Recent Related Items:

30 Comments


Matt says:

See, again I don’t get it. It’s nice that at least your review is positive instead of being negative because it might not appeal to children. But the fact that you knock a point off because it *might* not appeal to a group that you are not a part of and have no right to speak for is worrisome.

@Matt

LOL, a group I “have no right to speak for”? Um, what? I was at a screening with the public – the film seemed to bore kids, and I think I’m a decent judge of what might appeal to kids and what might not (I do have a daughter). I mean for crying out loud, I gave it 4 1/2 out of 5 stars and you’re giving me grief because of a half star? Thank God I didn’t go lower than that I guess…

Have you SEEN the movie yourself yet?

Yeesh.

Vic

jwalka says:

definitely going to watch it :D , i was a huge fan of the book when i was a kid (used to read it literally everyday at school)
just hope its as good as you say it is :-)

Aaron says:

Excellent. Loved the book and was hoping this movie would do well, even if it is more suited for older audiences. Nice review Vic

Gary says:

Oh yeah,
This one has my name on it!
Thanks Vic!

Ben says:

This book scared me as a child. Great memories though and I hope the film is less frightening!

greenknight333 says:

Thanks Vic!!..Looking forward to this film!!

INK says:

Taking my eight year old daughter tomorrow. I’ll let you know how she liked it. BTW she is really looking forward to it, as am I.

SK-47 says:

Nice review Vic,
I too was wondering what could Spike Jonze possibly to do have a 10 line story be turned into an almost 2 hour film?
Good review, even if it fails, at least it is something different and arftul.

Josh S says:

I’m taking my ten-year-old little brother to go see it today. Very interested in what he will think as he says he does want to see it (and so do I).

@Josh & INK

Please do let me know what they (and you) thought of it!

Vic

Casey P says:

So we have resorted to running experiments? ;)

I’ll be seeing this one with an open mind, and might even take a younger cousin depending on what their young ones think of it!

Thanks for another honest review!

CouponQueen says:

Thank you for the honest review, my kids are looking forward to the movie so we’ll see how it goes. I just ordered the book for them from amazon.com for $9.35. http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0061656860?ie=UTF8&tag=stsolutions00-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=0061656860

twistedburton says:

I’m about to leave right now to go see it!! I’m so excited. I have a feeling it’s going to be one of the best this year

Steve says:

I am moving all day today and tomorrow, I am mad I can’t see it til Sunday! I can’t wait though. Glad you gave it great review, you guys really seem to get it right on reviews.

Five Hens says:

Although this is being heavily marketed as a kid/family movie, I would seriously caution parents of children under 10 (and probably under 13) to avoid this movie or at least be prepared to deal with the issues it raises. The serious adult themes are confusing and inappropriate for little ones. As an adult I found the movie to be quite depressing and a big departure from a beloved children’s classic. Two words: highly disappointed to say the least.

We wrote a full review of the film from a parents’perspective right here: http://www.fivehens.com/where-the-wild-things-are-movie-review/

stpau1y says:

I really loved this movie and I almost cried at the end of it.

greenknight333 says:

I LOVED this movie!! Visually stunning and you could feel the filmakers love for the material with each and every scene. Jonze took the classic book and made a film appropriate for todays audiences. I found it to be very touching and was taken back to what it TRULY felt like to be a young kid again!! I felt that while the themes were mature I felt that kids 8 and older would find it engaging enough. I am glad that Jonze and company didn’t try to dumb any of the themes down and that they respected the fact that kids aern’t stupid and can understand more mature messages that they were trying to impart.
I would highly reccommend this film!! I may go see it again and trust me I don’t get out all that often!!

Longshanks says:

I just saw this movie today,and I liked it.It was very heavy on symbolism,and I wish that the parents that brought their little kids to see this would’ve known that,because this definitely is not a movie for little children.

There were just a few too many kids in the theater talking and carrying on for my liking.Those parents should’ve taken them to see something more appropriate,like Cloudy With A Chance Of Meat Balls,that way the movie would have been more enjoyable,and those talkative kids would’ve enjoyed that movie more.

Michael says:

Great movie…i do give it a 5/5. Being 17 i don’t know how a kid would react but i thought it was amazing

INK says:

@ Longshanks

Uhhh … it’s a kids movie, you should have expected kids to be there. If you wanted to see it without little kids go to the “after 9:00 showing.”

@Vic

Saw it today with the wife and daughter. I liked it a lot. Probably not one I’ll buy, but it was enjoyable. My daughter also liked it a lot. She thought it was funny. I thought they did an excellent job conveying emotion through the creatures.

Longshanks says:

@ Vic

I disagree,I really don’t think it was a kids movie.The themes presented are just to veiled and a bit much for a 5 year old to grasp.Maybe 10 years old and older would “get” it(with a bit of deciphering from their parents),but I don’t see kids younger than that(all the kids I saw in the theater were definitely younger than that) really getting what’s actually going on in this movie other than a kid running around an island with a bunch of talking monsters.There’s obviously way more than that going on here.

I know that there were a few scenes that elicited a seemingly uncomfortable silence from the younger crowd.I could tell that the dirt clod fight didn’t go over too well and neither did the scene where KW helped Max hide from Carol(don’t want to spoil it for those who haven’t seen it yet).Just because it was based on a children’s book doesn’t necessarily mean that the movie is meant for kids as well(when I say kids,I’m talking about those under the age of 12).

Rich says:

Well I guess the reviewer was getting popcorn or something he said Mas was a Only child.Max had a older sister in the movie, his anger over losing her to her new teenage friends is one of the major themes of the movie.The reviewer was correct about it not being for small children but to miss such a huge part of the whole theme of the movie makes me doubt he even watched it.

790 says:

I have 0 interest in this film however I’m not surprised its a tad hardcore.
I remember reading news that WB re-edited the first cut as it was too dark for a family film. Guess there’s only so much they can do to alter a directors vision…

I remember reading this book as a kid. I liked the artwork and it was cool how the kids dreamworld changed his bedroom at night. But I knew they would take it down the Golden Compass path,,,

INK says:

@Longshanks

I agree that it wasn’t a kids movie but they marketed it for kids, therefore kids were going to be there. I was actually a little nervous in parts of the film worried what my daughters reaction to some of the content. She got scared once, but overall she was OK and liked it.

BTW sorry for the last post, after re-reading it today it sounded kinda “jerkish” didn’t mean for that to be the case.

Longshanks says:

Sorry Vic,I was actually addressing INK in my last post.

@ INK

No worries

Aaron says:

Wow, this movie creeped me out more than I thought it would. And im 19

What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.