Top 10 Animated Superhero Movies

by  

"Follow us if you want to live."

175 Comments

Post a Comment

  1. I haven’t read through all the comments but is someone a DC fan? Nary an entry for Lionsgate animation hous eof Marvel movies.And where was First flight on your list.That is what the turdtacular Green Lantern film of 2011 should have been.Had I been making up the list it would have been as follows.
    10.Superman/Shazam
    9.Planet Hulk
    8.Justice League-Final Frontier
    7.The Ultimates
    6.Justice Leaggue-Crisis on two earths
    5.Batman-Under the Red Hood
    4.Green Lantern-First Flight
    3.Wonder Woman
    2.Batman-Dark Knight Returns
    1.Incredibles

    • I included Superman/Shazam because of the awesome Showcase features that used to run with there movies each is a classic and tackles obscure but cool characters like Spectre,Jonah Hex and Green Arrow.

    • has anyone seen Hulk vs. Wolverine?

  2. If Marvel animated Civil War, or Siege, or Dark Reign, or Secret Invasion or Annihilation they would blow DC out of the water. Someone read those stories and tell me they wouldn’t make amazing films! Or the Death of Captain America. Where was Planet Hulk , that was better than Public Enemies, and no All Star Superman?

    • Marvel Civil War would be cool as would World War Hulk and DC vs Marvel. I personally enjoyed All Star Superman, Batman: Under the Red Hood, and Superman/Batman: Apocalypse as they are my favorites.

    • I disagree, not because the story isn’t great, but because Marvel have proven completely inept at turning out quality animated versions of their heroes. DC is miles ahead in that regard. Interestingly the reverse is true when dealing with live action.

  3. Incredibles is kind of a cop out on the list. But Phantasm was legendary, and Red Hood would make for a good storyline in a rebooted Bats.

  4. Batman Sub Zero was awesome, I can’t believe I forgot that. What was the Batman Beyond movie where Tim Drake became Joker. They did the Joker AMAZING in that film.

  5. Justice League: The New Frontier is definitely the best of the DC adaptions that I’ve seen, well other than Mask of the Phantasm. The “Superman/Batman robo-rocket” in Public Enemies is utterly ridiculous. I mean, if you are trying to tell a serious, dramatic story, sometimes you have to edit things like that out…but they didn’t.

  6. Where do you guys rank Batman vs. Punjabi Prince from Pakistan?

  7. Justice League Doom really? It was so uninspired and boring, only nice thing was the animation and the voice cast. At least they put in Wonder Woman, that was such a good film.

    • oh, and I forgot to add Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker. That should be on here, soooo good.

  8. Are you serious? All DC? First of all the first Ultimate Avengers movie was as good as anything up there. Especially some of the weaker movies on the list and anything Wonder Woman is in as the story focus sucks. She just isn’t a central character.

    You have to at least add – Ultimate Avengers I, Dr. Strange (which was a really good movie surprisingly since I didn’t care for the comics) and Hulk Vs. Planet Hulk was OK, but it wouldn’t crack the list.

    Superman vs the Elite WOULD have been one of my favorite movies if they would have been consistent with the ethical dilemma that was the driving point of the first 3/4 of the movie. They really copped out in my opinion by making the anti-hero an actual “bad guy” to justify Superman’s “I don’t kill position”. I was terribly disappointed by them not continuing to explore the “Why do you have the power to permanently stop someone who keeps killing people because you don’t permanently stop them when you have the chance”.

    DC did make some really good Superman movies, the Justice league movies were just OK in my opinion. But then again, DC just has so many more to choose from.

    I don’t think it is fair to include incredibles unless we open it up to all animation which would include Japanese Anime.

    • When it comes to animated movies, DC blows Marvel away. The Avengers (animated movie) was not like a movie, it was more of a two part TV episode.

      Planet Hulk was okay. Dr. Strange was good, but it does not beat Crises on two earths, the weakest of these movies mentioned (have not seen Wonder Woman)

      I do agree with you about the Incredibles though.

    • If Japanese anime is fair game, then put ninja scroll in there. Blew my mind back in the day.

  9. All my favorites were included, Under the Red Hood, Batman/Superman: Apocalypse, Crisis on Two Earths, and The Incredibles.

  10. Wait a minute. “Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker” isn’t on this list? That movie was flipping amazing

    • I was about to post the exact same thing… very disappointed with this list.
      JL Doom should be higher up as well IMO.

      • “Batman: Year One” beats out at least one of the Superman/Batman movies IMO

        • Batman Year One was complete trash,imo.Haven’t seen all those on that list,but even so,it wasn’t good at all.

          • Better than some though. I can enjoy it more than some DC movies

            • I have to agree with Longshanks when it comes to Batman: Year One. It was pretty bad. The graphic novel was good though.

              • I just watched it again. Take back what I said about Year One, you’re both right. It is just bleh :\

    • agreed

    • Totally agreed. Was expecting to see it in the top 5.

  11. “As proof that not all the best Justice League stories are adaptations, Justice League: Crisis On Two Earths has its roots firmly planted in the animated TV series.”

    Sorry, but that is completely incorrect. The origins of this movie WERE in the original comic books, and are based on stories that were printed as far back as 1964, when an alternate Earth then called “Earth 3″ was introduced (based off of the “Earth 1″ of the Justice League and the “Earth 2″ of the Justice Society.) Years later, after one of DC’s universal reboots, the character were re-introduced in the “Earth 2″ graphic novel, which featured the same five characters: Ultraman, Superwoman, Johnny Quick, Power Ring and Owlman.

    And, yes, there are some similarities to the animated Justice League episodes involving the “Justice Lords”, but they came a completely separate storyline in the old Justice League comics.

    • Yeah. It threw me off too when I read that part before. Because that sentence was basically complete BS.

  12. Batman Beyond should have made the list.

  13. How is it that Warner Brothers can make such good animated movies of their heroes, yet, outside of the Nolan Batman movies and somewhat Superman Returns, can’t get their live action heroes off the ground…

    • Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm deserves the #1 spot for sure imo. Batman: Subzero should be considered because in the same year, it was better than Batman & Robin was. They even almost planned on releasing it in theaters but decided against it because of Schumacher’s film. Another that should be mentioned was Batman Beyond: Return Of The Joker Unrated version.

      heres how id list my favorites as i haven’t seen all of them.

      1. Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm

      2. Batman Beyond: Return Of The Joker

      3. Justice League:Doom

      4. Batman:SubZero

      5. Batman/Superman: Public Enemies

      6. Superman:Doomsday

      7. Justice League: New Frontier

    • @ sykora44

      That’s easy to answer. They probly wouldn’t think of to ask Bruce Timm,Paul Dini & Co if they would wanna put together DC’s live-action shared universe since they had such success with animation & know the characters of the comics.

      They’d be people id ask of considering of building a shared universe in making the jump to. Paul Dini knows write great stories as Bruce Timm had his momments & could design the background for sets on films aswell as cotumes.

  14. It’s always amazed me that when the discussion amongst fans arises as to which superhero movie (animated or otherwise) is the best, The Incredibles is never really up for consideration. The stigma of animation as a legitimate form of adult storytelling? I would hope not, but it wouldn’t surprise me.

    To put it another way, The Incredibles is a better movie version of Watchmen than Watchmen was.

    • Yeah, I agree with you. The Incredibles was, well…and incredible movie (lol, sorry I just had to do it). Not only did the movie make sense, but it was something that adults could honestly watch without thinking they were being silly (not that I think I am being silly when I watch animation flicks because I don’t). I go to the movies to check out pixar flicks, and will even tell you that I went to see BRAVE…and I went by myself and didn’t feel silly at all, thank you very much.

      FYI, I read something about there not being an INCREDIBLES 2. I hope that is not true.

  15. I own all the animated feature films that DC and Marvel has created and they are all great in their own right. I will agree that DC trumps Marvel all around but I am a sucker for Planet Hulk. It puts the biggest meanie on earth in a scenario where he isn’t the big guy anymore. Also, JL:TNF should be an honorable mention since it can definitely be a storyline for the live action to learn from.

  16. Very much seconding disbelief at ommision of Return of the Joker…

  17. The only two movies on that list that I haven’t seen are Wonder Woman and The Dark Knight Returns Pt.1, so with that in mind, here’s my list:
    1. The Incredibles
    2. Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm
    3. Batman Beyond: Return Of The Joker
    4. Justice League: Doom
    5. Batman: Under The Red Hood
    6. Ultimate Avengers
    7. Hulk Vs
    8. Justice League: Crises On Two Earths
    9. Batman/Superman: Public Enemies
    10. Batman: Sub Zero

    • And in case the Ninja Turtles are considered superheroes, the 2007 movie ‘TMNT’ would be in there too at the #5 spot.

    • I bought all of the movies on Amazon. I think I grabbed Wonder Woman for no more than $7. Worth it IMO.

    • much better than the original list, but i didn’t like the ultimates.

  18. Return of the Joker was pretty good for its time, but the DCU movies are much stronger, IMHO.

    • now that statement from you, kofi, is one I do agree with.

  19. Why isn’t this just called “Best DC Animated Movies Of All Time”?

    Personally,I think that The Incredibles is easily the best of the list.

    Though they aren’t full movie,rather OVAs,the X-Men and Iron Man animes are pretty awesome,and are better than anything on that list,minus The Incredibles.

  20. Well, I agree with most of people here. Personally I’ve been a big fan of Batman Beyond : Return of the Joker. That was a truly thrilling movie. Apart from that, I also liked All Star Superman, Planet Hulk and Megamind very much.

  21. I thought Doomsday was good, but always wondered what the heck happened to him. After he got done giving Superman the beating of his life, he disappeared! Are the Doomsday and Superman clone halves 2 different movies? Because it’s poor storytelling to introduce an epic enemy only to forget about him.

  22. what happened to planet hulk and batman year one

  23. What about Batman and Superman World’s finest? It is a certified classic!

    • My mistake I was thinking of the Superman animated series world’s finest episode arc. Classic none the less!

      • I’ve been thinking that too through out the whole article. Certainly a classic. I don’t know why it shouldn’t be considered for the list. It was a three part episode and they sold it as a whole movie for a few years afterwards anyway. Besides it didn’t really have much to do with Superman TAS or Batman TAS independently so it was basically an animated crossover movie.

  24. The problem with marvel is that not only are their toons not serious enough, their choice of artistry of their characters in animation form is weak compared to DC. DC art work of their characters in animation (as it pertains to ANIMATED MOVIES) look a little more realistic. This can even been seen in DC games such as INJUSTICE: GODS AMONG US. Marvel’s choice of artistry in their toons and games look like something a 12 year old drew up. However, HULK VS WOLVERINE was an excellent movie. What i did not like about it was that it was too short. Hopefully, marvel will make a sequel to that film. HULK VS THOR was weak IMO. As a marvel fan, I will admit that DC rules the animation and gaming dept. I hope their upcoming movies…MAN OF STEEL AND JUSTICE LEAGUE are awesome (and not comedic).

    sorry for the typos if any

  25. Dang I wanted to hate this list but its more or less on point I think I would put The Incredibles a bit further down the list and put Under the Red Hood at number 1 and Mask of the Phantasm at number 2 The Marvel animated movies are good but put up against DC movies they don’t stand a chance best Marvel animated film so far would be Hulk VS Wolverine and the first Avengers movie. And I saw the new trailer for the Hulk Iron Man animated movie and it looks like Trash!!!!

    • “Batman: Mask of the Phantasm” holds a special place in many Batman fan hearts, due to it being a theatrical animated Batman movie that’s based on the BTAS universe, which was and still is a brilliant cartoon series.

      That, and it’s just a REALLY well done movie

  26. BATMAN/SUPERMAN: APOCALYPSE was nice. the motion of the animated characters looks very real for a toon flick. It’s like the animators made sure they touched on every detail as it pertained to character movements in the film. Example: check out wonder woman and barda’s fight against the furies. The movements of the characters are fluid. Marvel doesn’t do that with their toons. The best art work and character motion of marvel characters in toon form has to be in an old marvel toon called SPIDERMAN AND HIS AMAZING FRIENDS. I was watching some of that particular cartoon series on youtube, and it is awesome. The artwork is well done and the the flow of spiderman whenever he is fighting is just so sharp and clean. Marvel needs to go back to those days of character art and motion. It’s about the details, man.

  27. Its a solid top 10, DC have so many awesome animated films there is always some that will miss out, I love all of them, shocked Batman Year One isnt on it though, I would also add All Star Superman and Return of the Joker to that list, I would move Crisis On Two Earths a bit higher up as well, Batman Under the Red Hood and The Dark Knight Returns are probably my favourites..

  28. I would add the Iron Man anime to this list. Marvel did a great job with the Sons of Yinsen and Zodiac combination, using some great studios in Japan to animate it. Even though it’s a series of shorts, another top one is the Return of Black Adam. The Green Arrow and Spectre shorts are cool. Frankly, the Spectre one SHOULD be a series on primetime, given the 70s vibe and revenge pieces, rather then this CW Smallville and Arrow crap (CW has never had a good series, IMO.) Everyone also seems to forget the HBO version of Spawn these days…

  29. These are all DC comics animated features (save for the incredibles. Hulk V.S.? Hello? can’t have it all now DC.

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.