After part one of the 90 Day Fiancé season 8 Tell-All, rumors of Mike Youngquist and Natalie Mordovtseva’s relationship being staged gained momentum. With their few similarities and plenty of differences, Mike and Natalie were never seen as a pair that would last by TLC viewers. And although Mike and Natalie’s wedding in the finale came as a surprise, even more unbelievable were the events that occurred after he dumped her. Now, Mike and Natalie’s Tell-All appearance on 90 Day Fiancé has given fans more chances to call their romance “fake.”

With heads butting in nearly every episode and Natalie trying to change Mike’s stubborn ways, the 90 Day Fiancé couple’s relationship reeked of toxicity. While season 7 had ended on a ring tossing note, season 8 at least saw some bouts of happiness amidst Mike’s indecisiveness. But Mike breaking up with Natalie on the morning of their wedding was seen as an unforgivable move, one which was also addressed on the Tell-All. However, despite the death stares that Natalie gave to every 90 Day Fiancé co-star, and Mike, some fans thought they could see right through their fakery.

Related: 90 Day Fiance: Mike Youngquist Shows Off New Ride After Natalie Spilt

It was odd for 90 Day Fiancé fans to see Tell-All host Shaun Robinson declare that she was “shocked” and “really surprised” to find out Mike and Natalie were “still together” after their season 7 debauchery. And when asked to rank things on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being awful and 10 being great, Natalie sighed, looked at Mike, and said “six,” while he said “seven.” Shaun then tried her best to get Natalie to spill the beans on what had gone wrong, but the 90 Day Fiancé star just maintained the cold attitude and her stubborn stance. Fans were left with plenty of questions unanswered amidst her eye rolls and childish behavior, as one of Natalie’s replies to Shaun’s many questions was also a blunt, “I’m not answering.” A post by @90DayCouple on Instagram saw some interesting observations.

The post had a photo of Mike and Natalie captioned, “Welcome to the 90 Day Fiancé, tell some but not all.” A comment noted, “It was annoying how every time she was asked a question, she kept looking back at Mike. She was never shy about opening her mouth before. You can definitely tell she’s playing an actor in her own drama.” Another angered fan asked, “Why come to the tell-all if you’re not going to tell ALL!” And a different fan noticed how it always looked like Natalie needed “his approval to answer” making it look “like a game like it’s her way of saying, ‘you want me to tell them everything?’”

A major theory about Mike and Natalie’s strange behavior and even more stranger situations on 90 Day Fiancé season 8 is them doing the show for the TLC money. Mike’s debt mentioned in the earlier season wasn’t brought up and neither was Natalie begging him for babies. Then again, Natalie dismissing Mike dumping her entirely, and now, even the fact that he may have cheated to marry him in a heartbeat is being seen as her desperation for a green card. Many fans also believe that 90 Day Fiancé star Natalie’s past experience as an actress (and a good one at that) hints at her having acted through her reality TV storyline with Mike. Could the whole thing have been staged?

Next: 90 Day Fiancé: Fans Upset Mike & Natalie to Star In Happily Ever After

Source: 90DayCouple