Tara Reid in American Pie

Vicky, Kevin's girlfriend, was hesitant to take "the next step" with him in the original. But once they did, she broke off the relationship before the two separated for college, leaving him discouraged and alone.

The sequel found Kevin pining for his former love, but his feelings were unrequited. Vicky had another boyfriend when she arrived at the lake, and she broke Kevin's heart once again.

Although Reid didn't appear in Wedding, she does return for Reunion. And although Kevin's married, the sparks between the high school couple fly when the two are reunited...

Bob Odenkirk as Gene Takavic in Better Call Saul
Bob Odenkirk Confirms Fans Have Guessed Better Call Saul's Ending