Recent Related Items:

32 Comments


Ken J says:

The only person I was really psyched about rumored to play Thor was Kevin McKidd, but that’s obviously not going to happen, but it’s ok now that news broke that they are working on a Rome movie. Man that’s going to rock, I hope that pulls through…

ken x says:

If rogers passion was acting…whyd he leave WWE? haha. I cant wait to see who they actually cast for this!

MissSwan says:

Alexander Skarsgård all the way… He definitely has the physique and is also a really talented actor, which is recommended lol… I mean wrestlers turned actors? no thank you…

Manowar says:

Anyone have a clip of this guy in a good acting segment.

His face is a little withered compared to the boyish looking Marvel Thor.

Andy S says:

NO WRESTLERS!

Skarsgard is the ONLY great choice for this role. Everyone else is an also ran.

SK-47 says:

Gotta support our canucks, right Rob!

Rob Keyes says:

That’s right SK-47 ;)

@ Ken J, I’m a big McKidd fan too and I liked the idea back in the day of him playing Thor. Rome is amazing and I can’t wait for the movie either.

Out of the choices we know about, Skarsgård is the candidate I’ve been supporting all along, he’s still my #1 choice.

Alex K says:

I’m not 100% on this.

I was supremely fond of Skarsgård in the role until I saw this wrestler guy.

It’s not that he’s an amazing actor, by far, but let’s face it- It’s a comic book movie about the son of Odin in the modern day. His tongue-in-cheek humour, coupled with the fact he -really- looks the part, even moreso than Alexander Skarsgård, and the fact he’s dying to get the role, in as much to make his own audition “in-character” Much like Brian Austin Green trying for the Green Lantern, I’d say the passion is there, hence it’s more deserved he get the part he so seeks.

SK-47 says:

Yeah Rob, my problem though is that James should make a proper audition tape as Thor. Be in character and act out some scenes taken from some issues. Not this stupid vid on MTV Live.

I only say this because I HATE MTV Canada! Other than the fact that I wanna get with Aliyah or Diane (Rob might know who they are), MTV Canada is complete trash! And I know what it really is, a modern day minstrel show!

Sorry for the rant, but point is, James should do his own audition and have his agent send it immediately to Marvel/Branagh.

Rob says:

Yeah right.

bessie says:

This movie seems a mash-up. Branagh can’t make up his mind or get it together. And…Tom Hiddleston??? Who the hell is he? James Preston Rogers looks ‘good’ in his warrior tats, though. I appreciate Alex K.’s ideas. I agree with Rob Keyes, Alexander has always been my #1. I read that after True Blood wraps Skarsgard will film a comedy in Sweden. It will interesting to read the next chapter on Branagh and Thor.

Ken J says:

Um, MTV anywhere is complete garbage…

Gary says:

I do admire Rogers passion for the role.
We shall see how it shakes out.
It will probably besomebody we know very little about.

Branden says:

We have to take in account that whoever is cast, their chemistry has to gel with RDJ, supposedly Ed Norton as the Hulk, the person who is picked to play Green Lantern (Nathan Fillion), Captain America (Neil McDonaugh)and so on.

I know that Branaugh has a good working relationship with Tom Hiddleston, but nobody knows who the hell he is in the States.

Gary says:

Branden,
Who knew who Christopher Reeve was when Richard Donner cast him as Superman?

Matt K says:

im w/ andy s on that wrestlers are NOT actors, they need to cast someone who is actually an actor

Josh R says:

Bah. Just because he’s a wrestler doesn’t mean he can’t act, and I’m sick of seeing so many people discount wrestlers-turned-actors just because some of them have made less than stellar performances.

Most of you probably haven’t seen Outlander (it had a very limited release), and his role wasn’t that big, but he did a good job and I could definitely see him playing Thor.

If I could choose, I’d probably still go with Skarsgard, but I’d be happy with Rogers. He’s also the only guy anyone has mentioned so far that could play the role tomorrow, what with him already being in peak condintion.

Richard says:

That Tom Hiddleton guy would be horrible, well maybe he could be his gimped alter-ego… IF that WWE guy can in fact act, I think he looks the part and might be bad ass. Im not a fan of WWE and I’m not really sure how many comic fans are so I don’t think its gonna taint the production or anything, I think hes a descent choice.

Stark says:

Whoa!
If you want someone who can act, is built better than my Armor, huge and can scare the crap outta you when he flexes… look back at the WWE… look at ‘HHH” (Triple H! He already is a ‘God of Thunder’! He has the range and humor that is needed. May be to popular tho… Give him an audition! – Stark

Tucker says:

Wow. Just no.

Skarsgard would be my top pick. Though Hiddleston might make an interesting choice.

Longshanks says:

I’m I the only person that’s a bit tired of hearing about who’s gonna be Thor?Just get Triple H and be done with it.

It’s not like it’s really gonna matter anyway.The way most of these comic movies have been going,chances are that we will be disappointed anyway.

Gambit says:

This whole wrestlers can’t act thing is idiotic. Obviously none of you have seen the Hulkster in was it like Mr. Nanny (or something like that..I think I’m right), or all of The Rock’s spectacular films. Hahaha. Okay so there hasn’t been a good Wrestler turned actor yet, but give this Rogers guy a chance. He does have the look, as long as he can pull off the way thor talks then I’m all for it. It is a comic book movie and, as much as I love them, they are more about action and special effects then acting. He can’t do any worse then good old Nick Cage did in Ghost Rider.

Ken J says:

Steve Austin isn’t too bad, but can’t go as far as call his acting “good.”

jago says:

@branden

Green lantern ?… he’s from DC… not Marvel…lol. Can’t believe no one noticed that he wrote that. Anyways isn’t this movie being made by Fox?… and if so… would it really matter who’s casted as Thor if the movie… well you know how fox is. But that’s just me thinking outloud… i do want this movie to do good… the hulk vs thor was awesome so it would be cool to see thor just pounding on loki.

Matt K says:

i do believe its made by MARVEL so they can set up for the avengers.

Rob Keyes says:

@ jago,

Thor is owned my Marvel Studios and that’s how he’ll cross over into the other films and appear in The Avengers.

And I noticed the Green Lantern thing too ;) Didn’t get a chance to comment earlier.

jago says:

ahhhh… thanks rob… should have paid more attention to that one thread where you guys divided all of them to there “rightful” owners.

T.BEAR says:

I really don’t care who plays THOR in the movie, but if he doesn’t look like THOR, it’s gonna suck as bad as the SYFY movie, “THOR: hammer of the gods”.(i know, not based on the comic)But come on, a faux-hawk??? HHH has the look,but i think we’ll all just be expecting him 2 spit water @ Loki. James Rogers looks like he could be a great THOR. He’s definatly got the look.

Richard Alexander says:

Everybody deserves a chance ! I agree with the guy about the Rock sorry agh Rock! You will never appear in a movie with Sly Stallome nothing personal ! Triple H maybe even Lex Luger or The Ultimate Warrior ! Hulk Hogan was good how about the series he had with a few other Wrestlers! He was also in a Walker Texas Ranger Episode ! I would like to submit some Ideas of my own for a Few projects Marvel is doing ! Nicholas Cage did good as Johnny Blaze! Can you do better? Best Wishes to the director ! And of course Marvel and the Man Stan Lee!

michael says:

when can we start to see pictures of chris hemsworth in thor costume

What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.