Former The Bachelorette lead, Andi Dorfman, is denying the mystery man in her now-deleted Instagram photo is Bennett Jordan.
Andi was thrown into the spotlight after she made it all the way to overnight dates on Juan Pablo's season of The Bachelor. After that relationship failed, she went on to be The Bachelorette, where she got engaged, but ultimately ended the relationship after a short six months. Now, fans have begun speculating if she is back on the dating scene with Bennett, who was just on Tayshia Adams' season of the popular dating show.
The 33 year old recently shared a photo of herself to Instagram on a balcony holding a mug with the caption, "Afternoon anyone? Or shall we stick to margaritas." A fan then left a comment asking, "Did Kaitlyn [Bristowe] call you about Bennett?!," reported Us Weekly. Andi simply replied, "Who?" The former reality star quickly shut down rumors she was dating Bennett, who was recently eliminated off of Tayshia's season for a second time. The 36 year old, for his part, has been posting photos of himself in New York City following the dating rumors between the two. His most recent photo is of him in his bulky winter jacket not too long after the snowstorm in the city. "I think this is proper hunting for cozy cubs in the city attire?" he wrote in his caption. See his post below:
Fans have been watching Andi's social media with a close eye ever since she shared a photo of herself while on vacation in Mexico with a man's legs captured in it. After fans began to question her dating life and her new man, Andi deleted the post and uploaded a new one of just the upper part of her back with her "out of office" denim cap. The original Bachelorette, Trista Sutter, was one of many fans asking for details about her mystery man. “Wait?!! Where did your friend go?!,” she asked in the comments section. Kaitlyn Bristowe also called for the old photo to come back. “BRING BACK THEM LEGS,” she replied.
At first, fans thought the mystery man was Michael Garofalo, who appeared on Desiree's season of The Bachelorette and other shows from the franchise. However, a source from the publication commented on the rumors and revealed Michael is not the man in Andi's Instagram photo. Whoever this mystery man is, hopefully Andi has found her happily ever after. But if it isn't Bennett Jordan, who could it be?
The Bachelorette airs Monday and Tuesday at 8 pm EST on ABC.
Sources: Us Weekly, Instagram: @andidorfman