Fans believe that 90 Day Fiancé couple Mike Youngquist and Natalie Mordovtseva may still be together, thanks to the unpredictable nature of their relationship and some interesting clues. When Mike’s Uncle Beau claimed that Natalie was living in Seattle after their separation, fans started sleuthing. They wanted to find out when the breakup happened. After that, Mike and Natalie arrived separately at the Tell-All and also showed signs of moving on via Instagram. However, fans who’ve always branded Natalie a fake thanks to her acting background feel that she and 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? husband Mike may be tricking fans to gain popularity.

While Mike didn't seem happy about Natalie coming to America during 90 Day Fiancé season 8 and even called off their wedding, the pair tied the knot in the finale. While fans read about Uncle Bojangles and his shocking Mike and Natalie split spoiler, both reality stars were roped in for a new TLC spin-off. Since their storyline seems pointless to many fans, people are wondering why they were cast on 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? Was it because of the noise they were making online due to their supposed split?

Related: 90 Day Fiance: Mike Reminds Fans of Beloved Recess Character

Fans first wondered if 90 Day Fiancé star Natalie Mordovtseva had broken up with Mike when she started posting cooking videos from a new kitchen. Rumors that she lived in a new house, separate from Mike, gained traction when Natalie cooked an apple pie with a “special guest” Nicole in a new video. Speculation that the little girl Nicole was the daughter of a new man Natalie could be dating began. Soon enough, the Ukrainian began posting videos from Tampa, Florida. While Natalie being in Florida with a “new man” wasn’t confirmed, TLC viewers soon saw her on a New Orleans trip. A reflection shown in a store video that featured Natalie showed the person filming her. Fans deduced that the person wasn’t Mike Youngquist.

Earlier this week, Natalie, who is participating in the Maxim cover girl contest, asked fans to vote for her on a website. The 90 Day Fiancé celeb’s profile bio mentioned she was a part of “90 Day: The Single Life,” which seemed to confirm her split from Mike. However, Natalie later clarified that “it was a mistake.” Maybe that was just a tactic used by Natalie to get more votes than her 90 Day Fiancé co-stars Julia Trubkina and Larissa Lima and take home the $25,000 prize. After all, Mike’s Instagram showed him playing with the husky Nymeria, who fans thought was Natalie’s dog all along. This threw their relationship status into question.

Natalie was also busy creeping fans out with her weird museum walkthrough video. It featured some intense background music, and some odd expressions to match. However, 90 Day Fiancé super sleuths who’ve been watching every reflective surface in her videos very carefully swore they saw Mike in front of a Naga Buddha sculpture. That person seemed very tall and there’s little chance that Natalie found herself a prospective fourth husband as tall as Mike. Also, a post about Uncle Beau's claims featured a major clue. And on a different post about Uncle Beau's claims, Mike and Natalie's season 8 cast member Rebecca Parrott had commented, "this may or may not be true,"

Is Mike a good actor like Natalie? Have both of them fooled 90 Day Fiancé fans all along? People love drama and Mike and Natalie’s storyline had enough of it to carry them through three seasons. All the talk about their separation is helping them to get attention, even if some of that attention is negative. Their 90 Day Fiancé: Happily Ever After? segments have already been called out for being fake and scripted. However, Natalie has remarked that “unfortunately she cannot say nothing,” because of her contract. Fans will need to stick around for some time to see what's really going on.

Next: 90 Day Fiancé: Everything To Know About Mike Youngquist's Friend Sarah