Recent Related Items:

44 Comments


KEL says:

@Lunar Child

I second that. :)

Larva says:

Give an unknown actor the role. =D

DV real says:

Alright guys look: Superman Returns was a good movie at best, but not a great movie like everyone had hoped. Nevertheless, Brandon Routh has the look (face, ht, wt, etc.) to pull off an exciting new “reboot” regardless of a new cast, directors. He’s about the closest thing to Christopher Reeve we can hope to get….let’s see what happens…could be awesome this time around.

Kevin in Seattle says:

Okay, no offense to those of you who liked Superman Returns, but I thought it was an absoulte steming pile of crap. Routh and the actress who played Lois Lane wre too young to be taken seriously as the characters they were portraying. Superman was supposed to have been gone for five years before the movie and there were allusions made to the fact that it picked up the same story as the Christopher Reeves films. So…how in the heck did Superman and Lois get younger? Not a little “Hollywood” younger, either.
The bigger problem is that Routh simply doesn’t convey the “Man of Steel” on camera. I believed him as the mild-mannered Clark Kent, but that’s only half of the role.

My two cents. I’ll shut up now.

KEL says:

Routh IS Superman:

http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh147/GLKEL/brandon-routh-fanboys-los-angeles-s.jpg

He looks friggin’ huge in that pic. And he’s a few years older now, I think he’s perfect for the part and should play Superman again.

My gripes about Superman Returns were the story (namely them giving Supes a bastard kid and the lack of action!), I thought Routh was fine with what he had to work with, which wasn’t much. Bosworth needs to put on some damn curves, just my opinion.

KEL says:

…and they should not have tried to connect the movie to the Reeve films and just started fresh, dammit!

Malvolio says:

I like Routh as Clark/Supes. he is perfect. Strip away all that was lame from SR, and you can have a good movie:
-New actrees to replace Lois Lane
-No son/kid
-no love interest for Lois
-no LUTHOR! (cripes give us some OTHER Supes villian!!!!
-no Kryptonite!
-No Kumar beats up Superman scene! lol
-Better costume for Supes

chrisj says:

Ive read somewhere that Tom Welling isnt too crazy about the wearing the tights in the final episode of Smallville. Not to mention wearing tights for one more season if was talked about. I rather see Routh countinue to play superman and finish what they started. Because i hate long waits for the right, decent movie to come along. How many years long gap in between Superman Returns, and Superman 4 that came out? Whos wanna wait that long for a reboot?

chrisj says:

Plus, this is a good time to have two hero franchises be connected and pave the way for a team-up film down the road as Marvel is doing right now.

NOTRouth says:

These comments are full of the same people calling, time and again for Routh to reprise Supes….

I’ve got news for all you people.. THAT’S WHY THE MOVIE BOMBED IN THE FIRST PLACE…. the simple fact is, whether or not it’s actually true… Routh looks GAY.. (as in effeminate and homosexual).. regardless of what you clothe him in…

There is nothing manly about about him whatsoever.. and that DEFINATELY is NOT the appropriate image for SUPERMAN. He ‘may’ be a good actor (although his portrayal of Supes first time round certainly doesn’t support this…), but the most famous and recognisable superhero of all time, is not a suitable vehicle for any talents that he may have.

As for Welling, well, …yes!.. quite simply because he looks the part and has a certain gravity (pardon the pun) about him, ALTHOUGH I do feel that he is still to young for such a momentous role, give it 5 years and there would be no one else better suited to play the part.. but can WB really afford to wait.

Given the fact though, that WB are due to lose Supes in 2013 they may try to sabotage the character to make him a less attractive proposition to Marvel and to reduce any licence fees that they may be likely to pay… so they may just go with the stupid and inappropriate choice of Routh.

chrisj says:

@NOTRouth
Brandon Routh wasnt the problem, it was the lack of action in the movie. As for Tom Welling, he doesnt look like it but last time i read about him he was 30 yrs old. Smallville is his thing and thats where people expects him to stay. Just curious of who would you prefer? Before Christopher Reeve was cast, ideas for supes was Robert Redford, Sly stallone, others i thought wouldnt fit the part.

Mike E. says:

what the hell kind of homophobic CRAP is being promulgated on this forum?

Brandon Routh is a model/actor.
He doesn’t look “gay”, or “effeminate”, or anything.. he’s just a good looking dude with good skin. Christopher Reeves was just as “effeminate” as Routh, and no one is complaining about that. He wasn’t any more “masculine” than Routh. Period. Have any of you even WATCHED the original movies recently?

If anything, Routh has a certain masculine quietness that is interesting to watch on film.

chrisj says:

@ Mike E
Couldnt of said it better myself. Both were unknowns when casted to play Superman. I remember Routh being married to a woman so he couldnt be gay. Not that i wanted to get on that issue.

tami says:

Tom Welling seria o melhor superman!!!
as pessoas acham que nao porque só lembram da imagem adolescente que ele deixou.
Além do físico melhor Tom uniu dois ‘’supermans” mais famosos que são Dean Cain e Christopher Reeve.
Chegou a hora de Tom Welling!!!

Page 2 of 2«12
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.