7 Actresses Who Could Play Wonder Woman in ‘Justice League’

The Amazonian Princess known to mortals as Wonder Woman is set to hit the big screen come Justice League (2015), with much of the character's onscreen success depending on proper casting. We've given our picks for a new Batman, and even The Flash, but Diana is another story. There are beautiful women whose own celebrity prevents suspension of disbelief, and fan-favorites who may have the looks, but lack the skills needed for such an iconic role (Exhibit A: Megan Fox). It's a colossal challenge to cast Wonder Woman, but we've assembled a list of women we think could bring all aspects of the character to the table. Here's our list of 7 Actresses Who Should Play Wonder Woman in Justice League. Morena Baccarin Wonder Woman

Morena Baccarin is no stranger to playing women blessed with otherworldly beauty, as the exotic and sensual Inara Serra in Joss Whedon's Firefly (2002), the last of the Ori in Stargate SG-1, and the leader of an invading alien race in V (2009). Since Diana of Themyscira is a human, not an alien entity, the role would actually be less of a stretch than usual. When Joss Whedon was hard at work on his own Wonder Woman film, the pair's history led many to believe that Baccarin stood a good chance of swapping her luxurious robes for Diana's lasso and bracelets. And it's not hard to see why: the Brazilian-American actress of partly Italian descent is no stranger to the term 'exotic beauty.' Baccarin has since found stability with Showtime's Homeland, so no one's doubting that she could pull off Wonder Woman. Her built-in fan base (and no doubt an endorsement from Whedon) would certainly help sell the casting.

Gina Carano Wonder Woman

Actresses with a knack for hand-to-hand combat (and looks every bit as disarming) are hard to come by, so when MMA fighter Gina Carano was cast as the lead in Steven Soderbergh's Haywire (2011), it didn't take long for Wonder Woman fans to start drumming up support. Carano's performance silenced those who thought her lack of experience would be distracting, and landed her roles in the upcoming Fast & Furious 6, and the all-female version of The Expendables. Could Wonder Woman be next? While she is sure to garner attention from Warner Bros., unless the studio is going for a hard-hitting and brutal action movie, Carano is a long shot. Then again, she and Henry Cavill have recently revealed that they're an item; if we were the suspicious type, we might wonder how they met. Perhaps there's some truth to those rumors of a Wonder Woman cameo in Man of Steel after all... Gemma Arterton Wonder Woman

It's no secret that Gemma Arterton's filmography so far has been less than stellar, critically if not financially. But while the films she's appeared in may have been aiming low, nobody seems to have informed her of that. The most recent example being her role as the titular sister in Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters (2013). Arterton has, so far, made a career out of elevating scripts with strong performances aided by her not-unpleasant looks. But if given a solid character to play - like, say, Wonder Woman, we have no doubt she'd convincingly sell the role. Or at the very least, welcome the challenge. Since the biggest drawbacks to casting established actresses with mass appeal (Jessica Biel, Kate Beckinsale) in the role is the difficulty in suspending disbelief, Arterton is the best of both worlds. She's stood out in problematic blockbusters already, but lacks a role that has come to define her - yet. Bridget Regan Wonder Woman

Casting Wonder Woman may sound like a tall order, but if you ask the online fan communities, Bridget Regan may be the name you hear more than any other. While that tends to be a sign of enthusiasts getting ahead of themselves, in this case the argument is a compelling one. Regan's work on Legend of the Seeker (2008) is the main evidence of her ability to do Diana justice: a medieval-fantasy adventure series casting Regan as the last of her order, in a quest to vanquish evil through swords and sorcery (with a dash of romance for flavor). It's not easy to hold one's own in battle and dialogue, but over the course of the series' two series, Regan created one well-rounded warrior woman. A relative unknown with two years experience playing a similar role could be the direction the studio wishes to take. If Regan wins the role, skeptics should rest easy: Diana is in good hands with this fan-favorite.

Lynn Collins Wonder Woman

Disney's attempt at forming a trilogy around Edgar Rice Burroughs' John Carter may not have turned out like we'd hoped, but it did deliver one convincing 'warrior princess.' Credit Collins for that, as her portrayal of deadly princess of Mars Dejah Thoris brought her onto our WW radar. Some comic fans may be skeptical, but a viewing of John Carter should silence critics, as she has essentially already played Diana once. But it's the range Collins has shown in recent years, as warrior princess, and love interest to both Joseph Gordon Levitt in Uncertainty (2009) and Hugh Jackman's Wolverine that convince us she'd be up for whatever take on Diana Warner Bros. and DC have in mind. Collins' age may be the only reason for concern, even if she consistently plays younger women. However, an older Wonder Woman might help seeing Superman and Batman defer to her judgement seem more believable to audiences...

Jaimie Alexander Wonder Woman

It may seem obvious to claim that Jaimie Alexander - the only female god-like being on Marvel's side - would be a perfect Wonder Woman, but the way Lady Sif meshed beauty with battling in Thor (2011) was more than convincing. Alexander's been brought up in the past as a potential Diana, but her interest decreased, she explained, after some embarrassing attempts at launching the character in recent years. Not exactly an endorsement for Justice League's hopes, but her impassioned argument for strong female role models could turn some heads at DC and Warner Bros.. While her Marvel contract has her optioned for an appearance in both Thor 2 (where her importance will grow) and The Avengers 2, there's no promises so far - especially since Thor 2 won't shy away from killing off characters. That said, we don't know any woman who would choose to play Thor's second-fiddle over the most iconic superheroine in history.

Taylor Cole Wonder Woman

Taylor Cole may be an 'unknown,' but any who saw her on Heroes, The Event and The Glades know the self-described "70% legs" actress is a force to be reckoned with. Physically, she puts other 'toothpick-sized' contenders to shame, while still possessing the looks to make even the Man of Steel tongue-tied. And unlike most models-turned-actresses, Taylor Cole can actually act. And damn well, too. Her previous roles have exhibited every quality Wonder Woman should: wit, smarts, and confidence that is uniquely feminine, but not simply sexual. Take a look for yourselves. A martial arts fan and Junior Olympics volleyball veteran, Cole has the physical stature and authority that makes heroes compete not for Diana's affections, but her approval. If DC and Warner Bros. have serious plans for Diana post-JL, Cole has the time and skills to make them a reality. Wonder Woman Actresses Justice League

That does it for our potential Dianas, but as this collection of Wonder Women proves, who ends up snagging the part will have as much to do with competent acting as the specific direction Warner Bros. and DC intend to take with Justice League, and possible spin-off movies to follow. Which actresses do you think could deliver a live-action take on Wonder Woman? Would they succeed in quieting skeptics and be a crowd pleaser, or just a dream come true for you, personally? Leave your thoughts in the comments. - Follow Andrew on Twitter @andrew_dyce.

"Follow us if you want to live."

430 Comments

Post a Comment

« Previous 1 … 7 8 9

AJ 3 weeks ago

Casting for WW is so absolutely tricky and I don’t envy the casting agents. While Hollywood is not short on beautiful women, it IS short on strong-looking, bankable AND critically acclaimed female actors. Many have already passed the “age region” (e.g. Naomi Watts). Others are already in rival genre flicks (Natalie Portman / Thor). And whoever remotely worthy is left looks too wrong or isn’t the genre actress (Emily Blunt, Kiera Knightley, Carey Mulligan, Ellen Page, etc etc).

If WB is looking to make a serious and intelligent Nolan / Snyder-type Wonder Woman (which I am absolutely hoping they will because JL and DC deserves it, plus they desperately need to set themselves apart from Marvel), then the actress for WW needs to be a strong character actor – not just a pretty face.

Sorry to say the list in this article doesn’t cut it at all and … have not seen any other worthy names in comments. In fact, if nobody in Hollywood can cut it, I’d really much rather they cast a much worthier unknown.

Here are my four suggestions. I personally do not feel strongly that any of them are worthy castings, but have shortlisted likewise because I see the potential in at least two, and the rest for what I feel is their strong physical resemblance (although anyone they cast will require the massive body work before making WW remotely believable).

In my order of preference:
1. Rhona Mitra – Underworld: Rise of the Lycans. IMHO the closest to how WW would’ve looked like. Around the right age look. Has always played rather serious characters, so if WB wants an intelligent Nolan / Snyder WW, she’s a strong candidate. Not sure if she has enough appeal though (although that’s obviously no problem with an amazing script, story & direction; case in point: Man of Steel)
2. Yvonne Strahovski – Dexter Season 7, main recurring (was good too and great chemistry with Michael Hall). With lots of body work (muscle, tone and mass) and generous aesthetic transformation.
3. Olivia Munn – The Newsroom. She’s apparently better known in the comedy genre but her character in The Newsroom is fairly straight and stoic. She is, additionally, sizzling hot. She will likely be able to pull off “serious” but not sure if she is critical-acclaim potential … but who is to say she would even be interested in doing anything so heavy (although The Newsroom tries fairly hard to position itself as intelligent).
4. Alexandra Daddario – Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief. Looks a little young for Diana but to date, as close to looking like WW as Rhona. Acting so-so (unless she’s yet to prove herself).

Reply
AJ 3 weeks ago

Casting for WW is so absolutely tricky and I don’t envy the casting agents. While Hollywood is not short on beautiful women, it IS short on strong-looking, bankable AND critically acclaimed female actors. Many have already passed the “age region” (e.g. Naomi Watts). Others are already in rival genre flicks (Natalie Portman / Thor). And whoever remotely worthy is left looks too wrong or isn’t the genre actress (Emily Blunt, Kiera Knightley, Carey Mulligan, Ellen Page, etc etc).

If WB is looking to make a serious and intelligent Nolan / Snyder-type Wonder Woman (which I am absolutely hoping they will because JL and DC deserves it, plus they desperately need to set themselves apart from Marvel), then the actress for WW needs to be a strong character actor – not just a pretty face.

Sorry to say the list in this article doesn’t cut it at all and … have not seen any other worthy names in comments. In fact, if nobody in Hollywood can cut it, I’d really much rather they cast a much worthier unknown.

Reply
john 3 weeks ago

I don’t know about her acting ability but I feel Ronda Rousey, would be great. Shes definitely got the chiseled body of an amazon and the actual fighting and combat skills to pull off epic battle scenes. Just darken her hair and bam she looks the part. Shes also got the angled chin, like the comic books version with the chiseled jaw.

Reply
BRUCR WAYNE 3 weeks ago

Collins should be play wonder man .. Perfect fit

Reply
BRUCR WAYNE 3 weeks ago

Collins should be play wonder man .. Perfect fit

Reply
BRUCR WAYNE 3 weeks ago

Collins should be play wonder man

Reply
john 3 weeks ago

Also shes got Venezuelan in her blood which is part of the amazonas. What could be more Amazonian than a woman that’s got blue eyes and real Amazonian blood. Oh and she already is one of the boys in real life and can trash talk with the best of them. Hmmm wonder woman trading barbs with bats and sups. Lol. It would be perfect. A woman in an action flick that can actually take a punch, and give 8 back as revenge. I would so pay to see that for once, not all these lame, cheesy fight scenes.

Reply
- Johnny M 3 weeks ago
  
  that must the most uneducated thing i’ve seen here yet. Ἀμαζόνες, (plural) or (singular) Ἀμαζών, refer to Hellenic warriors that have nothing to do with south america!!! Its not referring to south americans!! I find your lack of research truly offensive. Diana is HELLENIC, AND WILL ALWAYS BE HELLENIC! And only a fair skinned Hellenic actor can portray, not some mixed dark skinned person!
  
  Reply
- NLK3 3 weeks ago
  
  The Amazons have nothing to do with the Amazon Forest in South America. I know it’s related to European (Greek) Mythology. Look at the fact that they pray to Hera and Wonder Woman often fights Ares. Not sure what Hellenic is, but I’ll check it out.
  
  Reply
  - Johnny M 3 weeks ago
    
    Ummm I think you replied to the wrong person. I KNOW she’s Greek. By the way ‘Hellenic’ is the anglisized Greek word. In english you guys use the franco-germanic word Greek. But properly its Hellenic.
    
    Reply
john 3 weeks ago

Oh and for those that didn’t know Lynda Carter has Mexican roots which explains her exotic Amazonian look.

Reply
john 3 weeks ago

Must be something in that Amazonian river water ahhhhhhhhhh.

Reply
john 3 weeks ago

Oh and to johnny m I also think Amy dumas [Lita] from WWE would also look good and can pull off her own stunts. But if you really want the proof go look at a copy of the first wonderwoman No.1 January. same jaw line as Rondas and physique. And paradise island is said to be located somewhere in the Bermuda triangle. And how could something that was made by Ares be Greek, if the Greeks feared them. If they were Hellenic[Greek], then wouldn’t the Greeks call them also Greek or consider them part of the Hellenic state? If they were living for over 1000 plus yrs. in central America, doesn’t that make them more American? So in conclusion you are the uneducated one as Diana is not Hellenic, she is a warrior created out of clay, not Greek[Hellenic] but an amazon also. I suggest you figure out the difference between Hellenic warriors[Greek warriors] and Amazonian warriors[made by Ares].

Reply
- Johnny M 3 weeks ago
  
  ok you should stop now because you are making yourself look like a m o r o n. DIANA IS NOT SOUTH AMERICAN!!!My God!!! are you THAT s t u p i d that you can’t open a your eyes to read what I’m saying?! ITS A GREEK WORD!! REFERRING TO GREEK WARRIORS!!! PERIOD!!
  
  Reply
Steve 3 weeks ago

For the TV series currently in development I have a sneaking suspicion they’re going to use Michelle Borth from ‘Hawaii Five-0′. They’ve been using her in more action sequences and even dressed her up in a Wonder Woman-esque costume a few weeks ago for an ep about a roller derby. So it seems like they’ve been showcasing her in a way. The same thing was done when they used a lesser-known actor who had presence in other series and was also a completely unlikely choice for ‘Arrow’. Check her out in ‘Hawaii Five-0′ season 3 ep 18 ‘Na Ki’i’. Do you think she fits the bill?

Reply
DMC 3 weeks ago

Lauren Benanti from go on

Reply
Rosetta Milne 3 weeks ago

Megan Gale an Australian model could definitely play Wonder Woman..
http://images2.beautyheaven.com.au/article_images/0028/0207/megan-gale_article_new.jpg?1350535334

Reply
Karl I. 3 weeks ago

My bet is on Alexandra Daddario getting the coveted Wonder Woman role. By planning a Justice League film first followed by a solo effort, WW is going to be a young rookie. Daddario fits Diana to a tee, isn’t attached to a rival franchise, and is primed for stardom.

Reply
Henry 3 weeks ago

Alexandra Daddario
or
Gina Carano
are the only ones that I have read, that I could agree with.

Reply
john 3 weeks ago

Once again johnny m doesn’t read, I never said Diana is South American. Read again before you post lies. There is no such thing as real Amazonians its just a Greek myth like Zeus. But there is a real place in South America called the Amazon. It was given its name by a Spanish king when he had heard the tales of the battles his men had with strong fierce women warriors. Which turned out to be men. So in actual fact there is a real place that exists with the amazon name and of course its not a Greek mythical place. So if you use your brain you’d realise that the people of this region were referred to as Amazonian. Which makes the females true Amazonianz along with the males. Also you said Diana is greek which she is not, she is an Amazon created from clay. Just like her sisters. But her sisters were created by Ares in the original story. Ares originally created warriors which he called Amazons. So I don’t know why you are confusing Diana with being Greek or a Greek warrior[also referred to as Hellenic warrior] when she is clearly like her amazon sisters. If you did some research you’ll find that the true origins, have been changed since the first appearance. This might be your mistake. Furthermore if you knew what sarcasm was you’d see I was being sarcastic with the south American amazon connection.

Reply
- Johnny M 3 weeks ago
  
  Oh so now y o u are playing the victim after your b u l l s h i t was called. Remember I have screenshots of what you said, so stop pretending like everybody is BLIND!!
  But of course y o u think everybody is s t u i p except for you.
  Ares is a GREEK GOD!! ok?! do you understand that?? Apparently you don’t, because if you did you would have opened a G o d d a m n e d book to see what the facts are!!
  Diana is from a GREEK ISLAND (in actual history it wasn’t an island but on the mainland of Greece; the area now which was invaded by t u r k s. And saying that those words like Ἀμαζών weren’t originally Greek is only making look like a p r o p a g a n d a pusher!! ok? Diana, Themiscyra (Θεμίσκυρα), Αρης (Ares), etc etc etc THEY ARE ALL GREEK WORDS!! ALL OF GREEK ORIGIN!!
  But of course you think everybody is s t u i p except for you.
  Ares is GREEK GOD!! ok?! do you understand that?? Apparently you don’t, because if you did, you would have opened a God d a m n e d book to see what the facts are!!
  What you’re basically saying in your little p r o p a g a n d a rants, (which suspiciously smell like y u g o s l a v i a n p r o p a g a n d a), is like saying someone if physically japanese, that he were born in Tokyo, but he’s not from japan!!!! Or saying that an Icelandic person was born and raised in Grindavík, is clearly physically icelandic, but then turning around and saying that they are not from Iceland!! Are you really going to sit there and pretend like you haven’t been speaking like that?!?!?!!?
  And the MODERN area in south america that was called the Amazon was named that way by politicians in honor of Greeks.
  The ‘amazon’ in south america was named that waY by a spaniard becauase of how the natives there fought – and he TOOK the name from GREEK (OH MY GOD!!) references made by Greek (OH MY GOD AGAIN!) people Diodorus and Herodotus describing the warriors of ancient Greece (OH MY GOD AGAIN!).
  And also before you sound even MORE m o r o n i c, perhaps y o u should go and read and understand to what ‘mythology’ refers!! And go read that the names of Diana’s brethren are GREEK (WHAT A SURPRISE!!). And read archaeological records on what people have found concerning Θερμώδων!!
  So please stop your p r o p a g a n d a-pushing because y o u ‘re not fooling anybody!!
  
  Reply
  - Emily 2 weeks ago
    
    It must take you a very long time to type like t h i s…. are you r e a l l y that b o r e d?
    
    Reply
Ravyn 2 weeks ago

Based on this list, I’ll go for Gemma Arterton. She looks fine with the character and she is bad ass in her own way for example in Hansel & Gretel & Prince of Persia. Those movies are the example that she can do action scenes, fights & stunts. She also looks otherworldly gorgeous too & I think she might be the best choice.

Reply
JG 2 weeks ago

Gina Carano would be my pick, she even sounds similar to the WW voice actress from Justice League.

Reply
Nikki Jameson 2 weeks ago

Out of the seven women mentioned for the role of the Magnificently Beautiful Wonder Woman. I think the untainted Taylor Cole has what it will take to pull off a hit movie. I don’t know much about her other than what I read, but when I seen her photo, I said that is the perfect Diana! She has the look you are looking for to pull it off. I think she is as stunning as the original and that’s saying a lot. You guys need an unfamiliar to play this part in order for it to be a knockout and with Cole’s stellar looks, training, and body structure I truly believe you may have a hit movie. But who am I to say I’m just a fan that grew up watching WW, and all my other super hero’s. Taylor Cole 100%. Good luck and can’t wait to see it.
A fan..

Reply
joeyknuckles 2 weeks ago

Lynn Collins FOR SURE!!! WOW! When we first saw John Carter, it hit me right away. She was basically a Wonder Woman in that movie. A warrior princess for sure. I asked everyone what they thought of her being Wonder Woman and they all freaked. They clearly saw it! Lynn Collins For Wonder Woman Has our support!!!

Reply
Guilherme Ferreira 1 week ago

Alexandra Daddario

Reply
Michael 1 week ago

Cynthia Addai-Robinson or Ellen Hollman. Both know how to use a sword,shield and spear due to the Spartacus series,both are striking in different ways looks wise,both have worn some sort of armor and went through the Spartacus boot camp (which looked incredibly tough) and both have absolutely no issue with being covered in stage gore. If were going to re-invent WW,then lets go with the actual warrior woman take on the Amazonian myth.Either of these ladies playing the part would be a WW that even Superman wouldnt take liberties with.

Reply
naledge 1 week ago

I vote for Morena. Not only is she beautiful. but she can act. I’m a little skeptical on whether she can bring the intensity needed to play Diana, but as I just said she’s a pro.

Reply
ashley 1 week ago

i think that cobie smulders would be a great wonder woman. she can act, and was awesome in the avengers, she didnt even have powers and i think she could bet black window. so just think what she would be like as wonder woman.

Reply
cor2879 1 week ago

Actually there’s another actress that could pull off Wonder Woman perfectly, and that’s Maggie Q (in fact, I think she did voice her on Young Justice). We’ve seen that she’s more than capable of pulling of ar$e kickery, and she’s pretty easy on the eyes.

Yes, from this moment hence, Maggie Q gets my vote for Wonder Woman. If not her, then I suppose Morena Baccarin would be my second choice.

Reply
Ian`182 1 week ago

Taylor COLE!!!!
Taylor Cole!!!

Reply
Brian 6 days ago

Probably the toughest comic book character to cast. I like a few actresses on this list but I don’t think they would pull off Wonder Woman. Lynn Collins is intriguing and given what she did with Dejah, might just have a chance. The perfect blend of beauty and brawn very sexy.

I still think the best choice would be Xena herself, Lucy Lawless. She has proven she can pull off that kind of role. She’s beautiful, smart, strong. It’s perfect. Sure she’s a bit older but that could be worked in easily, making the character wiser.

Reply
Deme 3 days ago

She would be my first choice

Reply
Bamafan 8 hours ago

I vote for Gemma Arterton to play Wonder Woman!!!

Reply