Iconic DC butler Alfred Pennyworth once proved just how much he cared for Batman by giving him an archenemy, creating and becoming the Joker himself. Although it seems like the ultimate betrayal against the Dark Knight, Alfred might have been doing Bruce Wayne a favor.
There have been many stories diverging from the mainstream canon of the DC Universe, as depicted in Elseworlds as well as in more recent stories such as Dark Knights of Steel. However, a lesser-known alternate story contained a twist that forces readers to reconsider what they know about Batman. During a funeral for the fallen Caped Crusader, his friends remember the heroic life he led. Similarly, Batman's rogues' gallery reminisces about their encounters with the Dark Knight as well. The multi-part storyline “Whatever Happened to the Caped Crusader?” began with Batman #686, written by Neil Gaiman with art by Andy Kubert, Scott Williams, and Alex Sinclair, featuring a major twist regarding Batman's most trusted ally (Alfred) and his most hated foe (Joker).
During Batman's funeral, it was revealed that Alfred created the identity of the Joker to antagonize Batman, presenting himself as the Dark Knight’s greatest villain. The bizarre twist might appear as a betrayal, but Alfred’s motivation was actually sincere. After realizing that Batman’s other villains like Riddler and the Penguin couldn’t stand a chance against him, Alfred saw the need for a greater criminal mastermind to rise up and challenge Bruce. Putting on clown makeup and the signature purple suit, Alfred became the Joker. Armed with his maniacal smile, Alfred transformed from his role as the unassuming butler, ironically falling into a murder mystery cliché thanks to his villainous evolution.
Alfred Became The Joker To Keep Batman Busy (And Safe)
Eventually, Batman learned what had been going on, likely suspicious as he finally faced a villain who stood a chance against him. The story re-contextualized Batman’s history with Joker up until this point, as the revelation invalidated the Joker’s menace. The villain known for his chaotic motivations had been replaced with Bruce’s most trusted friend and caretaker acting out of compassion. Whereas the Joker’s plans to wreak havoc on Gotham City were never personal, Alfred’s plan as Joker was predicated on helping Batman become a greater hero— at least, in his own eyes. It also kept Bruce busy with pretend villains as opposed to actual criminals who could have killed him, invalidating Batman's own prowess as a vigilante as well.
The meta twist plays on the iconic dynamic between the Joker and Batman, as they have frequently canceled each other out as a force of chaos and a force of order. Some writers have treated their status as enemies as a dysfunctional relationship, as they’re obsessed with one another. While the Joker has fun terrorizing Gotham as a way to encounter Batman, the Dark Knight has been hinted to enjoy the fight just as much. With the reveal that Joker was Alfred the whole time, their dynamic actually makes a lot of sense.