Mike Youngquist from 90 Day Fiancé was spotted in the company of another reality TV star right after Natalie Mordovtseva sparked reconciliation rumors on Instagram. Natalie and Mike, who were last seen together on 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After?, have been living in separate states since their split. While Natalie is in Florida and has been spotted multiple times with a mystery man, Mike reportedly has a new girlfriend. But Mike admitted that he wasn’t dating anyone on the Tell-All, while Natalie recently shared romantic photos of them on Instagram, indicating that she hasn’t moved on. Amidst the drama, however, Mike showed up in a selfie with Marcia Brazil.

Although Natalie was consistently hinting at having a new boyfriend via various Instagram shout-outs, it was Jovi Dufren who confirmed she was hanging out with a mystery man during the reunion. Upon hearing that Natalie had someone new in her life, Mike immediately declared that he would be filing for divorce. But there has been no official announcement of the couple getting divorced as of now. Also, Mike was rumored to be dating a new blonde woman, but things supposedly went sour between them, and the ex-girlfriend revealed some shocking texts they exchanged.

Related: 90 Day Fiancé: Mike Busies Himself With A New Catch Amid Natalie Split

Still, what came as a bigger surprise to 90 Day Fiancé viewers was Natalie sharing sweet throwback photos with Mike from four years ago on her page. And within a day’s time, a Reddit user shared a screenshot taken from Marcia’s Instagram page where she posed for a cute selfie with Sequim resident Mike. “Shenanigans is Vegas 🙌🙌🙌 @bigmike90dayfiancé,” read the caption. Marcia famously appeared on Rock of Love with Bret Michaels and later was on Charm School with Ricki Lake. The fan couldn’t believe that the two worlds of “Rock of love and 90day” could collide one day and also noted that it would “be interesting” if Mike and Marcia dated.

Meanwhile, on Marcia’s own post, someone commented, “You and Mike are cute together!” The comment has also been liked by the VH1 star. Marcia is being followed by Mike on Instagram, but she has not returned the favor. It could mean that Mike had a fanboy moment and asked her to pose for a selfie. However, fans are also speculating if Mike, just like Natalie, could become a part of 90 Day: The Single Life. As usual, Mike has been keeping his private life under wraps, and Natalie posting “sweet memories” about him could be taken as a sign of a spin-off brewing.

Natalie and Mike’s storyline on 90 Day Fiancé is one of the most scandalous ones that franchise fans have ever seen. The couple infamously came back for 90 Day Fiancé season 8 despite seemingly breaking up in the season 7 Tell-All. Mike also called off his wedding to Natalie on the day of the ceremony. And with the couple not being divorced yet, nothing can be predicted about what Mike and Natalie are planning to do next.

Next: 90 Day Fiancé: Natalie Reveals Why Mike Can Get Any Girl He Wants

Sources: RedditMarcia Brazil/Instagram