Ratings played a big part in the show’s ending, but what was probably factored in the most was the creators simply not wanting to do it anymore. According to Kevin Conroy, the voice of Batman in the show and many other adaptations of the character over the years (via ComicBook), the reason that the creators of the show—Paul Dini, Bruce Timm, and Alan Burnett, among others—stopped working on it was that they “ran out of ideas for stories”. Conroy said that they “didn't want to compromise on the quality of what they had and start creating kind of silly stories,” and in that regard, it makes sense that Batman: The Animated Series would end, despite being as popular as it was; better for a story to end when the creators want to end it than drag it out and risk ruining it.

Even with Batman: The Animated Series getting canceled, its legacy still lives on. The influence it had on the Batman mythos has already been mentioned, but the show started the shared universe of the DC Animated Universe, which included Superman: The Animated Series, Batman Beyond, Static Shock, and both Justice League and Justice League Unlimited. All of those shows would go on to receive critical acclaim in their own right, and the DCAU as a whole is still held in high regard by many fans and critics alike. None of that, of course, would have been possible if it weren’t for Batman: The Animated Series.

More: Batman: TAS Can Definitively End With The Audio Drama

Key Release Dates