Avengers 4 Theory: Thor Dies To Complete The REAL Ragnarok

Last year's Thor: Ragnarok culminated in the destruction of Asgard - but what if the real Ragnarok requires Thor's death, and will arrive in Avengers 4? Ragnarok's title alludes to the important, cyclical apocalyptic event in Norse mythology (and a crucial storyline in the Thor comic books of the mid-00s). As in the myths, Asgard was ultimately destroyed by Surtur - albeit with the twist that the demon was actually unleashed by Thor as the only way of stopping his wayward sister Hela, the Goddess of Death.

Yet, as one savvy Redditor has pointed out, the ending of Thor: Ragnarok has the God of Thunder stating that Asgard is a people, not a place. With Ragnarok being a prophesied event - both in actual Norse mythology and within the Marvel Cinematic Universe initially - the question of whether the prophecy has fully come to pass remains open. In the original mythology, all the Norse gods die, including Thor, only to later be reborn (symbolizing the end that winter brings and the new life which dawns in the spring).

Although many Asgardians fall to Thanos and the Black Order in the opening salvo of Avengers: Infinity War, Thor is left alive (as are at least half of the other Asgardians, as partially confirmed by Tessa Thompson's character Valkyrie surviving the events of the movie). Could it be that, with Thor still breathing, Ragnarok hasn't fully come to pass? Thanos' casual murder of the Asgardians aboard their refugee vessel could have even been a continuation of the prophecy, with Thanos as an unwitting accomplice. As he says during that scene, "Dread it. Run from it. Destiny arrives all the same." So, can we expect Thor's eventual death and the culmination of the Ragnarok prophecy in Avengers 4?

This Page: Avengers 4 Could See the Conclusion of Ragnarok
Page 2: Why Thor Could Die in Avengers 4, and Why He Should Live

Ragnarok Happened in the MCU... Sort Of

Thor Ragnarok trailer shows the city and buildings of Asgard on fire

Ragnarok as an apocalyptic event for the Asgardians was initially hinted at in Avengers: Age of Ultron, when a badly-behaving Scarlet Witch subjected the team to horrifying visions preying on their fears in order to tear them apart. Thor was given a vision of himself destroying Asgard, or rather, its people - exploding them left and right with bolts of lightning. This included his friend, Heimdall. Loki was also originally meant to appear in this scene, but test screenings found his appearance confused audiences.

Whilst this vision may have been a blueprint as well as a teaser for the then-upcoming third Thor movie, it wasn't exactly the Ragnarok that was ultimately delivered. Thor was responsible for destroying Asgard, but not its people, just like vision in Age of Ultron. Elisabeth Olsen, who plays Scarlet Witch, has also gone on record stating that she doesn't believe the visions that the Avengers were subjected to necessarily culminated in what was seen in Infinity War. That said, Thor's actions in Ragnarok could be viewed as leading to the Asgardians' eventual demise at the hands of Thanos, as it made them vulnerable, all grouped together on one small ship, distinctly lacking in protection.

When considered as such, Thor destroying his fellow Asgardians himself in the Scarlet Witch's vision might be seen as a metaphor, but it's a tenuous link. After all, Thanos was probably heading to Asgard itself regardless of whether Surtur destroyed it or not, as he knew the Tesseract was stored there. His domination of them would've been the same regardless of where they were.

Yet if Asgard is truly defined by its people rather than a physical place, then Ragnarok has not fully come to pass. There are still Asgardians out there (Ragnarok no-show Sif being one of them, Thor and Valkyrie being the two obvious characters left alive), and for Ragnarok to be completed the scripture dictates that all the gods must die.

Avengers 4 Returns to Asgard In Some Form

Certain scenes have potentially been filmed for Avengers 4 in Durham Cathedral in the UK, a decidedly 'classical' location that could easily serve as an Asgardian setting. Chris Hemsworth's appearance during these scenes also indicates that we'll see a return to Asgard in some way, shape or form in Avengers 4. It could be with a flashback or time travel motif, as many cast tidbits and fan theories seem to suggest.

It could equally be a 'present day' setting, as it wouldn't be hard to dress up Durham Cathedral as a ruin. Avengers 4 could see Thor visiting the discarded remnants of the Realm Eternal, still floating aimlessly in space. The fact that a stand-in for Rocket is present during these scenes implies that another mission is underway for the God of Thunder and his 'rabbit' friend; either that, or it was a scene excised from Infinity War, what with the same characters having adventured together to Nidavellir to forge a Thanos-killing weapon. Time will tell what the reason for the Durham shoot was.

Will Avengers 4 Continue Ragnarok?

Avengers Infinity War - Thor Stabs Thanos

If Avengers 4 does indeed continue the Ragnarok plotline, resulting in Thor and the remaining Asgardians dying in battle against Thanos - or perhaps an additional enemy - the prophecy will be complete. As previously mentioned, if Asgard is its people and not a place, then those people need to all be removed from existence to fulfill the prophecy. It also doesn't necessarily mean the end for Thor, as Ragnarok is a cyclical event and always results in the return of the gods from the death they are consigned to (endlessly, for eternity).

It might be that Ragnarok was one-and-done with the events of Thor: Ragnarok. Asgard was destroyed by Surtur, and that was that. The glimpses of Thor seen in photos from the set of Avengers 4 show Hemsworth with long hair, implying there'll be a fair amount of flashbacks, or time travel - which could result in the preservation of Asgard in the future, undoing Ragnarok. This also strangely fits with the motif of the Norse apocalypse, as it is as much about rebirth as it is about death.

At this point it's unclear whether Avengers 4 will continue the Ragnarok subplot, but there are enough theories about Avengers: Infinity War and its sequel continuing Thor's new trilogy to imply that it is not yet fully over.

Page 2: Why Thor Could Die in Avengers 4, and Why He Should Live

Does Thor Need To Die to Beat Thanos & Ragnarok?

Ragnarok as a concept needs all the Asgardians to die; if Marvel wish to ascribe to this version of events, then it's understandable that Thor would be in line for the chopping block in Avengers 4. It would tie in with his character's overall arc beginning with Thor: Ragnarok and continuing through Avengers: Infinity War.

He was, after all, responsible for not delivering a killing blow to Thanos when he had the chance - instead choosing the less-immediate mortal wound so that Thanos could know who had defeated him. Thanos was ultimately still able to snap his fingers and eliminate half of all life from existence. This guilt will most likely pray very heavily on Thor's conscience going into Avengers 4, and it would make sense in a very Hollywood way for the God of Thunder to give his own life as recompense.

If he does give his life, this arguably could signal the real end to Ragnarok. Odin, Freya, Loki, Heimdall, the Warriors Three AND Thor would now all be dead, signifying a true end to Asgard as we know it.

Thor doesn't need to die to beat Thanos, but it would make a lot of poetic sense. He would need to die to fulfill the common understanding of the concept of Ragnarok - which matters little, because Ragnarok also eventually brings about the rebirth of the Asgardian gods by its own logic. Killing Thor gives Marvel a loophole to bring him back, at which point they can spin Thor off into a whole new status quo and series of adventures for Phase 4, in a truly post-Ragnarok world.

Why Thor Should Live

Of the MCU's original trinity, Chris Hemsworth's Thor is the best character to keep around. Chris Evans' time as Captain America is at an end, and Robert Downey Jr. has been operating on a film-by-film rolling contract basis for a while now, with the writing on the wall concerning his desire to move on from the MCU. Whether the characters heroically sacrifice their lives or not in Avengers 4 remains to be seen, but regardless, their absense from the MCU will leave an obvious hole for audiences looking forward to Phase 4.

Thor can continue to be one of the mainstays, especially now that the character has been reinvigorated by both Thor: Ragnarok and Avengers: Infinity War. Essentially, he's cool now - moved away from all the drab, Shakespearean, Lord-of-the-Rings-esque dialogue and plotlines. Hemsworth has taken to the comedic element of Thor under director Taika Waititi with aplomb, and the character's new role on the galactic stage of cosmic wackiness has opened up a myriad of exciting, esoteric future adventures for the character. Hemsworth himself has stated that he'll be game to continue playing Thor should the right scripts come along, and now that Marvel have really nailed the character, there's nowhere to go but up for the Mighty Thor.

Should Ragnarok come to pass in Avengers 4, resulting in Thor's death, it'll be easy to bring him back. Rebirth is as much a part of Ragnarok as death, so Marvel would get to have their cake and eat it too - allowing Thor to die valiantly finally defeating Thanos (or Annihilus, or whatever other villain will appear in Avengers 4), and to return in another Thor film with the simple explanation of "well, that's Ragnarok" - preferably with the hilarious creative genius of Waititi at the helm.