One of the most shocking moments from part one of 90 Day Fiancé season eight Tell-All was Natalie Mordovtseva suggesting husband Mike Youngquist cheated on her the night before their wedding. The TLC couple left their castmates astonished when they walked in separately to the Tell-All set. During the interview with host Shaun Robinson, further secrets about why Mike dumped Natalie on the wedding day came to light. However, Natalie provided fodder for the gossip mills by hinting at Mike cheating on her during his apparent “bachelor party.” Here’s why fans think she’s right.

Troubled couple Mike and Natalie first worried their fellow 90 Day Fiancé cast members by not coming to the Tell-All together. As more icy cold vibes were exchanged between the pair, Mike came clean about how he felt like a “piece of sh*t” for calling off the wedding on the morning of the ceremony. The 90 Day Fiancé star apologized profusely to an emotional Natalie about being under “a lot of pressure,” feeling lost, scared, and “overthinking things.” Sequim resident Mike mentioned how he went down to the river and was gone for “five or six hours,” during which Natalie, in sheer panic, asked Uncle Beau and Tamara about his whereabouts, as his phone was not reachable.

Related: 90 Day Fiancé: Signs Mike Younquist Never Wanted To Marry Natalie

But Natalie later asked Mike, “Were you with someone?” based on Tamara saying he might have left to have a last-minute bachelor party. Mike shocked his fellow cast members by revealing, “Natalie thought I went and cheated on her,” and, strangely enough, some TLC viewers agreed. After Natalie’s newest cheating accusation against her 90 Day Fiancé husband, Twitter saw fans asking why she married him despite knowing he was a cheater. One tweet by @2ndReaction read, “Hearing he was gone 5-6 hrs i Thought Mike went and cheated too!” Another fan, @ChefGibson, chimed in saying, “Mike Cheated with his Hair Cutter!!! remember she asked him out on a date!!” Mike’s disloyalty is also about to be the feature of the couple’s 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? stint, which, as ET explains, will see Natalie worrying  “that he isn't really committed.”

This incident wasn’t the first time Natalie accused Mike of cheating, especially since a similar incident came forth in the season seven Tell-All. Natalie’s bombshell accusation about Mike sleeping with his best friend on the night before her wedding was a topic of one fight in season eight as well. As per Natalie, Mike initially told her Sarah's husband-to-be would be staying at the house as well. But according to him, the plans changed. Natalie called him on the morning of the event, and he picked up the phone from the sofa, “half-naked and stoned,” with Sarah saying, “I’m going to the shower” in the background.

That’s when 90 Day Fiancé star Natalie concluded Mike “spent the night with this lady.” But season eight also saw Mike saying Sarah was more like his sister, as he had known her “for years and years.” But recently, viewers came across more evidence of Mike’s apparent unfaithfulness when a screenshot of a chat between him and a 90 Day Fiancé fan was revealed. The incident had reportedly taken place in December 2020, and Mike also allegedly sent the unidentified woman a nude selfie on her Snapchat.

This is also not the last time 90 Day Fiancé season eight tackles the topic of Mike cheating on Natalie. A preview for part two of the Tell-All has Shaun introducing the audience to Mike’s “close friend” Sarah for the first time. Shaun asks Sarah if anything romantic happened between her and Mike that night, as the rest of the cast looks on. While Sarah may or may not answer in the affirmative, fans feel Natalie should have left Mike when she had the chance, but it may have been the green card that held the 90 Day Fiancé star back.

Next: 90 Day Fiancé: All The Ways Mike Made Natalie Miserable In America

Source: 2ndReaction, ChefGibson, ET