Screen Rant

Which of Seth Rogen's performances in An American Pickle is better - Herschel or Ben Greenbaum? 1 / 8

Between the two, Rogen gives his best work in the movie as Herschel. 2 / 8

Rogen's portrayal of Herschel is a departure from his typical work, and is a funny contrast to Ben... 3 / 8

While his portrayal of Ben is the one audiences will likely find easier to connect to. 4 / 8

However, Herschel shows the range Rogen possesses... 5 / 8

While Ben is a more recognizable Seth Rogen performance. 6 / 8

In the end, Rogen does all-around great work in An American Pickle... 7 / 8

But his portrayal of Herschel is the stronger showcase of the full range of his talents. 8 / 8