Comments on: Thomas Jane Talks Perfect Punisher Movie

By: shawn clawson

shawn clawson — Sun, 27 Nov 2011 10:26:35 +0000

Thomas Jane is absolutely right about what the punisher film needs to be and what direction it needs to go… and yes most definitely Jane is Frank castle. .he came closer than anyone to truly bring the castle character to life.. with the right script and the right cast to support and drive the castle character home it could be such a great action movie to remember fondly for years to come

By: Beaux

Beaux — Thu, 03 Nov 2011 22:25:51 +0000

I with you 100% on that but what I’m trying to say is that I think the guys who do Saw are very good at doing gore purely from a skill standpoint and I think they would do a good job. Meaning, I don’t want frank to shoot someone in the head with a 9mm and have their whole head turn to red paint. Also I would like to withdraw my suggestion of James Wan and replace him with Zack Snyder. He’s a bit “fantastical” but I think Zack Snyder + Robert Rodriguez + Marvel Studios = What we’ve been waiting for. But.. I definitely could be wrong. And that will probably never happen anyway.

By: Victor

Victor — Thu, 03 Nov 2011 18:51:03 +0000

First off I am a big punisher fan and its true what Thomas Jane said these movies aren’t really doing the character any good at all, when reading these comments I do fully agree that they should move away from the comic book feel of things and get down to the core. Every body agrees that it should be more hard core. And im trying to see this movie in my head where the passion is clearly noticed through all the chaos. But yet again if you go to like lets say “Kill Bill” or “SAW” kind of gore, then it might happen where the story gets lost and we forget why the character is doing what he is doing. So hoping for a new one and that they can find the correct balance between broken harts and exploding heads.

By: Beaux

Beaux — Mon, 17 Oct 2011 12:22:21 +0000

I know what you’re sayin about jigsaw and war zone but really i think it’s more about bringing the punisher into reality. What i mean is, I love the comics and war zone was pretty faithful to them but christopher nolan will lose me if i see the boy wonder zippin around the city with batman you know? Although Marvel did somehow bring the Avengers together into reality pretty well, including a guy who turns into a giant green rage monster and a norse god. So.. I don’t know, nevermind i said anything. Although the world need a truly great punisher movie no doubt. and i think tom jane is the man for the job.

By: Beaux

Beaux — Mon, 17 Oct 2011 12:14:28 +0000

to follow up on the gore thing, i say that because the comics dont skip on the “head explody”. But it doesn’t need to be super cartoonish like War Zone.

By: Beaux

Beaux — Mon, 17 Oct 2011 12:11:53 +0000

Here’s what I have to say. For some crazy reason Marvel doesn’t have studio rights on the Punisher. WTF Right? I say bring it back to Marvel (seeing how their pretty much blowing up the hero movie, fantastically i might add) and put a good team at the helm. I’d like to see Robert Rodriguez in the producers chair (because I loved what he did with Predators) and as far as director wise, James Wan… I know what you’re thinkin’.. WHAT? I’m basing this on the great (mostly realistic) gore and action of the Saw movies. And the the Kevin Bacon movie Death Sentence. Seriously, I think it would work great.

By: Mantronix

Mantronix — Fri, 24 Jun 2011 00:35:48 +0000

Bigger budget also shoot on location in Italy now thats what many fans would like to see.

By: shane6

shane6 — Mon, 30 May 2011 03:09:19 +0000

I Dont agree with any of you, Thomas Jane was great as The Punisher but Ray Stevenson just nailed the grit and grim side of what makes Frank Castle tick as The Punisher. I think it would be cool if thomas Jane came back as The Punisher cuz we really didnt get to see him fully embrace the role of The Punisher until the last 20 minutes of the movie. My main problem with the 2004 movie was it didnt follow what The Punisher is about there was to little volience Punisher needs to be brutal and come in guns blazing. Johnathan Hensliegh was a terrible director he didnt ever read a Punisher comic until “Welcome back frank” and i think that was the only punisher comic he ever read. He also said he doesnt like voleince, then why in the hell did you want to direct a Punisher movie?
We also as fans Know the Punishers loss of his family and we sympathize with his loss but Frank doesnt cry like a baby and drink instead he puts it behind him and goes out and kills scumbags so no one else has to live his pain or feel it. This is the reason why fans like to read his comics we like seeing Frank kill scumbags who deserve it. If Punisher was a real person O.J. Simpson would be dead already. I know people are going to be mad at me But i been reading The Punisher since i was 8 years old he’s my favorite character ever! Ray is better but I dont think we got to see Thomas Jane fully embrace the character so i would want to see him come back a realistic approach is fine but kill more bad guys next time. Also War Zone may not have had the best script but they nailed Jigsaw if you’ve read the comics you know he’s a former pretty boy for the mob the only thing they changed was he wasnt a hitman first. Howard Saint’s son would have been cool but it wouldnt have been the comic version of Jigsaw. That’s all i have to say.

By: jacob

jacob — Mon, 02 May 2011 23:29:37 +0000

the 2004 punisher movie was truly the real punisher. it’s my favorite movie of all time and I’m a huge Punisher fan. Tom Jane was born to play that part. I also realy like the directors work on it to. But punisher war zone was pathetic. they didn’t fully understand the Punisher. when I first heard that there was going to be another Punisher movie i was so excited I couldn’t believe it. but what I didn’t know at first was that tom jane wasn’t going to be in it. even though i kind of knew that without tom jane it wouldn’t be as good as the first one. but i was still kind of excited. and when I saw it i coudn’t believe it. that thing was a piece of CRAP! there wasn’t even a good story line to it. and the directer was terible. probobly because the director was a CHICK. I mean i’m glad that women can vote and all that stuff, but come on this is man’s work. especialy since it’s Punisher. and there was way to much blood and gore. I knew there was gona be blood but that was way too much. it almost made my friend barf with all the gore. and worst of all. WAY to many f-bombs. Iknow that there were a few in the first Punisher. and that’s perfectly fine. But every time someone talked, its was f that and f this and f you. and it wasn’t even the actors that made the movie bad realy it’s the writers and director. but I still like Tom Jane better. If they make a third punisher it better not be another war zone. It beter at least have Tom Jane and the director Jonathan Hensliegh. But hey punisher still is the best marvel character and movie ever!

By: danja

danja — Tue, 29 Mar 2011 02:41:23 +0000

Punisher war zone destroyed what could have been an awesome set of movies. It annoys me to no end how certain items that are in comic book films are never built upon by subsequent writers. It doesn’t coincide with the comics, but a perfect plot would have been for howard saints son to have survided the explosion at the club and become jigsaw…but nope some idiot writers who never read a comic decided on the crap story. No wonder why thomas jane dropped out. Although warzone was horrible, there is still a chance to make a punisher 2, and just forget about warzone. But for it to be successful, Jane needs to reprise hise role and there needs to be a convincing story. And the punisher needs to be a ruthless conspiring person like the first movie where he pitted the saints against each other, not just some idiot gunslinger.

By: Mantronix

Mantronix — Sun, 22 Aug 2010 23:03:24 +0000

The Punisher needs Jonathan Hensleigh and Michael France back firstly, now I was listening to a radio broadcast. Which had been placed on YouTube, Thomas Jane said he has ideas for a sequel in which will bring about the battle van. A simple and effective story, what they also need is to bring in a villain who is similar to Frank yet will do anything to protect his domain.

For a villain I would like to see Hitman or Bruno Costa, although he is
responsible for Castle family he can easily be brought in. Bruce Willis can easily portray this character, simply related to Travolta Thomas Jane was a thinking man thriller yet the sequel after watching Expendables Hensleigh and France possibly Kurt Sutter will have their work cut out.

Marvel need to invest more money and get producers whom are willing to invest, the production company Valhalla pictures need to put more money into the sequel. The director will be Hensleigh or get a director from a well known movie, such as Precinct 13, Last Man Standing, The Shooter all of these directors can make this movie better.

Also help the audience to comprehend who Frank Castle is, Frank was a military man, then an F.B.I agent, family man and lastly a Vigilante. The points need to be raised, show both his military training and his F.B.I training.

Frank is a skilled combatant both armed and unarmed, the fight scenes have to be believable show various types of weaponry. The person whom I would recommend for the role of Jigsaw would be Jeffrey Dean Morgan Micro Chip Wayne Knight if not Jack Black.

The Budget for this movie without casting should be a minimum of $50-60 Million dollars and take place in N.Y.C. This movie needs to be well written and surprise the hardcore fans, need to pay homage to the creator of the Punisher no more goofy scenes PWZ, the rpg roof top scene and frank jumping of a building and a fence good grief.

Also give Frank Castle a motor bike a Honda or Suzuki or a Bimota, New York is a big place a customised version of each bike would be perfect another thing make the story believable how does Frank go about daily chores he can be killing very criminal, all the time how does he make money and get weaponry, the development of the body armour bring the Daily Bugle to emphasise the Marvel Universe.

Frank is human he misses his family daily, many members of his family are dead due to Howard Saint and his wife Maria Saint. This movie will have to be darker and not make any more mistakes, keep more to the Marvel material but make them work in the real world.

Hopefully this sequel will by-pass the $54,700,105 mark good luck Marvel you need it.

By: Turk

Turk — Tue, 29 Jun 2010 02:51:28 +0000

Here’s what I have to say,

I agree with jane that if they want to make a punisher movie right they need to make it realistic, Sort of like Batman Begins & Dark Knight. What I think anyone should do with it is make it realistic as possible. Why? Because EVERYONE will love it, including critics why does this matter good ratings equals a wider audience which means more money towards the movie which means WE GET A SEQUEL!!! That’s why I honestly think it would be best to make it as realistic as possible. Also I would enjoy it more because I like the Punisher because he’s HUMAN he doesn’t have super powers or even fancy gadgets, he has willpower and a devotion to rid the streets of scum, so that’s why I would like the movie to be realistic I don’t want to see the punisher doing a quadruple backflip off a building while shooting a rocketlauncher at a truck. While that would be awesome I would rather see him take down the truck more realistically IE no quadruple backflips off a building shooting a rocket launcher.

Now then onto who I would want to see as the Punisher. I would prefer Tom Jane as his performance had more emotion and realism, HOWEVER I wouldn’t mind if Ray Stevenson returned as one he looks like the Punisher and two it wasn’t his fault warzone sucked it was a bad script and a bad director he was just making the best of it as he could I’m sure if he had a good script and a good director he could give a good performance (go watch Rome if you don’t believe me) Remember I still PREFER Jane.

Also this is about the villains of the Punisher universe. If you are going to put in Jigsaw do NOT make random scene where he laughs for no reason while breaking mirrors. Jigsaw has no reason to laugh he was a mob hitman who got his face torn to shreds because of the punisher if anything he should be the most pissed off person in the movie besides the Punisher, jigsaw should kill people who even look at him funny. Now in Warzone he was played by Dominic West I’m 100% sure the reason his performance sucked was because of the script/director so don’t be afraid to put him in a Punisher movie but just to be safe make him a detective or an fbi agent. There are several different villains you can put in like Barracuda who should be played by Michael clarke Duncan and if you can’t get him get Terry Crews I know terry is more of a comedy guy but he wasn’t half bad in Gamer. Another villain is Bushwacker for a realistic punisher movie just make him an Experienced mercenary/weapons expert who is hired to kill Frank Castle (punisher).
of course there’s Ma Gnucci a mob leader who wants punisher dead you can easily put her in as well as Maginty and no not like the one from warzone the one from MAX the ruthless Irish mob leader.

Well that’s all I got thanks for reading.

By: Ace the bat hound

Ace the bat hound — Sun, 30 May 2010 07:28:13 +0000

I agree with punfan honestly a lesson can be learned form this that is majority of people dont like goofy comic book stuff even in the current the punisher max comic they’re relatively real like I could see that kind of stuff happening (except frankin castle when that pissed me off really what was marvel thinking). All I want is for some one to bring The Punisher some justice because Thomas Jane was a great Punisher Stevenson was too it was just the script of that movie any one would have sucked as The Punisher in that movie.

By: PunFan

PunFan — Sat, 29 May 2010 20:28:20 +0000

Couple thoughts on making a good Punisher movie:
1. Make it more realistic like Jane described and less cartoonish like ‘War-Zone’.

2. Make it more of a hardened, violent, action-drama similar in heaviness to a Scorsese meets Tarantino film.

3. Integrate elements of ‘Born’ into the film as a backstory. It would be interesting at the end of the film to see if Frank is really motivated by the death of his family or if there’s something more. Kinda gives it a Taxi Driver feel.

By: Mandaloin

Mandaloin — Fri, 16 Apr 2010 10:45:27 +0000

Anyone ever read Welcome Back Frank? Thomas Jane was perfect for that Punisher and the 04 movie got that comic pretty spot-on, while still cutting out a lot of corny stuff I didn't like in it. Ever since I heard about the concept of the punisher (a hero who actually uses guns and kills people who deserve it) I was a fan, and I rented the 04 movie. After watching it I immediately chose it as my favorite movie. I was pretty excited about hearing about Warzone, but after watching it I realized the braincells I wasted watching it were for nothing. That was probably the worst movie I've ever seen. And Ray Stevenson was horrible. A scrawny little guy with a weird voice and no acting skills. Everything about Jane's character was perfect for me. Build (huge, again, read Welcome Back Frank), weapon choice (simple, yet effective), voice and demeanor. I'd love to see Jane try another Punisher movie, and judging by his obvious passion for the character, I think he can pull it off.

By: 009

009 — Wed, 24 Feb 2010 04:13:54 +0000

Forget what “people” wanna see. They have no idea. HOw many of those “people” even read comix anyway? How many could actually imagine a good stroy if they tried? The beauty of the punisher is that hes not a “superhero” hes a vigilante, an anit hero in a heros world. Thats what i love about the Marvel U. There can be these “heros” who save the day and there is still room for the real thing where jus because uve saved the day doesnt mean its all ok. Frank Caslte is human. A guy whos been pushed way over the edge…and now hes pushing back…HARD. WarZone was terrible. One of the worst if not the worst Marvel Movie yet. 1988 Punisher was better. I wish all actors in Marvel movies had the dedication and insite Thomas Jane has. He was right to quit…i mean look at the result. I wouldnt want to have been in WarZone. What an embarresment. Thats not to say Ray Stevenson was bad..jus everything else was. I do like Jane better and i think he deserves it. I hope he can find a way to make it work, and that its a movie that lives up to the name. Its supposed to be Real, Dark. Gritty. Mean. Emotional.
Tense…Bloody. Like the Dark Knight meets Rambo meets James BOnd meets Resevoir Dogs. Tarrantino or Rodriguz should be doing this.. i mean.. its a Punisher Movie Dammit!!!!

By: 009

009 — Tue, 23 Feb 2010 21:21:32 +0000

I agree with Jane also.. and yes his punisher was goofy as well. But it was the first one… im sure its not something he was keen on. ANd if he had his way im sure the next one would be dark serious and all that jazz. Hes not gonna tellt he studio what to do on his first movie. The guy still isnt even Alist..ie no pull. Now he would be in that position. How good are most origin stories anyway?

By: 009

009 — Tue, 23 Feb 2010 20:21:32 +0000

By: PB210

PB210 — Tue, 26 Jan 2010 21:52:20 +0000

Thank you for bringing up the history.

"The character is one you would think would be easy to bring to the big screen: hell, how many movies (The Brave One), TV shows (24) or video games (Max Payne) made since 1974...."

Ah, but keep in mind that the last ten to thirteen years have not treated R-rated adventure films kindly in the US at least. Stallone has had few of his R-rated films in American theaters in the last ten years, as have Seagal and Van Damme.

http://www.miskatonic.org/rara-avis/archives/20...
http://deadpit.proboards.com/index.cgi?action=d...
http://www.jabootu.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID...

By: Ken J

Ken J — Tue, 12 Jan 2010 13:24:38 +0000

I loved The Punisher Stevenson did and those who didn’t go get a tissue or handkerchief and cry into those for goodness sake.

Damn, it’s scary how well you can interchange the names…

Anyway, I agree that Warzone was a pretty crappy movie, but as for the character itself, TOM Jane’s Punisher doesn’t even come close to Ray Stevenson’s Punisher in my opinion. If you don’t like that, go cry into your tissue. lol just kidding.

Tom is short for Thomas. Thom is just weird…

Tom Jane would make a killer Captain America though…