Recent Related Items:

127 Comments


Chris Willhite says:

Someone asked earlier why these seven people? I think the reason may be one of two reasons. I think the first reason was becuase of his rare blood type (which Rosario Dawson’s character had). Second reason, is because of the tax issues. I think he wanted to help people in financial need with the tax man.

Not sure how he would figure out who had health issues AND tax problems.

I still think about this movie and it was more than a week ago I seen it in the theatre.

SO— how many of you all have went back for a second viewing? I think I am returning tomorrow night to see it.

Morris says:

I am planning to see it again on the 15th of March in another country to compare the original with Polish subtitles,

Morris

Helena Booker says:

I cannot believe some people think the human heart weighs half a stone.

11 OUNCES IS NOT 5-8 POOUNDS. Never heard of when a baby is born and weighs (for example) 6 pounds 7 ounces?

It is a reference to both the amount of people he helped, and NOT the taming of the shrew, it was the Merchant of Venice.

Uneducated people.

I loved the film, i thought it was Will Smiths best performance yet. Those who didn’t see the point, thought it was just depressing, or thought it was only the last ten minutes worth watching obviously didn’t really understand it.

Kerry Anne Hogg says:

Yes, The Merchant of Venice is correct. A mistake made by some, including myself. Just a pity that certain people on here have to throw their weight around being opinionated & a tad pompous when all this group was meant for was to give different opinions on the film. Cinema is an art…..some people feel something; others don’t. That doesn’t mean they don’t “get it”; it just means it didn’t say to them what it said to others.

I really look forward to hearing many other takes on this film, be they positive or negative or indifferent; just not domineering & opinionated.

Victor says:

I am speechless.

Mark D. says:

I loved this movie. Pretty much what everyone else said it took a little while to catch on but once I did I realized how good it was. Can’t wait to add this to the DVD collection.

Nicole says:

WOW!!! I really procrastinated to see this one cuz I heard it was a tear jerker and couldn’t bring myself to see it. Finally plucked up the courage today and…WOW!! Will is great…as he always will be! My husband’s reaction was “he should have just gotten counselling!!” lol…but seriously, this film moves you to the core and seems to challenge your own sense of selflessness…great job Will!!

René says:

I everyone, i’ve seen the film a few weeks ago and i’m still puzzled!

I remember hearing Will Smith saying to Oprah Winfrey: Making people happy can make yourself happy….but that was a bit too much.

I don’t understand why he was sacrifying himself like that. I know, he was really depressed with his accident killing his own family, but….

I was trying to see what they are trying to tell me but i don’t understand it…

I might go back for a second time to understand it better!!!

Have a nice day!

DaveS says:

Well – I thought this movie was COMPLETELY obvious as to what was going to happen in the end. I mean – anyone watching the first few minutes would note – hes calling 911, something obviously happened to distress him in the past. Hmmm Jelly fish in the room with him… geee wonder if hes going to use that… You can gather what is going to happen in the first 15 minutes of the movie and another 90 for the obvious to play out. Only thing I didnt know was about the stolen credentials from his brother.. but that didnt matter – just made me think worse of Will’s character, Tim. Im sorry, because I love Will Smith, he does do a great job, but this movie was just too obvious to me. I also didnt like the fact we really dont get to know his character. What was he before, good man? maybe. After the accident.. why is there nothing but self loathing. I dont see this as selflessness but more self loathing. He cant stand living with the ACCIDENT he caused? come on – it was an ACCIDENT. You’re going to commit suicide? You think your dead wife would want you to kill yourself or move on, try to get connect with the people left behind whose lives were effected by your actions, find meaning in life, God?? Sorry it just bothered me that he takes no value in his life at all- maybe he could design rollover protection in cars or something to prevent that kind of accident from happening again – I dont know – something more than that. Whatever – it got us all talking though.

Diana says:

To Dave S….
You made some really good points!! An accident is an accident. Instead of commiting suicide, do something good with your life, something relative to the accident – make lemonade out of lemons! He was trying too hard to be a hero for those seven people but in the process needlessly gave up another life -HIS.

Deej says:

I haven’t read all he commentary but noticed so far no one has written of one of the significant points in the movie. He chose to suicide int his way to finish paying back the “seven pounds” he felt he owed (as per the comments on The Merchant of Venice, yes) but it was not just that he felt responsible for seven people’s deaths that lead to his choice. He felt lost and alone without his beloved wife, and had no reason to continue living without her. Yes, especially since her death was (he felt) the result of his carelessness, but absolutely beside that he did not want to live without her.

This is teh reason for his behavior just prior to his suicide…he had fallen in love again (with Emily) and so had found a reason to go on living, finally, for the first time since his wife’s death. But Emily’s chances for a heart other than his were nil because of their rare blood type, so if he didn’t go through with it, she was going to die too. He had chosen to live again because of her…and then he went through with his original plan because she wasn’t going to survive to be with him anyway. That was the ultimately poignant point of the film. To have no reason to go on, find one, and then give up the life you now want to live by chosing death to exchange your life for the life of one you love.

The IRS agent ploy was simply to enable him to get access to information about the people he was screening for help. Some of that could be done by computer, but in some cases he needed to ask them questions in person too. Can you imagine most people just volunteering information to some stranger? But we’re all scared of the IRS, especially when we know we owe taxes –as did Emily and the guy at the nursing home.

jomo says:

i thought the last scene where rosario’s heart makes her cry seeing woody’s eyes was the best moment in the film. that the film was obvious except for the tim-bob relationship is beside the point. the question that the film raised which i found engrossing was the whole value of human life question. is good better than bad, is seven better than one.
while the film had a whole set of problems– most important of which is that the donation system works on a list. you can’t say i will give my eyes to you or my heart to you. rich america will be writing suicide notes for the homeless in a jiffy if that was the case.
i thought the role of smith’s friend the lawyer or whatever was partuicularly unnerving. on the whole the film was ok. engrossing well made well acted sufficient amount of violins in the background to tweak the tear ducts, sufficient big smile with you heart momemts, reasonably cathartic.
i was disappointed that the film maker doesn’t push the ideas of good and bad and deserving further. also, there is no question of bob’s (the irs brother) deserving the kidney other than his blood relation and that he’s a father. smith is a good actor but being his brother doesn’t mean he’s “good”.
still great film.

Deej says:

Actually a kidney donation recipient CAN be specified…it happens often from one family member to another simply because of good tissue matching. I have never heard of it happening in the case of a heart, but if the recipient is one of those at the top of the list and is of an extremely rare type and the heart comes available right next door in the same town, so to speak, it is quite likely to go to that recipient, so it’s not totally far-fetched though it is wierdish. and…uh…most homeless people’s hearts won;t be good matches for most rich people’s bodies, not to mention VERY bad risks as a donor organ considering the conditions their bodies tend to be in.

The part with the eyes was utterly impossible, of course…eyes can’t be transplanted. Only corneas can be transplanted. In other words, Woody’s eyes would be the same eyeball, same color iris, etc…only the clear part at the very front of the eyeball is different. I wish they’d get that straight in movieland…this is not the first time I’ve seen that particular fubar made.

gee says:

I have heard a few times viewing comments, people who say wils character shouldnt have done that etc etc etc, it a film. Critisise the acting etc, not the plot. Maybe in real life it would be better for a man to get over it because it was an accident, but aint that what most people in the world do, go to chuch or something. I respect uniqueness in the world and i think it was a brilliant plot that a lot of people who commit suicide, should take heed of, before they just put a gun to their head or hop off a building. Notice will smiths character in his last 3 films, he wants to die, or is pissed off with his situation. Symbolic of the struggle we face. Last but not least, I think depending on the side of the brain you use most, will determine wether you like the movie or not. I think the side of the brain that is stimulated by cars blowing up, gunshots, blood and guts, is not the same side of brain you use to watch seven pounds. But to me in life, you are suppossed to train yourself to use both sides at will. The matrix movie requires you to use both. So stop being ignorant, you one sided people.

gee says:

My favourite films in the world are the movies that require you to think while the movie is going, and after, and you have to watch it again.
Someone earlier said they knew the whole plot from the start, i find that hard to believe, not saying it is impossible. But to me it was as hard to work out as sixth sense. I thought he wanted to commit suicide but wasnt going to. You know movies, plus i have seen a movie b4 that starts with someone wanting to commit suicide, but they change their mind at the end. If someone can remind me of the title that would be nice.

@gee

So what you’re saying is that it’s OK for YOU to be “one-sided” but it’s not OK for the rest of us to be “one-sided.” Am I reading that right? In other words if our opinion doesn’t agree with yours then we must be ignorant.

Gee, where have I heard THAT before.

And yes, within about 20 minutes I knew exactly where this movie was going. Sorry if you weren’t able to figure it out.

Vic

gee says:

I didnt say it was impossible to know the plot, i wasnt refering to you either, your comments seem intelligent. And where did i say anything about being one sided, I was promoting the usage of two sides of the brain, not one sided thinkers. Point out my one sided views for me, thanks.

jay says:

i think its name 7 pounds cuz thats how much a human heart weighs?

LinJam says:

I watched “7 pounds” and I feel in love with Will all over again, Rosario was wonderful…the entire movie was great, I enjoyed every minute of it. I am not a big fan of movies that sad, or deal with death of sickness. But, with the chemistry that Will and Rasario had; I loved every minute of it. It was Will’s relationship w/all of the people it touched, it seemed as if I was attached to thier emotions. I LOVED IT! Can’t wait to buy it.

LinJam says:

If I may put in my 2 cents about the title “7 Pounds”. In the beginning Ben states that God created the world in 7 days, and his life was shattered in 7 seconds. I think that the title relates to the number of seconds, the number of pounding beats of his heart, his pounding pulse, when he realized that he had lost his fiance, and six other people were dead, because of his carlessness. I think 7 pounds relates to time, moving in time; rather than the number of people he touched or the number of good deeds Ben did. If five people would have died, I still think 7 pounds would have been the title. Weight vs. velocity.

aldith says:

thanks for the info vic!after watching the movie, the title is still puzzling me.. now i know..gracias

Ann G says:

What a awsome movie. I love all of will smiths things and this one is right over the top. Now to answer your question of what 7 pounds stands for. It is a bibical belief from the bible. For a sin of murder you must pay with 7 pounds of flesh.

Jan says:

I did’nt really think of his death as a suicide in the sense he was so devastated, he could’nt live with himself anymore. But rather, a very well thought out, meticulous plan to save the lives of 7 people. Choosing seven for the seven lives he took.. It was the only way he knew to give back life.. If he could have donated those particular organs without dying, if it were at all possible, do you really think he would have still killed himself AFTER the donation? I don’t! What he did was make a sacrifice-his life for seven. Very selfless and profound!!

Jen says:

I also knew where the movie was going to go within the first half hour or so.

I agree that it was a tad slow moving but throughly enjoyable.

The Merchant of Venice reference came right to mind when I was watching the film. but I do agree with another poster that it may be ties to the beating or pounding of his heart/pulse..interesting..

Phoenix says:

I had the same question Melinda Johnson did: why would he chose to die by a jellyfish? It kills you with toxins which go into your blood and heart. Wouldn’t that be a problem for organ transplants? I couldn’t stop thinking about that when they were removing and transplanting his heart. But hey, I’m not a doctor.

I also wondered about the title “Seven Pounds”. It seems the Shakespearean reference from Merchant of Venice makes the most sense to me– someone who must repay a debt is said to owe “a pound of flesh”, hence seven “pounds” he gave to the seven strangers to pay for the lives he took. I thought the movie was OK, not spectacular. I just felt like there were a lot of loose ends. Also I felt like some things were meant to be symbols but instead, they just made the story a bit odd. But I think the overall message is very clear and powerful.

alex says:

reply to karen if you chould whould you donate any organs you to vic?

this movie is good for people who like kind of dramma movies

nevean says:

will smith is a great acter and really deseves
an awward for his movies!

nevean says:

will smith is a great acter and really deserves
an awward for his movies!

nevean says:

just to let you all know i messed up on first mes. so dont tell me about it

alex says:

on a rate of 1-10 i rate 9 now i want youre votes you to vic

Page 3 of 5«12345»
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.