If fans felt that Sumit Singh was the one catfishing Jenny Slatten when he met her, the 90 Day Fiancé celeb turned the tables about it on a recent 90 Day Bares All episode. Upon some prodding by his parents, Anil and Sahna, Sumit openly admitted about being shocked by Jenny’s appearance as it didn’t look like what he’d seen in her pics. But was Jenny really showing “blurry” pictures of herself to her 90 Day Fiancé lover in 2011? TLC viewers have uncovered throwback pics that prove, no, she wasn’t.

The last time fans heard of Sumit and Jenny was when season 2 of 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way showed the couple on the brink of marriage. Eventually, these plans fell through all due to his meddling mother. Jenny, 63, who’s been in a relationship with Sumit, 32, for 10 years, in spite of him catfishing her and also being married and lying about it, stayed put. Even as the 90 Day Fiancé pair found the Arya Samaj solution to marry, going against his mother was not an option for Sumit who just gave her a “promise ring’ in the finale. However, 90 Day Bares All had Sumit and Jenny face his parents through video call, where they egged him on when revealing that they wanted a “good looking” daughter in law. Jenny, who was then 53, had apparently “shocked” Sumit when he saw her the first time. As Jenny stormed off the Discovery+ show, Sumit claimed the “camera quality was not good” in 2011, which is why he didn’t get a “clear picture” of Jenny. Meanwhile, 90 Day Fiancé Jenny’s old pictures from the same year, tell a different story.

Related: 90 Day Fiancé: What We Know About Jenny Slatten's Daughters, IG, Job & More

It looked like a clear case of the pot calling the kettle black when Sumit hinted at Jenny having catfished him. Still, Jenny may have never used filters and pulled a Rebecca Parrott on him as Sumit claims. A set of photos unearthed by a 90 Day Fiancé fan on Reddit shows a visibly, 50-something Jenny confidently flaunting her age lines and wrinkles during a night out with friends. Sure, the Palm Springs granny does have make-up on, but Jenny appears to have not used any filters on her face.

After all, 2011 was 10 years ago, as a 90 Day Fiancé viewer points out, and “no one was extra super worried about catching that ‘perfect insta pic’ & were posting real pictures still." A different TLC fan taunts Sumit by commenting, “When the catfisher becomes the catfishee?” saying they do not understand how and why Sumit would have an issue as he was the one catfishing Jenny.

As fans appear concerned about Sumit and Jenny’s 90 Day Fiancé relationship, all seems to be well in their Indian paradise as per a recent Facebook update by her. “Don’t believe the rumors” said Jenny in a caption for her recent selfie with Sumit. Could it be that in Jenny’s case, love is really blind – enough for her to fall for Sumit’s frauds and lies multiple times? Or is Sumit being “shocked” by Jenny’s face something that 90 Day Fiancé added to give some value to 90 Day Bares All?

Next: 90 Day Fiancé: Who Was Jenny Slatten's Ex-Husband Before Meeting Sumit?

Source: Reddit