Natalie Mordovtseva might have split up with her 90 Day: The Single Life boyfriend Josh Weinstein as fans caught him flirting with a different 90 Day Fiancé franchise beauty. Natalie, who is from Ukraine, married Mike Youngquist, from Sequim, in 90 Day Fiancé season 8. Natalie and Mike’s relationship was short-lived, after which she moved to Florida and started looking for a fourth husband. Natalie dated around until she met Josh, the CEO of a modeling agency in California, at a work event. Sparks flew, and Natalie found herself in L.A. in 90 Day: The Single Life season 3, where she’s had a one-night stand with Josh and believes she might be pregnant.

However, Natalie and Josh might break up in upcoming episodes of 90 Day: The Single Life because of what fans have seen on Josh’s Insagram. Reddit user cyrtographer13333 shared a very confusing screenshot of one of Josh’s Instagram Stories with fellow TLC viewers. The screenshot shows Josh having reposted an Instagram Story by Jaylyn Davis, who’s a recurring cast member on 90 Day Fiancé herself. Jaylyn, better known as Jenn to fans, is the sister of Elizabeth “Libby” Potthast who has been with the 90 Day Fiancé franchise since 2017. Jenn seems to have done a Q&A session with fans where someone asked her, “You getting w Josh now?! Much better match than Nutalie [sic]!!” To this, Jenn replied, “Damn how’d they find out @hweinsteinent” and he reposted it with a laughing emoji, which could also indicate it's not true.

Related: 90 Day Fiancé: What Natalie & Mike Have Been Up To In 2022 (Spoilers)

90 Day Fiancé Fans Question Natalie & Josh's Relationship

Natalie Mordovtseva and Josh Weinstein on 90 Day: The Single Life smiling with Natalie looking away

Eagle-eyed Reddit user acbosssssss discovered a 2016 photo of Josh with Elizabeth. The photo posted on Josh’s official Instagram has a caption that says, “These people made the March show a huge success. Glad they are in my life.” Libby is tagged in the photo. This confirms that 90 Day Fiancé star Libby and/or her family have known Josh for a long time, even before Natalie entered his life. “Everyday I learn more and more about how MATT Sharp’s production frauds us!” read the top comment by Justletmeatyou.

This does make it look like Natalie and Josh might never have been a real couple in the first place. It’s a small world, but Libby and her sisters knowing Josh personally just doesn’t seem right in any case. Libby has an acting past herself, having acted in shows such as Homeland. Libby’s mom Pamela Putnam is also an actress who has been a talent agency owner and is well-known in the entertainment industry. In that case, Josh, who is the founder and CEO of Preview Models since 2015, could have been running in the same circle as the Potthast clan. Meanwhile, 90 Day Fiancé star Natalie recently confirmed that she’s on the TLC show because she’s an entertainer, and drama sells the best.

Both Natalie and Josh never made their relationship Instagram official. It’s almost as if they never dated but were possibly acting all along. Fans suspect Natalie meeting Mike in the previews and hugging him outside his Sequim home in the previews is also scripted. If Natalie herself has claimed she works hard to “entertain” viewers and that it’s cast members who don’t act “normal” that stay on 90 Day Fiancé, it becomes easier to believe she and Josh were never a real couple in the first place. But fans may wonder if that mean Josh and Jenn are the real 90 Day Fiancé pair that might soon make its way to a new show once reality TV star Natalie and him part ways.

90 Day: The Single Life airs Mondays at 8 p.m. EDT on TLC.

Next: 90 Day Fiancé's Natalie's Best Full-Body Photos After Weight Loss

Source: cyrtographer13333/Reddit