And just like that, the plot thickens (or at least gets more dramatic). The details surrounding the cause of the breakup of The Bachelorette couple Clare Crawley and Dale Moss continue to unfurl amidst a he-said-she-said situation. Now, the truth may be taking shape, as Dale’s supposed “mystery woman” has been identified, and it turns out she’s making risky moves on social media.

Clare and Dale’s storybook romance came crashing down when the former NFL player recently announced on Instagram that his relationship with Clare was over. After two days of radio silence from the former Bachelorette, Clare took to her Instagram account to assert that she was shocked to find out Dale ended the relationship on social media without telling her first. “I was made aware of a ‘mutual’ statement at the same time you all were, so I’ve needed some time to really digest this,” the post states. And on top of the surprise breakup accusations, rumors of Dale cheating on Clare have been buzzing around Bachelor Nation as well. Dale was spotted in NYC with a “mystery woman,” though he maintains that she is just a friend and he never cheated on Clare.  

Related: Bachelorette: Clare Crawley Says She Was Crushed By Dale’s Breakup Post

Of course, nothing remains a mystery for long, at least on social media, and E! News reports that the woman Dale was seen with is named Eleonora Srugo. Now that her identity has been revealed, part of Dale’s story checks out—he claimed he was with her in NYC because she was helping him find an apartment, and it’s true, she is a New York real estate agent. But just because that part of the story is true, doesn’t mean the whole story is, and Eleonora is exhibiting strange online behavior given the sticky situation she’s now in. A peek at Clare’s Instagram post responding to the breakup shows that Eleonora “liked” the post, which is odd considering Clare was supposedly suspicious of Eleonora and the time she was spending with Dale throughout their relationship, according to E! News

clare crawley the bachelorette

Considering that Clare and Eleonora knew about each other before the breakup, it’s notable that Eleonora doesn’t follow Clare on Instagram, though she does follow Dale. Not only does she not follow Clare, she also hasn’t “liked” Clare’s other posts—even the ones featuring Eleonora’s supposed friend Dale or Clare’s recent emotional post about her mother. Given Eleonora’s lack of input on Clare’s other pics and videos, it’s hard to see the solo like as anything other than shady.

With Eleonora now at the center of the Clare and Dale breakup drama, this could be the “like” that goes down in infamy.

Next: Bachelorette: Former Contestant Spencer Asks Clare Out After Dale Split

Source: E! News, Clare Crawley/Instagram, Eleonora Srugo/Instagram