Recent Related Items:

45 Comments


“As far as character development, what do you expect from a 2 hour movie?”

Panda, don’t take this personally, but that’s one of the most ridiculous things I’ve ever heard.

There are literally HUNDREDS of movies (if not more) with amazing character development, many in much less than 2 hours. Hell, you can get decent character development on a 40+ year old half hour episode of The Twilight Zone!

Vic

Panda says:

I’m sure I’ve said much more rediculous things on here before.

But really my point is that there is only so much room for character development in a 120 to 150 minutes. There is not possible way to develop 12 or so Transformer characters and human characters. The main human characters were developed ok, like them or not. The primary beef is that the humans were the focus, which was intentional. It was written for a teenage audience (hence teenagers as the primary focus), and it was successful at it. It angers diehard fans apparently, but it is what it is.

Sure, 22 minute TV episodes can develop a one or two characters really well, but that is typically one open-and-shut story that focuses on that character. But, I disagree that there are many movies that were successful at developing more than four or five characters, particularly action movies because so much of the screen time is action scenes rather than dramatic or character focused scenes.

I’m in a minority regarding this movie I know and no one probably cares what points I’ve made, but I just think there were more positives than negatives. I’d also like to see a lot changed in a sequel that probably won’t happen, but ‘oh well’ – I’m not the one bank-rolling it.

@Panda

“There is no possible way to develop 12 or so Transformer characters and human characters.”

Ah, now I see what you mean. That is indeed a difficult task.

Although they managed to do it just fine in the classic WWII film “The Dirty Dozen.” :-)

Vic

Ken J says:

That’s funny Vic, I was thinking of the same response. You beat me to it, lol.

Panda says:

Point taken… but not enough robots in that one though – j/k

DarkGrittyMovieLover says:

Transformers was a joke, plain, simple, end of story.

Doom3524 says:

Is that because it wasnt dark and gritty?

@DarkGrittyMovieLover

You’ll fit right in here, bud.

Vic

chjonkel says:

Why is everybody trashing the best movie ever made? Not just the special effects but the story too. Cant wait till tf2 comes..

“Why is everybody trashing the best movie ever made?”

ROFLMAO :-D

Vic

Ken J says:

LMAO @ chjonkel

I wonder if you were able to make that joke with a straight face dude. If you did, you deserve an oscar.

tbaffjhjhgft says:

Oi Vic open up the AVP3 comment thing

anyways transformers was pretty good it would be great if it had more bots

High Kalibur says:

I think that, overall, the underlying reason for Transformers turning out the way it did was the target audience. The diehard fans of the old school Transformers are (mostly) 20+ y/o — the film was made too childish in a overzealous effort to capture the 6 and up crowd.

I love when a film succeeds in appealing to the majority of all audiences, i.e. Hook but I see the validity of many points made here as to why Transformers isn’t that great.

I recognize the same root problem, too much time was spent developing it for the children. I can see its aim was at adults and kids but in the adult department it just doesn’t hit its mark.

And… why are we making up Transformers when Soundwave was denied a part in this film? Rhetorical, he is my favorite. At least they had Starscream!

Hopefully, ‘Revenge’ is The Dark Knight of the Transformers. Well… that is probably asking for too much… well it definitely is asking for too much…

Page 2 of 2«12
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.