Arrowverse Theory: Earth-2 Destruction Really WAS Oliver Queen's Fault

In the Arrow season 8 premiere, Oliver Queen (Stephen Amell), the hero that started the Arrowverse, unintentionally got Earth-2 destroyed. As the final season is building up to Crisis on Infinite Earths, Oliver is working closely with the Monitor (LaMonica Garrett) to prepare for what's coming. With the Anti-Monitor active on other Earths in the Multiverse, the Monitor requires Oliver to be careful with his decisions. In order for the good guys to be one step ahead of the Anti-Monitor, Oliver has to do everything he can to not draw attention to himself. Despite the Monitor's great warning about it, Oliver, more or less, ends up being responsible for what happened to Earth-2. In the season opener "Starling City", Oliver visits Earth-2 where he encounters several doppelgangers of the people he knows.

Continue scrolling to keep reading Click the button below to start this article in quick view.

Throughout the events of the episode, Oliver is on a mission on behalf of the Monitor to find Dwarf Star particles. But Oliver gets sucked in by seeing people like his mother Moira (Susanna Thompson) and Tommy (Colin Donnell) alive. The Monitor makes it clear that Oliver can't allow himself to get involved with the lives of the people on Earth-2. By doing so, he risks the Anti-Monitor coming for that Earth. Oliver, however, tries to have the cake and eat it too by helping Laurel Lance (Katie Cassidy) stop Earth-2's version of the Undertaking from the first season. From discovering that Tommy is the Dark Archer of Earth-2, Oliver makes it his mission to save the doppelganger of his best friend.

RELATED: Arrow Season 8: Unanswered Questions & Theories Before Episode 4

As Oliver got deeper involved with the events of Earth-2, the Monitor's fear comes to fruition. After convincing Tommy to stop the Undertaking, Oliver and Diggle (David Ramsey) get ready to return to Earth-1. Once Oliver says farewell to his mother, Laurel informs Oliver and Diggle that the city is being attacked. The windows of the police station get crushed by a wave of anti-matter as everything is being destroyed. Oliver witnesses Tommy and Moira being taken by the anti-matter and he is forced to see them die for a second time. As the anti-matter completely destroys Earth-2, Oliver jumps back to Earth-1 with Diggle and Laurel. While Oliver never intended to get on the Anti-Monitor's radar, his actions caused Earth-2 to be destroyed.

With the Anti-Monitor fully active in taking one Earth after another, Earth-2 was always in danger no matter what. But had Oliver listened to the Monitor's warning and returned straightaway with the dwarf star particles, it could have allowed Earth-2 to live for a bit longer. It remains unknown if it was Oliver going for the Dwarf Star particles or his involvement with the events of Earth-2 that triggered the Anti-Monitor. It could have been as simple as Oliver being on Earth-2 that eventually led to the Anti-Monitor in destroying that world, hoping the Green Arrow would die with it.

But in one way or another, Oliver's choices on Earth-2 caused that world to die earlier than maybe they were supposed to. Following the premiere, Oliver has yet to travel to any other Earth in the Multiverse. Given how Earth-2 got destroyed, it is probably for the better that Oliver stays put for now. With only a couple of episodes left before the Crisis crossover, the clock is dangerously ticking. Currently, Oliver is collecting more information on the Monitor as the Crisis approaches. The latest episode "Leap of Faith" ended with Team Arrow witnessing the arrival of Mia (Katherine McNamara), Conner (Joseph David-Jones) and William (Ben Lewis) as they were transported from 2040 to 2019.

NEXT: Arrow: Did Thea & Talia Just Create The Justice League?

Scarlett Johansson as Black Widow and Jeremy Renner as Hawkeye with Vormir Background in Avengers Endgame
Avengers: Endgame Deleted Scene Reveals Alternate Black Widow Death (& It’s Worse)

More in SR Originals